Skip to main content

Music has been part of theatre almost everywhere: Greek choruses sang, Noh and jingju are built on music, and Sanskrit drama joined song and dance to speech. What English speakers call musical theatre is one particular branch of that family, which grew up in London and New York and has since spread across the world.

Ballad opera and operetta

In 1728 John Gay's The Beggar's Opera took London by storm. The Beggar's Opera was a ballad opera, setting new words to popular tunes that audiences already knew, and it mocked both fashionable Italian opera and the prime minister, Robert Walpole, by comparing politicians to highwaymen. In the nineteenth century, operetta flourished in Paris, Vienna and London. Operetta is light comic opera that mixes songs with spoken dialogue. Jacques Offenbach mocked the court of Napoleon III, and the partnership of W. S. Gilbert and Arthur Sullivan, from HMS Pinafore (1878) onward, delighted audiences with absurd plots and sharp lyrics about class and officialdom.

Minstrelsy and its long shadow

American musical theatre has a painful root. Minstrel shows, in which white performers in blackface caricatured Black Americans, were among the most popular entertainments in nineteenth century America. Beginning around 1830 with acts such as Thomas Dartmouth Rice's "Jim Crow" routine, minstrelsy spread degrading stereotypes that shaped how millions of white Americans saw Black people, and its stock character lent his name to the later system of segregation laws. It also borrowed and distorted Black music and dance. Black performers, shut out of much of the stage, sometimes had to work within minstrel conventions, even wearing blackface themselves, as the brilliant comedian Bert Williams did.

Black artists also built their own road to Broadway. Shuffle Along (1921), written and performed by Black artists, became a major Broadway hit, with songs by Noble Sissle and Eubie Blake, and it helped launch the careers of performers such as Florence Mills and Josephine Baker.

The book musical

Early Broadway shows were often revues, strings of songs, sketches and dances with little connecting story. Show Boat (1927), by Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein II, was something new: a sweeping story spanning decades of life on a Mississippi riverboat. Show Boat confronted racism and a mixed-race marriage, at a time when such marriages were illegal in much of the country. Making such a show takes a team of specialists. The composer writes the music, the lyricist the words of the songs, and the book writer the spoken scenes and overall story, which is why a musical's script is called its book. A choreographer creates the dances, and an orchestrator arranges the score for the pit band. Its great successor was Oklahoma! (1943), by Richard Rodgers and Hammerstein. In an integrated book musical, songs and dances advance the plot and reveal character instead of interrupting the story. Agnes de Mille's dream ballet in Oklahoma! used dance to show the heroine's fears, making movement part of the storytelling. This model dominated for decades. South Pacific (1949) included a song arguing that prejudice has to be taught to children, which drew attacks from some Southern lawmakers when the show toured.

Concepts, rock and new voices

From the late 1960s writers stretched the form. A concept musical is organized around a theme or idea rather than a straightforward plot; Company (1970), by Stephen Sondheim and the director Harold Prince, explored modern marriage through loosely linked scenes. Hair (1968) brought rock music, burning draft cards and nudity to Broadway. Later decades brought spectacular "megamusicals" from London, such as Les Misérables, and new kinds of stagecraft, including The Lion King (1997), whose director Julie Taymor drew on puppetry traditions from Asia and Africa. Hamilton (2015) told the story of America's founders through hip hop, with actors of color playing the white founders. Supporters praised it for opening the national story to people long left out of it; critics argued that it softened the founders' ties to slavery.

The form is now global. In Japan the Takarazuka Revue, founded in 1913, is a company of women who play every role, men's parts included, a mirror image of Kabuki's all male stage. South Korea, Germany and many other countries now produce both imported hits and original musicals in their own languages, and London and New York shows routinely tour the world.

Worked example: one song doing three jobs

Consider how a good song works in a book musical. At the start of Oklahoma!, the cowboy Curly is heard singing about a beautiful morning before he strolls on. In a few minutes the number establishes the setting, farm country in Indian Territory in 1906; shows Curly's easy confidence and his wish to court Laurey; and sets the warm tone of the evening. A revue song could be cut and placed anywhere. This one could not be moved without damaging the story. Writers still use a blunt test: if a song could be removed without the audience missing any information or feeling, it probably does not belong. At its best, the form makes song the moment when a character's feelings grow too strong for speech.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was The Beggar's Opera?
2. What is operetta?
3. What were minstrel shows?
4. Why does Shuffle Along (1921) matter?
5. What did Show Boat (1927) confront?
6. What is an integrated book musical?
7. What is a concept musical?
8. How did Hamilton (2015) tell its story?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia