Skip to main content

Venice was famous long before it was a tourist destination, and its fame was political. Europeans who wanted a model of stable republican government looked to Venice. Others saw in it a sinister oligarchy of masks and spies. Both images, the myth and the counter-myth, outlived the republic itself, which ended in 1797 without a battle.

The myth of Venice

The classic statement of the myth came from Gasparo Contarini, a Venetian noble, diplomat and later cardinal. His book on the Venetian state, published in 1543 and translated into English in 1599, praised its blend of institutions. Contarini described Venice as a mixed government, combining monarchy in the doge, aristocracy in the Senate and democracy in the Great Council. On this view each element checked the others, which explained the city's stability and freedom. English republicans of the seventeenth century studied the Venetian ballot, and James Harrington borrowed its mix of lot and rotation for the imagined commonwealth of his Oceana (1656).

The myth had a hard side too. The Council of Ten received anonymous accusations through slots in the walls carved as lions' faces, the "lions' mouths", boxes where anyone could drop a secret denunciation. The state's three Inquisitors could arrest, question and punish in secret. To critics, Venice looked less like a free republic than a police state run by old men.

Defying Rome

Venice's independence was tested by the papacy. In 1606 Pope Paul V, angry at Venetian laws limiting church property and the trial of two clerics in secular courts, laid Venice under an interdict, forbidding the sacraments. Venice ordered its clergy to ignore the interdict and keep holding services, and expelled the Jesuits, who obeyed the pope. The friar Paolo Sarpi wrote the government's defense, arguing that a ruler's authority in worldly matters came from God and not from the pope. The dispute was settled through French mediation in 1607 without Venice retracting its laws. Soon afterward Sarpi was stabbed by assassins and survived.

Carnival and decline

In the eighteenth century Venice was poorer in power but rich in pleasure. Carnival lasted for weeks, masked revelers filled the squares, and the state's gambling house drew visitors from across Europe. Carlo Goldoni wrote comedies about merchants, servants and gondoliers in Venetian dialect. Giacomo Casanova, gambler and adventurer, was imprisoned by the Inquisitors in the cells under the lead roof of the Doge's Palace, and in 1756 he escaped from the Leads, a feat he later described in a famous memoir. The republic kept a policy of armed neutrality and avoided the wars of the age.

The end of the republic

Neutrality could not survive Napoleon Bonaparte. In 1797, fighting Austria in northern Italy, his army moved through Venetian territory. Anti-French risings broke out in Verona, and Venetian guns fired on a French ship at the Lido. Napoleon declared war. On 12 May 1797 the Great Council voted to dissolve itself and end the republic, and the last doge, Ludovico Manin, laid down his office. French troops entered the city. A few months later, in the Treaty of Campo Formio, Napoleon handed Venice to Austria in exchange for Austrian concessions elsewhere. The bronze horses of San Marco were carried to Paris; they came back in 1815.

A living city in danger

Today the problems are different. Venice has always sunk slowly and the sea has slowly risen. On 12 November 2019 the tide reached 187 centimeters, close to the record flood of 1966. In 2020 a system of mobile flood barriers called MOSE was raised for the first time to close the lagoon's three inlets during high tides. Meanwhile residents have left. The historic center held about 175,000 people in 1951 and fell below 50,000 in 2022, while tens of thousands of visitors arrive on busy days. In 2024 the city began charging some day visitors an entry fee, a trial meant to manage crowds.

Worked example: was Venice a free republic?

Should Venice be admired as a model of liberty? Its defenders have strong points. It kept the rule of law for centuries, limited the power of its head of state, rotated offices, used secret ballots and avoided both tyranny and civil war. Its laws protected foreign merchants, its courts handled commercial disputes predictably, and its press printed works banned elsewhere. Contarini's admirers saw these as the institutions of a free people.

Critics answer that liberty belonged to a few thousand noble men. Most residents had no political voice, Jews were confined to the ghetto at night, the medieval city traded in slaves, and subjects on Crete or the mainland were ruled rather than represented. The Ten and the Inquisitors watched everyone. A fair verdict holds both truths. Venice showed that power can be divided, timed and checked so that no one rules for long, a lesson republics still use. It also shows that well-designed institutions do not make a government free when most of the people it governs are left outside them. The idea that every person has an equal claim to a voice was not Venice's idea; it came later, and had to be fought for.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Contarini describe the Venetian state?
2. What were the lions' mouths?
3. How did Venice respond to the papal interdict of 1606?
4. What did Casanova do in 1756?
5. What did the Great Council do on 12 May 1797?
6. What did Napoleon do with Venice at Campo Formio?
7. What is MOSE?
8. What happened to the bronze horses of San Marco after 1797?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia