Every society is a relay in which the runners overlap. At any moment, infants, workers in mid-career and great-grandparents share the same roads, laws and budgets. Decisions made today about schools, pensions, debt and the climate will still be shaping lives long after most of the people who made them have died. That raises a question ordinary politics rarely asks out loud: what does each generation owe the others?
Jefferson's letter from Paris
In September 1789, writing from Paris as the French Revolution began, Thomas Jefferson sent James Madison a startling proposal. "The earth belongs in usufruct to the living," he wrote, and "the dead have neither powers nor rights over it." By usufruct he meant that each generation may use the earth and its fruits but does not own it outright. Working from mortality tables, Jefferson estimated that most adults alive at a given moment would be dead within about nineteen years. Jefferson concluded that no generation should bind the next with debts, or even laws and constitutions, beyond about nineteen years. After that span, the living majority would be a new set of people who had never consented.
Madison replied early in 1790 with a gentle but firm objection. Some burdens are taken on for the sake of those who come later. A debt run up to win independence, or to build works that last, benefits people not yet born, and it would be odd for them to enjoy the gains while refusing any share of the cost. In his words, "the improvements made by the dead form a debt against the living, who take the benefit of them." Madison's point was that debts incurred for lasting benefits may fairly be shared by those who inherit the benefits. He also warned that laws expiring every nineteen years would bring confusion and weaken respect for any settled order.
Burke's partnership
A year later the Irish-born statesman Edmund Burke, attacking the revolution in France, offered a third picture. Society, he wrote in his Reflections, is "a partnership not only between those who are living, but between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born." For Burke, each generation holds an inheritance in trust for the next: it should neither squander what it received nor tear it down in a single season. Critics replied that trusteeship can become an excuse for preserving privilege, since the dead cannot be consulted and their supposed wishes often sound suspiciously like those of present elites.
Two meanings of "generation"
The word generation is slippery. Sometimes it means an age group: the young, the middle-aged, the old. Sometimes it means a birth cohort: everyone born in, say, the 1960s, who will be young, middle-aged and old together. An age group is a stage of life that people pass through, while a birth cohort is a group born at the same time who share one historical path.
The distinction changes what counts as unfair. The American philosopher Norman Daniels argued in Am I My Parents' Keeper? (1988) that since everyone who lives a full life passes through every age, treating age groups differently need not be unfair at all. On Daniels's prudential lifespan account, favoring one age group can be just if a prudent person would choose it when planning over a whole life, much as a sensible person saves in middle age for old age. Cohorts are another matter: if people born in one decade get a worse deal than their parents did, the gap is never evened out.
The Hungarian-born sociologist Karl Mannheim, in a 1928 essay, added a cultural sense of the word. People who meet the same great events in youth tend to form outlooks that stay with them. Mannheim held that a generation is formed by meeting shared historical events at a formative age, not merely by being born in the same years.
An unequal bargain
What makes fairness between generations hard is not only disagreement about values. It is a deep imbalance of power. People not yet born cannot vote, sue, protest or bargain, so the present holds nearly all the power over them. Any arrangement between generations is therefore struck largely by one side, which is exactly the situation in which fairness is easiest to neglect.
Worked example: paying for a water plant
A town must replace its water treatment plant, which will last about sixty years. It could raise taxes sharply and pay the whole cost now, or borrow and repay over thirty years. Jefferson's rule warns against binding later residents for too long, and thirty years already stretches past his limit. Madison's reply supports borrowing: residents twenty years from now will drink the water, so asking them to pay part of the cost seems fair, while charging today's taxpayers for all of it would bill them for benefits many will not live to enjoy. Burke would ask why the old plant was allowed to decay. Daniels's distinction adds a final check. If the town's population is stable, residents pay at every stage of life, and the choice mostly shifts timing. If the town is shrinking, a smaller future cohort will carry the debt, and the bargain becomes harder to defend.
