Skip to main content

Gilded Age Americans loved great public shows. World's fairs, monuments and bridges drew millions of visitors and told a story about what the nation was and where it was going. Looking at what those shows included, and what they left out, is a good way to end, because historians have argued ever since about which story of the age is the true one.

The Centennial

In 1876 the United States marked a hundred years of independence with an exhibition in Philadelphia that drew close to ten million visitors. Its star was a machine. A giant Corliss steam engine, two stories high, powered the many machines of Machinery Hall through a network of shafts and belts. Visitors saw typewriters, new printing presses and Bell's telephone. The fair announced the United States as an industrial power, though it opened in a year of depression and in the shadow of a disputed election that would soon end Reconstruction.

A statue and a poem

The Statue of Liberty was a gift from French admirers of American liberty, designed by the sculptor Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi. Its first sponsors had abolition partly in mind, and broken chains lie at the figure's feet. France paid for the statue, but Americans were expected to pay for the pedestal, and the money came slowly. The pedestal was finally funded by small gifts gathered through Joseph Pulitzer's newspaper, the New York World, which printed the names of donors, many of whom gave less than a dollar. The statue was dedicated in October 1886.

Three years earlier the poet Emma Lazarus had written a sonnet called "The New Colossus." Lazarus wrote "The New Colossus" for an art and literary auction held to raise money for the pedestal. Its lines gave the statue a meaning its designers had not chiefly intended: "Give me your tired, your poor, / Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." The poem was nearly forgotten for years and was placed on a plaque inside the pedestal in 1903. Over time it made the statue a symbol of welcome to immigrants, at the very moment when Congress was beginning to restrict who could come.

The White City

In 1893 Chicago hosted the World's Columbian Exposition, marking four centuries since Columbus. Under the architect Daniel Burnham, its planners built a classical dream city of white plaster palaces beside Lake Michigan, lit at night by electricity. More than 27 million admissions were counted. The Woman's Building was designed by Sophia Hayden, the first woman to complete the architecture program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

The fair also displayed the period's hierarchies. Along the Midway, a long strip of amusements, organizers placed villages of peoples from around the world. Critics observed that the Midway's villages were arranged to rank peoples from civilized to savage, with northern Europeans nearest the White City and Africans farthest away. Black Americans were almost entirely excluded from planning the fair, and Frederick Douglass and Ida B. Wells helped produce a pamphlet protesting their absence. The fair opened just as the Panic of 1893 was breaking, so the gleaming city stood beside a city filling with the unemployed.

Robber barons or builders?

How should the age be judged? In the 1930s, amid another great depression, the journalist Matthew Josephson popularized a harsh verdict in his book The Robber Barons. Josephson argued that the great tycoons built their fortunes largely through fraud, bribery and plunder. Historians such as Allan Nevins answered that men like Rockefeller were also industrial statesmen who created efficient enterprises that made goods cheaper.

Later scholars shifted the question. The business historian Alfred Chandler emphasized the rise of salaried managers and new corporate structures, arguing that the visible hand of management in giant firms, more than any single tycoon, was the age's real innovation. More recently Richard White, in a study of the transcontinental railroads, offered a sharper view. White argued that the transcontinental railroads were overbuilt and badly run, kept alive by political favors, and that their failures did great harm to the West. Other historians now stress the age's reformers, its immigrant and Native communities, and its women, and many treat the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era as one long period of argument over how to govern an industrial society.

Worked example: is today a second Gilded Age?

Commentators often call the present a second Gilded Age. Test the comparison. Some features match: very large fortunes, powerful companies that dominate whole networks, worries about money in politics, and new technologies that change work faster than law can follow. Other features differ: the modern United States has an income tax, a central bank, labor laws, antitrust agencies, social insurance and far broader voting rights, all products of the struggles that followed the Gilded Age. A good historical comparison names both the likenesses and the differences, and asks what people at the time did about their problems. The Americans of the 1880s and 1890s did not know how their story would end. Their arguments over who owned the time, the land, the network and the courts are the reason so many of those later institutions exist.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What powered the machines of Machinery Hall at the 1876 Centennial?
2. How was the Statue of Liberty's pedestal finally funded?
3. Why did Emma Lazarus write "The New Colossus"?
4. Who designed the Woman's Building at the 1893 Chicago fair?
5. What did critics observe about the Midway's villages in 1893?
6. What did Matthew Josephson argue about the great tycoons?
7. What did Alfred Chandler emphasize about Gilded Age business?
8. What did Richard White argue about the transcontinental railroads?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia