Skip to main content

A white coat, a title before a name, a confident voice on the radio: these are the signs people usually read as expertise. They are not useless signs, but they are not the thing itself. To decide whom to trust, it helps to be clear about what expertise actually is, where it comes from and where it stops.

Competence, not costume

An expert, in the sense that matters here, is someone who reliably gets things right in a particular domain, or does a skilled task well, far more often than most people could. Expertise is a track record waiting to be shown. Credentials such as degrees and licenses are evidence of expertise, not expertise itself. They are good evidence when the institution that grants them tests real skill, and weak evidence when it does not.

Where real skill grows

For decades, two camps of psychologists seemed to disagree about expert judgment. Daniel Kahneman's tradition catalogued the errors that even trained professionals make. Gary Klein's tradition studied firefighters, nurses and military commanders and found their quick intuitions often remarkably good. In 2009 the two men wrote a joint paper, subtitled "A Failure to Disagree," that explained when each picture holds.

Kahneman and Klein concluded that skilled intuition develops only when two conditions are met: an environment regular enough to be learned, and plenty of practice with quick, clear feedback. A firefighter learns how burning buildings behave because buildings obey physics and the results of each decision arrive within minutes. A stock picker or a long-range political forecaster works in a world where luck swamps skill and feedback comes late, if at all, so confident intuitions there deserve less trust.

They gave a pointed medical comparison. Anesthesiologists see the effects of their choices on a patient within minutes, while radiologists often never learn whether a reading was right, so the first group has better conditions for building reliable intuition. The difference lies in the job, not in the people.

Two kinds of expertise

The sociologists Harry Collins and Robert Evans, in their 2007 book Rethinking Expertise, drew a further distinction. Contributory expertise is the ability to do the work of a field and add to it: to run the experiment, perform the operation or write the code. Interactional expertise is the ability to talk about a field fluently and understand its debates without being able to practice it.

Collins tested the idea on himself. He spent decades among physicists hunting for gravitational waves. In a 2006 imitation game, physicists read his answers to technical questions alongside answers from a working gravitational-wave physicist, and most of the judging physicists could not reliably tell which answers came from the sociologist. Interactional expertise is real and valuable. But it is not the same as being able to do the work, and the difference matters when a decision rests on fine technical judgment.

The edge of the map

Expertise has borders. The philosopher Nathan Ballantyne coined the term epistemic trespassing for experts who pass judgment on questions outside their field while relying on the authority they earned inside it. Trespassers are not always wrong, but their credentials no longer vouch for them.

The chemist Linus Pauling is a famous case. He won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1954 and the Nobel Peace Prize in 1962, and he was one of the most gifted scientists of his century. In 1970 he published a popular book arguing that large daily doses of vitamin C would prevent colds, and later he claimed benefits against cancer. Controlled trials found that regular vitamin C does not prevent colds in most people and at best slightly shortens them, and trials did not support his cancer claims.

A fair word for the critics

Talk of expertise can turn into snobbery. Credentials have often been withheld from women, the poor and minorities, so the list of recognized experts has reflected who was allowed in as much as who was able. Farmers, nurses and patients sometimes know things that degree holders miss. These criticisms argue for widening and testing our idea of expertise, not for abandoning it.

Worked example: three voices at a public meeting

A town is debating whether to narrow a busy road to add a protected bike lane. Three people speak. The first is a traffic engineer who has redesigned a dozen similar streets and measured what happened to traffic and crashes afterward. The second is a local reporter who has covered transport for twenty years and can explain the studies clearly. The third is a respected heart surgeon who lives on the street and warns that the change will cause gridlock.

The engineer has contributory expertise, gained in a setting with real feedback: she has seen the results of her own designs. The reporter has interactional expertise and can help the audience understand the evidence, but his own forecast deserves less weight than his summary of others' work. The surgeon is trespassing. His view as a resident who knows the street's daily rhythms is worth hearing, but his medical prestige adds nothing to his traffic forecast. Sorting the voices does not settle the debate, since the town must still weigh safety, convenience and cost, but it shows whose predictions deserve most weight.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How does the level describe credentials such as degrees and licenses?
2. According to Kahneman and Klein, when does skilled intuition develop?
3. Why did Kahneman and Klein think anesthesiologists have better conditions for intuition than radiologists?
4. What is contributory expertise?
5. What is interactional expertise?
6. What happened in Harry Collins's 2006 imitation game?
7. What does Nathan Ballantyne mean by epistemic trespassing?
8. What did controlled trials find about Linus Pauling's vitamin C claims?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia