Skip to main content

For most of history, digging up the past meant digging for things. Renaissance collectors filled cabinets with ancient coins and statues. In the 1700s workers for the Bourbon kings of Naples tunneled into Herculaneum, buried by Vesuvius, and hauled out sculptures for the royal collection with little thought for the buildings they smashed on the way. The change from treasure hunting to archaeology came slowly, through a handful of people who began to care about how things lay in the ground.

A trench in Virginia

One early example came from an unlikely digger. In 1784 Thomas Jefferson cut a trench through a burial mound on his land in Virginia and recorded its layers. Many settlers of his time believed the mounds of eastern North America had been built by a vanished race rather than by Native Americans. Jefferson wanted to know how the mound had been made. He saw distinct strata of bones and earth, and concluded that it had grown over many separate burials rather than being raised all at once. He described the work in his Notes on the State of Virginia. It was a small dig, but it treated the soil itself as a document.

Ordering time

Museums faced a different problem: drawers full of objects with no dates. In Copenhagen the curator Christian Jürgensen Thomsen arranged the Danish national collection by material and by the things found together in graves. His three-age system sorted prehistoric artifacts into a Stone Age, a Bronze Age and an Iron Age, and it appeared in a museum guidebook in 1836. His younger colleague Jens Jacob Worsaae took the scheme outdoors: Worsaae tested the three ages with evidence from excavations, showing that the sequence held in real deposits and not only in museum cases.

A second leap concerned how old humanity was. For decades the French customs official Jacques Boucher de Perthes had claimed that stone hand axes in the gravels of the Somme valley lay with the bones of extinct animals. Most scholars scoffed. In 1859 the British geologist Joseph Prestwich and the antiquary John Evans visited the pits and accepted that the tools, found with extinct animals, proved that people were far older than anyone had thought. The same year saw Darwin's On the Origin of Species, and deep time arrived for humans and animals together.

The cost of impatience

Heinrich Schliemann, a wealthy German businessman, began digging in 1871 at Hisarlik in northwest Turkey, convinced it was Homer's Troy. He was probably right about the place, but his method was ruthless. He drove a huge trench through the mound and cleared away upper levels to reach what he thought was the Homeric city. In 1873 he announced the discovery of "Priam's Treasure." Schliemann's trench destroyed many layers, and he assigned Priam's Treasure to a level more than a thousand years older than the age of the Trojan War. His fame also made archaeology popular, which complicates how historians judge him.

Recording everything

Other excavators set higher standards. In Britain the retired general Augustus Pitt Rivers dug on his estates at Cranborne Chase in the 1880s and published thick volumes of plans, sections and drawings. His rule was that every find should be recorded, however ordinary it seemed, because no one could know in advance which details would later matter. In Egypt, Flinders Petrie faced cemeteries of graves with no written dates. He noticed that pottery forms changed gradually, such as handles that slowly lost their function and became decorative lines. Petrie invented sequence dating, which ordered graves by gradual changes in their pottery styles, and he published it in 1899. It was the first systematic version of what is now called seriation.

In the twentieth century the British archaeologist Mortimer Wheeler popularized the box grid. Instead of opening one large area, diggers worked in a grid of square pits. The box grid left standing walls of earth between squares so the layers could be read on their faces. His student Kathleen Kenyon refined the approach at Jericho in the 1950s. Later archaeologists moved toward open-area excavation, which shows the plan of a whole building at once, but the idea that sections must be drawn and kept became standard.

Worked example: Troy dug three times

Hisarlik shows how methods change what a site can say. Schliemann's architect, Wilhelm Dörpfeld, who joined the work in 1882, brought order to it and distinguished a sequence of cities stacked on top of each other, later counted as nine main levels. In the 1930s the American Carl Blegen returned and studied the surviving deposits layer by layer, refining the dates. From 1988 the German archaeologist Manfred Korfmann led a new project that used geophysical survey to look beyond the mound and found traces of a much larger lower town around the citadel of the late Bronze Age.

Each team asked new questions, but each also had less to work with, because Schliemann's trench had removed material that could never be replaced. Later excavators even studied his spoil heaps and the cut faces of his trench to recover what they could. The site still yields evidence, but its story is now partly a story of loss. That is the core lesson of archaeology's history: digging is a one-time act, and the method matters as much as the find.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Thomas Jefferson do with a burial mound in 1784?
2. What did Christian Jürgensen Thomsen's system do?
3. How did Jens Jacob Worsaae strengthen the three-age system?
4. What was accepted in 1859 about hand axes from the Somme valley?
5. What was wrong with Schliemann's dating of Priam's Treasure?
6. Which principle did Augustus Pitt Rivers champion?
7. What was Flinders Petrie's sequence dating?
8. What was the purpose of Wheeler's box grid?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia