Each side expected one battle to settle the war. The first major battle, at Edgehill in Warwickshire on 23 October 1642, proved them both wrong: it ended without a clear winner, and both armies claimed victory. The king advanced on London, but in November a much larger force of Parliament's soldiers and the London trained bands stood in his way at Turnham Green, and he withdrew. Charles made Oxford his capital for the rest of the war, while Parliament held London, with its money, its port and its printing presses.
Resources and allies
The king's armies were often better led in the early years, and his nephew Prince Rupert, a veteran of the wars in Germany, made royalist cavalry feared for their charges. Parliament's long term advantages were economic. It controlled the richest region, most of the navy and the customs revenue of London. From 1643 it also introduced new taxes that would once have outraged its own supporters: a weekly assessment on property, and an excise on goods such as beer, meat and salt.
In 1643 royalist victories in the north and west alarmed Parliament enough to seek help from Scotland. The Solemn League and Covenant of September 1643 was the price: a Scottish army in return for a pledge to reform the English church along the lines of the best reformed churches, which the Scots took to mean Presbyterian. The king, for his part, agreed a ceasefire with the Irish Catholic Confederates so that troops in Ireland could be brought over to fight for him. Each side had now pulled the other kingdoms into England's quarrel.
Marston Moor
In early 1644 a Scottish army of about twenty thousand crossed the border. On 2 July 1644, at Marston Moor near York, the combined Scottish and parliamentarian forces defeated Rupert in what was probably the largest battle ever fought on English soil, though estimates of numbers vary. The result cost the king control of the north of England. Much of the credit went to the cavalry of the Eastern Association, commanded by a Cambridgeshire member of Parliament with no military training before 1642, Oliver Cromwell.
Remodeling the army
Victory did not end the war, partly because Parliament's aristocratic generals, the Earl of Essex and the Earl of Manchester, seemed reluctant to crush the king. Manchester is reported to have said that if they beat the king ninety nine times he would still be king, but if the king beat them once they would all be hanged. Cromwell and his allies concluded that the war needed commanders who meant to win.
The answer came in two steps in the spring of 1645. The Self-Denying Ordinance required members of both houses to give up their military commands, which removed Essex and Manchester. Cromwell was a member too, but he was soon exempted and became lieutenant general of the cavalry. At the same time several regional armies were merged into a single national force, the New Model Army, with an authorized strength of about twenty two thousand men under Sir Thomas Fairfax as commander in chief. It was paid more regularly than earlier armies, and promotion depended more on ability than on rank in county society. Many of its officers and men held strong and independent religious views, a fact that would matter enormously later.
The war at home
The war touched nearly every community. Armies took horses, food and lodging, and both sides plundered. Towns were besieged, and some, like Bristol and Leicester, were stormed. In 1645 countrymen in several southern and western counties formed associations known as Clubmen, who tried to keep soldiers of both sides out of their districts. Disease, spread by armies on the march, killed more than battles. One influential estimate, by the historian Charles Carlton, suggests that war and related disease killed a larger share of England's population than the First World War did, and that Scotland and especially Ireland suffered worse. Such estimates rest on scattered evidence and should be treated as rough.
Worked example: why Naseby was decisive
On 14 June 1645 the New Model Army met the king's main field army at Naseby in Northamptonshire. Fairfax had roughly fourteen thousand men, the king perhaps nine thousand. Rupert's cavalry on the royalist right broke the parliamentarian horse facing it and then galloped on toward the enemy's baggage, far from the fight. On the other wing Cromwell's cavalry also won, but they were held together, turned, and fell on the royalist infantry. The king's foot soldiers were surrounded and most surrendered.
Apply the ideas from this level. Numbers mattered, but discipline mattered more: Cromwell's troopers could be rallied and reused, while Rupert's could not. The king also could not replace thousands of trained infantry, while Parliament, with London's money, could. Then came a blow to the king's reputation. His captured letters, published by Parliament as The King's Cabinet Opened, showed him seeking Irish Catholic and foreign troops, which confirmed his enemies' worst fears.
After Naseby the royalist cause crumbled. Fairfax retook the west, Bristol fell in September, and in May 1646 Charles rode out of Oxford in disguise and surrendered to the Scottish army near Newark. The war was over; the struggle over what peace should look like had only begun.
