Skip to main content

In 1984 a new skyscraper opened on Madison Avenue in New York. For decades corporate towers had been sleek glass boxes, stripped of ornament because ornament was thought dishonest. The new headquarters of the telephone company AT&T, designed by Philip Johnson and John Burgee, wore pinkish granite and was crowned with a huge broken pediment. Critics nicknamed it the Chippendale building because its top resembled the crown of an eighteenth century wardrobe. It was a joke, a quotation and a provocation at once, and it became a symbol of something that had recently acquired a name: the postmodern.

What "modern" meant

To understand "post," start with "modern." Philosophers use the word modernity for the outlook that grew from the scientific revolution and the Enlightenment. Its core hope is easy to state. The modern project trusted that reason, science and free inquiry would bring both truth and human emancipation. Knowledge would accumulate, superstition would retreat, and political life would be rebuilt on rights that every rational person could recognize. History, on this view, had a direction, and the direction was progress.

The twentieth century strained that confidence. Industrial science produced poison gas and the atomic bomb. Modern bureaucracies organized genocide with timetables and card files. Empires that claimed to bring civilization ruled by force. By the 1960s many thinkers, especially in France, asked whether the promises of modernity had concealed new forms of domination all along.

Two labels, often confused

Two labels are attached to the thinkers met here, and they are not the same. Poststructuralism names a movement in French thought of the 1960s and 1970s that questioned whether meaning could ever be fixed. It grew out of structuralism, a method that studied language, myth and society as systems of relations, and then turned against structuralism's hope of scientific certainty. Michel Foucault and Jacques Derrida are its best known figures, though both disliked the label.

Postmodernism is broader and looser. It names styles in the arts and also a diagnosis of a historical period. The critic Charles Jencks popularized "post-modern" in architecture with a 1977 book on its language, where it meant the return of ornament, irony and historical quotation, as in Johnson's tower. In philosophy the word became famous through Jean-François Lyotard's 1979 report on knowledge, where it meant suspicion of grand claims to universal truth. What the different uses share is suspicion of any single universal standard, whether of style or of truth.

Family traits

No single doctrine unites these writers, but several traits recur. The first is anti-foundationalism: the denial that knowledge rests on a bedrock of certainties that need no further support. Descartes sought one indubitable starting point; these thinkers doubted any such point exists. The second is attention to language. Rather than treating words as clear windows onto reality, they asked how vocabularies shape what can be seen and said. The third is suspicion of universals: claims about "human nature" or "reason as such" were examined for whose experience they quietly took as the standard. The fourth is a focus on power, on how knowledge and institutions sort people into the normal and the deviant.

An older ancestor

Many of these themes were anticipated by Friedrich Nietzsche. In an essay written in 1873 and published after his death, he asked what truth is and answered: "A mobile army of metaphors, metonyms, anthropomorphisms." Nietzsche suggested that truths are illusions whose origins have been forgotten, metaphors worn smooth like coins that have lost their stamp. French philosophers of the 1960s read Nietzsche intensely, and his suspicion of fixed truths runs through everything that follows.

Why it matters

Postmodern thought is often treated either as a liberation or as a disaster. Admirers credit it with exposing how claims to neutral knowledge excluded women, colonized peoples and minorities. Critics blame it for relativism, obscure prose and, more recently, a culture in which every inconvenient fact can be dismissed as somebody's narrative. The best way to judge is to read what the main figures actually argued, which is often more careful, and sometimes more troubling, than either fans or enemies suggest.

One question will keep returning. If universal claims are always suspect, what becomes of universal human rights, which rest on the idea that every person has equal worth? Some of these thinkers had answers. Some of their critics thought the answers failed.

Worked example: reading a building

Take the AT&T tower as a test case. A modernist architect of the 1950s would judge it by function and honesty of materials: does the form express the structure? By that standard the pediment is a fake, a decorative hat on a steel frame. A postmodern reading asks different questions. Who decided that plain glass boxes were the "honest" style, and whose taste did that rule serve? The tower mixes the corporate skyscraper with the furniture of an English drawing room and an arched entrance that recalls a Renaissance chapel in Florence. It does not claim one true style. It quotes several, with a wink.

Notice what the example shows and what it does not. It shows a shift in attitude, from a single standard to playful plurality and from faith in progress to borrowing from the past. It does not show that there are no better or worse buildings; plenty of critics found the tower clumsy. The postmodern turn changed which questions felt urgent. It did not settle the answers.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the modern project trust would bring both truth and human emancipation?
2. What does poststructuralism name?
3. In which field did Charles Jencks popularize the term "post-modern" with a 1977 book?
4. What is anti-foundationalism?
5. What did Nietzsche suggest truths are?
6. Which of these is described as a recurring trait of postmodern and poststructuralist thinkers?
7. Why did critics nickname the 1984 AT&T tower the Chippendale building?
8. Which trait links postmodern architecture with postmodern philosophy?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia