Skip to main content

The hour a day

Studies of travel from very different times and places have turned up a curious regularity. Villagers walking to fields, Londoners on the Tube and Americans driving to office parks spend roughly similar amounts of time moving each day. The transport researcher Yacov Zahavi noticed this in the 1970s, and the physicist Cesare Marchetti later popularized it. People across eras tend to spend about an hour a day traveling. The pattern is approximate, but it has a powerful consequence: when transport gets faster, cities spread out rather than people simply saving time.

A city of walkers could be only a few kilometers across. Horse-drawn omnibuses and then electric streetcars let cities grow along their lines; the historian Sam Bass Warner described how Boston's streetcar suburbs grew in the late nineteenth century as lines reached into farmland. The car stretched the radius again, so that a metro area like Atlanta now covers thousands of square kilometers. The shape of a city is, in large part, a record of how fast its people could move when it was built.

The city built for cars

Cars offer real freedom: door to door, at any hour, with groceries and children aboard. But they make demands on space. A moving car needs a lane and a parked car needs a space at each end of a trip, so a car-dependent city spends a large share of its land on roads and parking. People who cannot drive, including children, many older people and those who cannot afford a car, are left with poor options. Transport also shapes housing costs: a cheap home far from work can carry a heavy bill in fuel, insurance and time.

What makes transit work

Transit works best where many people live and work close to its stops, and where trains or buses come often enough that nobody needs a timetable. The planner Jarrett Walker argued that transit agencies face a trade-off between ridership and coverage. A fixed budget can run frequent buses on a few busy streets, carrying many riders, or spread thin routes everywhere so that every neighborhood has some service, carrying fewer. Both goals are legitimate, one about efficiency and the other about fairness to people in thinly settled areas, and Walker's point was that a city should choose openly rather than pretend it can have both.

Buses that act like trains

Rail is expensive, and some cities found a cheaper path. Curitiba, Brazil, opened dedicated busways in 1974, and Bogotá, Colombia, launched its TransMilenio system in 2000. Bus rapid transit gives buses their own lanes and stations where fares are paid before boarding, so that loading is fast and buses are not stuck behind cars. These systems carry very large numbers of people for a fraction of the cost of a subway, though TransMilenio's crowding has become a frequent source of complaint.

Why building costs so much

Rail is costly everywhere, but not equally. The first phase of New York's Second Avenue Subway, opened in 2017, cost about 4.5 billion dollars for under three kilometers of track and three new stations. A research team at New York University compared projects worldwide and found that American transit projects are among the most expensive per kilometer in the world, while cities in Spain, Italy, Turkey and South Korea built comparable lines for a fraction of the cost. The researchers blamed oversized stations, heavy reliance on consultants and weak in-house expertise, more than wages or geology.

Paying for road space

Roads in busy centers are scarce at peak times, yet usually free. Congestion pricing charges drivers to enter a crowded area at busy times. Singapore began the first such scheme in 1975; London followed in 2003. Stockholm ran a seven-month trial in 2006, after which residents voted in a referendum. Traffic crossing the cordon fell by about a fifth. Strikingly, public support for Stockholm's charge rose after people experienced the trial, as residents saw streets move. New York began charging most cars nine dollars to enter lower Manhattan in January 2025, the first such program in the United States, amid a legal fight with the federal government. Critics argue that charges fall hardest on lower-income drivers who lack good transit, which is why many schemes spend the money on buses and trains.

Worked example: redrawing the bus map

A city of 400,000 runs forty bus routes, most coming once an hour. Ridership is falling. A consultant proposes ending ten lightly used routes and using the savings to run twelve main routes every ten minutes.

The ridership and coverage trade-off makes the choice visible. Ridership would likely rise, because frequent service lets people simply turn up. But some residents, often older people in outer neighborhoods, would face a longer walk to a stop or lose service. A fair process would name who loses, offer alternatives such as on-demand vans, and let elected officials decide the balance in public. If the city also allowed more homes along the frequent routes, the hour a day would buy residents much more of their city.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. About how much time do people across eras tend to spend traveling each day?
2. According to the level, what happens when transport gets faster?
3. What trade-off did Jarrett Walker say transit agencies face?
4. What does bus rapid transit provide?
5. Which city launched the TransMilenio system in 2000?
6. What did New York University researchers find about American transit projects?
7. What happened to public support for Stockholm's congestion charge?
8. Where did the first congestion pricing scheme begin, in 1975?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia