Skip to main content

In the autumn of 1918 Germany was losing a war that most Germans had been told it was winning. On 29 September the army's real chief, General Erich Ludendorff, told the Kaiser that the front could break at any moment and that Germany must ask for an armistice at once. Within six weeks the empire of Wilhelm II was gone. A republic stood in its place, born less from a plan than from exhaustion, mutiny and the sudden collapse of the old order.

Mutiny and the councils

In October a reforming liberal aristocrat, Prince Max of Baden, became chancellor, and constitutional changes made the government answerable to the Reichstag. But at the end of the month naval commanders planned a last sortie of the High Seas Fleet against the British. Sailors who saw it as a suicide mission refused to sail. The revolution began with a sailors' mutiny at Kiel in early November 1918, and by 4 November sailors and workers controlled the port. They formed workers' and soldiers' councils, elected bodies modeled loosely on the Russian soviets, and within days similar councils had taken power in cities across Germany.

On 9 November, with crowds filling Berlin, Prince Max handed his office to Friedrich Ebert, leader of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), the largest party in the Reichstag. That afternoon the Social Democrat Philipp Scheidemann proclaimed a republic from a window of the Reichstag, partly to get ahead of Karl Liebknecht, who proclaimed a "free socialist republic" from the royal palace a few hours later. The two proclamations captured the question that would shape the next months: would Germany become a parliamentary democracy or a council republic on the Russian model?

Ebert's bargains

Power passed to a Council of People's Deputies, made up of three members of the SPD and three of the more radical Independent Social Democrats (USPD). Ebert wanted order, food supplies and an elected national assembly, and he feared that Germany would slide into the kind of civil war then tearing Russia apart. On the night of 10 November he spoke by telephone with General Wilhelm Groener, Ludendorff's successor. In what became known as the Ebert-Groener pact, the army pledged to support the new government against radical revolution, and Ebert in return promised to uphold the authority of the officer corps.

A second bargain came on 15 November, when employers led by the industrialist Hugo Stinnes and unions led by Carl Legien signed the Stinnes-Legien agreement. Employers recognized trade unions as bargaining partners and accepted the eight-hour day, while the unions set aside demands to take over industry. In December a national congress of councils voted by a large majority to hold elections for a National Assembly, which in effect chose parliamentary democracy over council rule.

The January uprising

The radical left did not accept that verdict. The Independents left the government at the end of December after troops fired on mutinous sailors in Berlin, and the Communist Party of Germany (KPD) was founded at the turn of the year, with Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht among its leaders. In early January 1919 a mass protest in Berlin turned into an armed uprising, often called the Spartacist uprising after the group the two had led. The SPD defense minister Gustav Noske crushed it using regular troops and the Freikorps, volunteer units of demobilized soldiers led by nationalist officers. On 15 January Luxemburg and Liebknecht were captured and murdered by officers of a cavalry division. Their killers were barely punished, and the bitterness between Social Democrats and Communists never healed.

The National Assembly

Four days later, on 19 January 1919, Germans elected a National Assembly. Women voted alongside men, the voting age was lowered to 20, and turnout was over 80 percent. The SPD won about 38 percent of the vote, the Catholic Centre Party about 20 percent and the liberal German Democratic Party (DDP) about 19 percent. Together these three parties formed the Weimar coalition, with roughly three quarters of the vote. Because Berlin was considered too unsafe, the Assembly met in the small city of Weimar, the home of Goethe and Schiller. In February it elected Ebert as the republic's first president.

Worked example: did Ebert betray the revolution?

Ebert's critics on the left argued that he wasted a rare chance. The councils were mostly led by moderate Social Democrats, not Bolsheviks, and could have been used to democratize the army, the civil service and the courts. Instead Ebert left the imperial elites in place and relied on officers who would later despise the republic. On this view the murder of Luxemburg and Liebknecht was the price of an alliance that poisoned democracy from the start.

Ebert's defenders reply that he faced hunger, an Allied blockade still in force, millions of returning soldiers and a real danger of Russian-style civil war. He needed trained officials to run railways and food supplies, and an army to bring the troops home in order. Democracy, they say, required an elected assembly, not rule by self-appointed councils. A fair judgment can hold both points. Ebert's basic choice for parliamentary democracy was defensible, but he and his colleagues did far less than they could have to reform institutions that stayed loyal to the old order.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did the German revolution of November 1918 begin?
2. What were the workers' and soldiers' councils?
3. Who proclaimed a republic from a window of the Reichstag?
4. Who made up the Council of People's Deputies?
5. What did the army pledge in the Ebert-Groener pact?
6. What did employers accept in the Stinnes-Legien agreement?
7. Which forces did Noske use against the January 1919 uprising?
8. Why did the National Assembly meet in Weimar?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia