Skip to main content

On 25 April 799 a procession was making its way through Rome when a band of armed men, led by relatives of the previous pope, dragged Pope Leo III from his horse. In April 799 attackers tried to blind Leo III and cut out his tongue. He survived, accused by his enemies of perjury and adultery, and escaped north. After the attack, Leo III sought help at Charlemagne's camp at Paderborn in Saxony. What followed would give western Europe an emperor for the first time in more than three centuries.

Christmas 800

Charles sent Leo back to Rome under escort and arrived himself in late 800. A difficult question hung over the visit: who could judge a pope? The answer chosen was that no one could, so the pope would clear himself. On 23 December 800 Leo III swore an oath clearing himself of the charges, standing in St Peter's with a Gospel book in his hands. Two days later, at the Christmas mass, Charles was crowned emperor and acclaimed by the Romans present. Leo's attackers were tried and sentenced to death, then sent into exile instead.

Why an emperor, and why then?

Why did a new title matter? Part of the answer lay in Constantinople, where the Roman empire still existed in the eyes of everyone around the Mediterranean. In 797 the empress Irene had her own son, Constantine VI, blinded and ruled alone in his place. The Annals of Lorsch, written close to Charles's court, explained the coronation in exactly these terms. The Annals of Lorsch said the imperial title was vacant because a woman ruled in Constantinople, and that the pope, the clergy and the Christian people therefore thought Charles, who held Rome and the old imperial seats in the west, should bear the name.

The new title had to be worded with care. Charles did not simply call himself "emperor of the Romans," the title used in Constantinople. From 801 Charles styled himself emperor governing the Roman empire, while keeping his older titles as king of the Franks and of the Lombards. The phrasing claimed imperial authority without claiming to have replaced the emperors in the east.

Two other empires

Constantinople was offended all the same. To its rulers there could be only one Roman emperor, and he lived on the Bosporus. Years of tension followed over Venice and the Adriatic coast. In the end a deal was struck. In 812 Byzantine envoys at Aachen hailed Charlemagne as emperor, and in return Venice and the Dalmatian coast stayed with Constantinople. The eastern emperors did not accept that he was emperor of the Romans, only an emperor.

Charles also exchanged embassies with the Abbasid caliph Harun al-Rashid in Baghdad, a common enemy of both the Umayyads of Spain and the Byzantines. Abul-Abbas was an elephant sent to Charlemagne by Harun al-Rashid. It reached Aachen in 802, guided by Isaac, a Jewish member of the embassy who was the only one of the Frankish envoys to survive the long journey. A later Abbasid embassy brought a brass water clock that dropped small balls to mark the hours.

A Christian emperor

Charles and his advisers saw the empire as a Christian commonwealth, a people of God whose ruler was answerable for their salvation. After 800 royal decrees spoke more often of peace, justice and correct worship, and the emperor demanded a new oath of loyalty from his subjects in his imperial name. He did not, however, treat the pope as the source of his power. In 806 he planned to divide his lands among his three sons, but two of them died before him. In 813 Charlemagne had his son Louis crowned co-emperor at Aachen, with no pope taking part. Louis was the only one of the three left. Charles died at Aachen on 28 January 814 and was buried in his palace chapel there.

Worked example: three accounts of one coronation

Three sources describe Christmas 800, and they do not agree on what mattered. The Liber Pontificalis, the official series of papal biographies kept in Rome, puts Leo at the center: the pope crowns Charles with his own hands, and the Romans then shout their acclamation. The Annals of Lorsch, from the Frankish side, stress the reasoning beforehand: the vacancy in Constantinople and the request of the assembled clergy and people. Einhard, writing years later, claims Charles said he would not have entered the church that day had he known what the pope planned.

Each account serves its author. The papal biography makes the pope the maker of emperors, a claim later popes would press hard. The annals make the title a reasoned response to circumstances, decided by an assembly rather than handed down by Rome. Einhard's story of reluctance may reflect modesty, unease at the pope's role or a classical convention, since Roman writers often praised rulers who refused honors at first. Side by side, they show that the coronation was contested from the start, and that the question it raised, whether popes made emperors or emperors protected popes, would echo through the next five centuries.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did attackers try to do to Leo III in Rome in April 799?
2. Where did Leo III seek help after the attack of 799?
3. What did Leo III do on 23 December 800?
4. Why did the Annals of Lorsch say the imperial title was vacant?
5. What title did Charles use from 801?
6. What happened at Aachen in 812?
7. What was Abul-Abbas?
8. How was Louis made co-emperor in 813?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia