Skip to main content

If the heavens were no longer made of a special substance, and the body could be explained as a pump and a set of pipes, what was the world made of, and how did it work? In the seventeenth century a powerful answer spread: nature is a machine.

The mechanical philosophy

Aristotle had explained things by their forms and purposes: a stone falls because it seeks its natural place, an acorn grows because it aims to become an oak. Renaissance thinkers added sympathies and hidden powers. The mechanical philosophers swept all this aside. Everything, they said, comes down to tiny particles of matter, their sizes, shapes and motions, pushing on one another. A favorite image was a great clock. Robert Boyle compared the universe to the famous clock of Strasbourg cathedral, whose figures move in perfect order without knowing why.

Descartes

René Descartes (1596 to 1650), a French philosopher who spent about twenty years in the Dutch Republic, built the most ambitious system. For Descartes, matter was simply extension, so truly empty space was impossible. Wherever there is length, breadth and depth, there is matter. The universe was a full plenum of matter swirling in vast whirlpools, or vortices, which carried the planets around the Sun.

By 1633 he had nearly finished a book on all this, The World, which assumed a moving Earth. Then news arrived from Rome. Descartes shelved his book The World after learning of Galileo's condemnation in 1633. It appeared only after his death. Instead, in 1637, he published his Discourse on Method in French, so that people of good sense without Latin could judge it, along with essays on optics, weather and geometry. The geometry essay joined algebra to geometry, the root of the graph coordinates every student now learns.

Gassendi and the atoms

Not every mechanist followed Descartes. The French priest and philosopher Pierre Gassendi (1592 to 1655), the same man who watched Mercury cross the Sun, revived the atomism of the ancient Greek Epicurus, with its indivisible particles moving through empty space. Epicurus had long been notorious as a godless thinker who denied providence. Gassendi revived ancient atomism while reconciling it with Christian belief: God created the atoms, set them moving and gave humans an immortal soul. His version made atoms respectable.

Does nature abhor a vacuum?

An old saying held that nature abhors a vacuum. Pumps seemed to prove it: suction raises water. Yet well diggers in Italy knew that suction pumps could not lift water much more than about ten meters. In 1643 Evangelista Torricelli, who had assisted Galileo in his last months, filled a glass tube with mercury, much heavier than water, and turned it upside down in a dish. The mercury fell to a height of about 76 centimeters and stopped, leaving a gap at the top. Torricelli explained that the weight of the surrounding air holds up the column of mercury, and the space above, he suggested, was empty.

In France, Blaise Pascal saw a test. If air has weight, there should be less of it pressing down on a mountaintop. In 1648 his brother-in-law Florin Périer carried the tube up the Puy de Dôme, a peak in central France. On the Puy de Dôme the mercury stood lower at the summit, showing that air pressure falls with height. In Germany the engineer and mayor of Magdeburg, Otto von Guericke, built an air pump. In public shows in the 1650s and 1660s he pumped the air from two copper hemispheres fitted together. Guericke showed that teams of horses could not pull apart two hemispheres held together by air pressure.

Worked example: Boyle, Hobbes and the leaking pump

In 1659 Robert Boyle, with Hooke as his assistant, built an improved air pump: a glass globe that could be emptied of air while experimenters watched what happened inside to candles, sound, mice and birds. Boyle presented results as "matters of fact", witnessed by reliable gentlemen and reported in detail. Arguments about ultimate causes he set aside. In 1662 he published the rule now named after him: at a fixed temperature, the pressure of a gas rises as its volume shrinks.

The philosopher Thomas Hobbes attacked the whole program. The pump leaked, he pointed out, as it did. Experiments in a costly machine, seen by a select club, could not compel agreement. Hobbes argued that real knowledge must be demonstrated like geometry, not witnessed in expensive experiments. To him a vacuum was nonsense, and a club of experimenters claiming special authority looked like a recipe for faction.

In 1985 the historians Steven Shapin and Simon Schaffer studied this quarrel in their book Leviathan and the Air-Pump. Coming soon after England's civil wars, they argued, the dispute was about more than air. Both men wanted knowledge that would end bitter quarrels instead of feeding them. Shapin and Schaffer argued that the dispute was also about how to keep peace and order after the civil wars. Boyle's answer, a community that agreed on facts while tolerating disagreement about causes, won out, and it remains close to how scientists work. Hobbes's objection still has force: whoever owns the machines and chooses the witnesses shapes what counts as fact.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Descartes think empty space was impossible?
2. What did Descartes do with his book The World in 1633?
3. What did Pierre Gassendi do with ancient atomism?
4. How did Torricelli explain the column of mercury in his tube?
5. What happened when the mercury tube was carried up the Puy de Dôme in 1648?
6. What did Guericke's copper hemispheres show?
7. What was Thomas Hobbes's main objection to Boyle's experiments?
8. What did Shapin and Schaffer argue about the Boyle and Hobbes dispute?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia