Dingane, who took the throne after Shaka's murder in 1828, is often remembered as the lesser brother: crueler, weaker, less brilliant. That reputation owes a great deal to the event that defined his reign, the killing of a Boer leader and his men in 1838, and to the way white South Africans later told that story. Looked at more closely, Dingane faced a problem no Zulu king had faced before: armed, mounted settlers arriving in large numbers and wanting land.
A new king
Dingane promised a gentler rule and at first relaxed some of Shaka's demands, letting some regiments marry. He built a new capital, uMgungundlovu, in the Emakhosini valley, the burial ground of the Zulu royal ancestors. But he also killed rivals within the royal family and faced revolts and defections. He allowed missionaries to visit and dealt cautiously with the traders at Port Natal, whose settlement was growing and sheltering refugees from Zulu rule.
The Great Trek arrives
From the mid 1830s thousands of Dutch speaking farmers left the British Cape Colony with their families, servants and herds, heading inland. Some crossed the Drakensberg into Natal, the fertile country south of the Thukela that the Zulu kings regarded as their own. Their leader there was Piet Retief, who came to uMgungundlovu late in 1837 to ask Dingane for land.
Dingane set a condition. He asked Retief to recover cattle stolen from the Zulu by Sekonyela, chief of the Tlokwa. Retief did so, but he kept the guns and horses he also took from Sekonyela, and he did not hand them over. In February 1838 he returned with about seventy men and their servants. A document dated 4 February, which trekkers later said was a treaty ceding Natal, was apparently marked by the king. Two days later, on 6 February 1838, Dingane had Retief and his whole party seized and killed on a hill outside the capital.
The missionary Francis Owen, who lived near the capital, saw the killings from his hut and described them in his diary, one of the few eyewitness accounts of the day.
Why? Possible reasons include the trekkers' recent defeat of Mzilikazi, which showed what their guns and horses could do; Retief's refusal to hand over Sekonyela's guns; reports that the trekkers were already settling without permission; and a royal decision that the threat had to be stopped at once. Within days Zulu regiments attacked the trekker camps scattered along the rivers below the Drakensberg, killing several hundred people, many of them women, children and servants. The town of Weenen, whose name means "weeping," later grew near the scene.
Ncome, or Blood River
In late 1838 a commando of about 470 men under Andries Pretorius rode into Zulu country. Before the battle the trekkers made a vow that if God gave them victory they would build a church and keep the day holy. On 16 December 1838 they formed a laager, a defensive circle of wagons, beside the Ncome River and fired into the Zulu regiments that attacked it. Estimates of Zulu dead run to about 3,000, while only three trekkers were wounded. The river was said to run red, and the trekkers named it Blood River. The anniversary later became a public holiday, and since 1995 it has been called the Day of Reconciliation.
Dingane abandoned and burned uMgungundlovu. When the trekkers reached it, they found the remains of Retief's party on the hill and later said they had recovered the signed treaty from his leather bag. Some historians have doubted whether the king understood what the document said, and the original was later lost.
Mpande's defection
The defeat shook Dingane's rule. In 1839 his half brother Mpande crossed into Natal with thousands of followers and allied with the trekkers. Early in 1840 Mpande's army, with a trekker commando in support, defeated Dingane, who fled north and was killed soon after. Pretorius proclaimed Mpande king. The trekkers set up a short lived republic, Natalia, but Britain annexed Natal in 1843, and many trekkers moved back over the mountains.
Worked example: one battle, two memorials
Today there are two memorials at the battlefield, on opposite banks of the river. On the west bank stands a laager of 64 life size bronze wagons, unveiled in 1971, honoring the trekkers. On the east bank, the Ncome Museum, opened in the late 1990s, honors the Zulu dead.
For much of the twentieth century 16 December was a public holiday called the Day of the Vow or Day of the Covenant, and Afrikaner nationalists made the battle a sign that God had chosen their people. For Zulu and other black South Africans, the same day marked a massacre and the start of dispossession. After 1994 the new government kept the holiday but renamed it.
The two memorials, facing each other across the water, are a physical record of a history told in two ways. A visitor can walk from one to the other and see how the same few hours became a story of deliverance and a story of loss, and why a democracy chose to hold both rather than erase either.
