Skip to main content

Archaeologists have two kinds of dating. Relative methods put things in order: this layer is older than that one, this pot style came before that one. Absolute methods attach numbers, usually as a range of years with a stated probability. The best chronologies combine both, since numbers without order and order without numbers each leave half the story untold.

Putting things in order

Stratigraphy, described in the previous level's terms of contexts and cuts, is the foundation of relative dating. Typology adds a second line of evidence: objects of the same kind, such as axes or brooches, change in recognizable ways over time. Seriation builds on this by tracking how common each style is. A style typically appears, rises in popularity and then fades, so its share of finds through time traces a shape often called a battleship curve, narrow at both ends and wide in the middle. Arranging assemblages so that every style's curve is smooth produces a likely order for them, even with no dates at all. Fashions in baby names follow the same pattern.

Borrowing dates

Some periods can be dated through history. Coins and inscriptions often carry rulers' names. Imported objects carry dates with them: cross-dating links a site to a securely dated culture through objects traded between them. Egyptian objects found in Aegean sites, and Aegean pottery found in Egypt, helped date the Bronze Age Aegean long before scientific methods existed.

Tree rings

Trees in seasonal climates add one ring a year, wide in good years and narrow in bad ones. Because a whole region shares the same weather, its trees share a pattern of wide and narrow rings. By overlapping samples from living trees, old buildings and preserved timbers, researchers have built master sequences reaching back thousands of years, first in the American Southwest through the work of the astronomer A. E. Douglass, later in Europe and elsewhere. Matching a timber's pattern to the master sequence gives the years its rings grew. If the outermost ring under the bark survives, the year the tree was felled can be known exactly. No other method gives that precision.

Radiocarbon

Radiocarbon dating, developed by Willard Libby in the late 1940s, works on anything that was once alive: wood, charcoal, bone, seeds, shell. It has limits that every user must understand. Atmospheric carbon-14 has varied over time, so raw radiocarbon results must be calibrated against tree rings and other records before they become calendar dates. Calibration can widen a result into a range of a century or more when the curve wobbles. Because so little carbon-14 remains after many half-lives, radiocarbon works only back to about 50,000 years.

Methods have improved greatly. Early labs counted the radioactive decays in large samples. From the late 1970s, accelerator mass spectrometry counted carbon-14 atoms directly and needed only a tiny sample, a few milligrams, so single seeds or a scrap of cloth could be dated. Sample choice still matters. The "old wood" problem arises because charcoal from the inner rings of a long-lived tree can predate the fire that burned it by centuries. Short-lived materials, such as seeds or twigs, avoid this trap.

Light and heat

Some materials store a kind of clock in their crystals. Natural radiation in the ground knocks electrons into traps in minerals such as quartz. Heating empties the traps and releases a faint glow. Thermoluminescence dates the last time a pot or a flint was heated, because firing reset the clock and the traps have been filling ever since. A related method, optically stimulated luminescence, dates when sediment grains were last exposed to sunlight, which resets them the same way. For far older sites, volcanic layers can be dated by the slow decay of potassium into argon, bracketing any finds between them.

Increasingly, archaeologists combine many dates with the stratigraphic order using statistical models. If three samples come from layers known to be in sequence, the model uses that order to narrow each date's range. This Bayesian approach has tightened chronologies for sites from the Neolithic to the medieval period.

Worked example: dating the Shroud of Turin

The Shroud of Turin is a linen cloth bearing the faint image of a man, revered by many as Jesus's burial cloth. Its documented history begins in the 1350s, when it appeared at Lirey in France. In 1988, with the church's permission, a strip was cut from one corner and divided among three laboratories, in Oxford, Zurich and Tucson, each using accelerator mass spectrometry. Control samples of known age were included. The results, published in Nature in 1989, agreed closely and placed the linen between 1260 and 1390 AD at 95 percent confidence.

The result fits the shroud's first appearance in records, and most scientists accept it. Critics have argued that the sampled corner might contain medieval repair threads, or that the measurements were not as uniform as reported; a 2019 reanalysis of the labs' raw data found variation along the strip and called for new testing. Defenders reply that no evidence shows a repair large enough to shift the result by a thousand years. The case shows both the strength of the method, with three labs agreeing blind, and the importance of choosing and documenting samples well.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What pattern does frequency seriation rely on?
2. What is cross-dating?
3. When can tree rings give the exact year a tree was felled?
4. Why must radiocarbon results be calibrated?
5. About how far back does radiocarbon dating reach?
6. What advantage does accelerator mass spectrometry offer?
7. What is the old wood problem in radiocarbon dating?
8. What event does thermoluminescence date?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia