Skip to main content

The Black Death was the first wave of a pandemic that lasted four centuries. Plague returned to Europe, North Africa and the Middle East again and again, and the ways people learned to fight it laid foundations for modern public health. The disease has not vanished even now.

The long tail of the second pandemic

Outbreaks came every decade or two for generations, then less often. London's Great Plague of 1665 killed around a fifth of the city, with about 68,000 plague deaths in the official bills of mortality and more unrecorded. Northern Italy lost huge numbers in 1630 and Naples in 1656. Moscow was hit in 1771, provoking riots. After that, plague faded from western Europe, though it lingered in the Ottoman lands and North Africa into the nineteenth century. Why it retreated is still debated: better housing, changes in rats, controls at borders and shifts in the bacterium have all been proposed.

Building public health

Italian cities led the way in organized response. They set up temporary health boards during outbreaks, and these became permanent: Venice created a permanent health magistracy in 1486. Venice had already, in 1423, set up its first lazaretto, on an island in the lagoon, a quarantine hospital where the sick were isolated and ships, goods and travelers could be held. Health passes certified that a traveler came from a healthy place. Later, states drew guarded lines around infected regions, called cordons sanitaires.

These measures saved lives, but they also gave officials new power over ordinary people. Houses were locked with families inside, the poor were blamed for spreading disease, and trade bans ruined workers. The tension between protecting the public and respecting individual freedom and dignity began here and has never gone away.

The beaked doctor

The most famous image of plague, a doctor in a long coat and a beaked mask stuffed with herbs, does not belong to the Black Death at all. The beaked plague doctor costume dates from the seventeenth century, credited to the French royal physician Charles de Lorme. Doctors of 1348 wore ordinary clothes.

The third pandemic and plague today

The third pandemic began in southwestern China, reached Hong Kong in 1894 and spread by steamship to ports on every inhabited continent. The third pandemic killed about 12 million people in India, mostly between 1896 and the 1920s. It also left plague established among wild rodents in new regions, including the western United States, which still sees a handful of human cases most years.

Plague remains a danger where poverty, rodents and weak health systems meet, above all in Madagascar and parts of central Africa. Madagascar suffered a large outbreak, mostly of the pneumonic form, in 2017. Yet the disease that emptied cities is now curable. Plague is treated today with antibiotics given early, which can save most patients if started soon after symptoms appear.

Written in our genes?

Can a pandemic change human biology? A 2022 study compared DNA from people in London and Denmark who died before, during and after the Black Death. It reported that plague favored certain immune gene variants, including one in a gene called ERAP2 that helped the body recognize the germ. The same variants are now linked to a higher risk of some autoimmune diseases. Other geneticists questioned the statistics, so the finding remains under debate.

What changed for good

Historians also argue about the plague's deepest effects. David Herlihy argued that scarce labor encouraged labor-saving inventions, perhaps even the printing press, and that the shock broke the hold of old habits. Others think trends already underway explain more. Few doubt that the Black Death showed how a connected world spreads disease, how quickly fear seeks scapegoats, and how a disaster can shift power between rich and poor.

Worked example: Marseille, 1720

In May 1720 a merchant ship, the Grand-Saint-Antoine, arrived at Marseille from the eastern Mediterranean. Several crew and passengers had died on the voyage. Plague reached Marseille in 1720 on a trading ship from the Levant. The ship was placed in quarantine, but its cargo of silk and cotton was valuable and was due at a great trade fair, and powerful merchants pressed for its release. The rules were relaxed. Within weeks, plague was in the city, and perhaps half of Marseille's people died. Provence lost many more.

The authorities then went to the other extreme. The mur de la peste was a wall built to keep plague out of a region: in 1721 a dry stone wall was raised across the hills of Provence, guarded by soldiers, to stop the disease spreading north. The case shows both sides of plague control. The system of quarantine worked only when officials resisted pressure from commerce, and when it failed, the response fell hardest on ordinary people. Any modern response to an epidemic faces the same tests: will it be applied fairly, and will the interests of the powerful be allowed to bend it?

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. When did Venice set up its first lazaretto?
2. What did a health pass certify?
3. When did the beaked plague doctor costume appear?
4. How did plague reach Marseille in 1720?
5. What was the mur de la peste?
6. Where did the third plague pandemic kill about 12 million people?
7. How is plague treated today?
8. What did David Herlihy argue about the plague's effects?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia