Skip to main content

Charles called Parliament in April 1640, hoping for money to fight the Scots. Its members wanted their grievances heard first, and he dissolved it after about three weeks, which is why it is remembered as the Short Parliament. Defeat in the second Bishops' War left him no choice, and in November 1640 a new Parliament met at Westminster. It would sit, in one form or another, until 1660, and so it is called the Long Parliament.

Dismantling the Personal Rule

The Long Parliament opened with near unity. Laud was sent to the Tower. Thomas Wentworth, Earl of Strafford, the king's ablest servant and former Lord Deputy of Ireland, was accused of planning to use an Irish army against the king's English subjects. When an ordinary trial looked likely to fail, Parliament passed an act of attainder, a law simply declaring Strafford guilty and condemning him to death. Crowds surrounded Whitehall, and Charles, fearing for his family, signed it. Strafford was beheaded on Tower Hill in May 1641. The king never forgave himself.

A run of laws followed. The Triennial Act of 1641 required that Parliament meet at least once every three years, even if the king did not summon it. Another act said this Parliament could not be dissolved without its own consent. The prerogative courts of Star Chamber and High Commission, which had punished Prynne and other critics, were abolished, and Ship Money was declared illegal.

Why consensus broke

Then the coalition split, and the main reason was religion, above all the future of bishops. Some members wanted to abolish bishops "root and branch", in the phrase of a London petition of 1640. Others thought bishops and the prayer book were the best defense against both popery and chaos, and they were alarmed by crowds, unlicensed preachers and attacks on altar rails. These moderates began to drift toward the king, who now posed as the guardian of the established church. Without that shift Charles could never have raised an army.

In October 1641 Catholics in Ulster rose against Protestant settlers, and thousands of settlers were killed or driven out. Reports reaching London were exaggerated. Everyone agreed an army must be sent to Ireland. The question was who would command it. Many members feared that an army raised for Ireland might be turned against Parliament by the king. The Irish rising thus turned a dispute over the past into a dispute over control of armed force, the question on which any state finally rests.

In November 1641 John Pym and his allies brought in the Grand Remonstrance, a long catalogue of the king's misgovernment since 1625 with demands for ministers Parliament could trust. It passed the Commons by only eleven votes, 159 to 148, after a debate so heated that some members reached for their swords. Its supporters then ordered it printed, which their opponents saw as an appeal over the heads of the king and the Lords to the public.

Choosing sides

In March 1642 Parliament passed the Militia Ordinance, which claimed control of the county militias without the king's assent. Charles replied with Commissions of Array under the old royal authority to muster troops. In June Parliament sent him the Nineteen Propositions, which would have given it a veto over his ministers, his children's marriages and the church. In his answer, Charles warned that the scheme would upset the balance of a mixed government of king, Lords and Commons. On 22 August 1642 he raised his standard at Nottingham, the formal declaration of war.

Most people did not want to choose. Many counties tried to stay neutral, and gentry families sometimes split. Parliament was strongest in London, the southeast, ports and the cloth districts, and among godly Protestants. The king drew more support in the north, the west and Wales, and among those who valued the church as it was. But loyalty, conscience, local rivalry and plain fear all played a part, and no single cause sorted the nation into two camps.

Worked example: the attempt on the five members

On 4 January 1642 Charles walked into the House of Commons with an armed escort behind him at the door. He had come to arrest five members, John Pym, John Hampden, Denzil Holles, Arthur Haselrig and William Strode, on a charge of treason. They had been warned and had slipped away by boat to the City of London. Charles asked the Speaker, William Lenthall, where they were. Lenthall knelt and replied that he had neither eyes to see nor tongue to speak in that place except as the House directed him. The king looked around and remarked that the birds had flown.

Use the ideas above to read this scene. Charles had a legal case of a kind, since treason was a crime and members were not immune from it. But no monarch had ever before entered the Commons in person to seize its members, and to most observers the act confirmed the warnings in the Remonstrance. Lenthall's answer stated a new principle in old form: the Speaker served the House, not the crown. London's trained bands and apprentices turned out to protect the five members. Within a week the king had left London, and he would return only as a prisoner.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why is the Parliament of April 1640 called the Short Parliament?
2. What was the act of attainder used against Strafford?
3. What did the Triennial Act of 1641 require?
4. How did the Irish rising of 1641 change the quarrel in England?
5. How did the Grand Remonstrance fare in the Commons?
6. What did the Militia Ordinance of 1642 claim?
7. What was the main reason the Long Parliament's early unity broke?
8. What did the Nineteen Propositions of June 1642 demand?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia