Skip to main content

An emperor on strike

The Wanli emperor reigned from 1572 to 1620, longer than any other Ming ruler, and his reign began well. But after Zhang Juzheng's death he clashed with his officials over the succession. Wanli wanted to make the son of his favorite, Lady Zheng, heir, instead of his eldest son. The officials insisted on the rule of seniority, and the struggle, known as the dispute over the root of the state, lasted some fifteen years before Wanli named his eldest son in 1601.

Wanli's response was to withdraw. For long stretches he refused to meet his ministers and left vacant posts unfilled, so that by the early 1600s many offices in the capital and provinces had no holder. Memorials went unanswered. Wanli did not stop ruling entirely, and he still sent armies and collected money, but the machinery of government ground down.

Donglin against the eunuchs

In 1604 a dismissed official named Gu Xiancheng revived an old academy at Wuxi, near the Yangzi delta. The Donglin Academy became a center where officials and scholars criticized the government on moral grounds, demanding honest officials and an end to eunuch abuses. Its members and allies formed a powerful faction at court.

Under the Tianqi emperor, who reigned from 1620 to 1627, the eunuch Wei Zhongxian took control of the government. He struck back hard, and in 1625 and 1626 leading Donglin figures were arrested, tortured and killed in prison. Officials eager for favor built shrines across the empire to honor Wei while he was still alive, an honor normally given to sages and great benefactors. When the Chongzhen emperor came to the throne in 1627, Wei was disgraced and killed himself. But the factional hatred outlived him.

Danger from the northeast

Beyond the Great Wall, the Jurchen chief Nurhaci had united his people. In 1618 he issued a manifesto called the Seven Grievances, listing wrongs the Ming had done the Jurchens, and declared war. In 1619 his forces destroyed a large Ming expedition at Sarhu. In 1626, however, the commander Yuan Chonghuan held the fortress of Ningyuan against Nurhaci, helped above all by European-style cannon mounted on its walls. Nurhaci died later that year. Yuan was accused of treason after Jurchen raiders broke through to Beijing in 1629, and in 1630 the Chongzhen emperor had him executed. Nurhaci's successors renamed their people the Manchus and their state the Qing.

Cold, hunger and rebellion

Then the weather turned. The mid seventeenth century was among the coldest periods of what is called the Little Ice Age, and north China suffered severe droughts, locusts and famine through the 1630s and early 1640s. Epidemics swept the north. The state, short of money, cut costs, and in 1629 it shut down many of the courier stations of the postal relay system.

Among the men laid off was Li Zicheng, who had been a courier in the government's postal relay service. He joined the rebels roaming the starving northwest and became their most successful leader, winning support with promises to lower taxes and share grain. In 1644 his army took Beijing, and the Chongzhen emperor hanged himself. Li proclaimed a dynasty of his own, but within weeks Qing armies entered China and drove him out.

Why did the Ming fall?

Historians weigh several causes. William Atwell argued that a sharp fall in silver imports in the 1630s and 1640s deepened the crisis, making taxes harder to pay; others have questioned whether imports really dropped that much. Climate historians such as Geoffrey Parker stress cold and drought. Others point to institutions: a court paralyzed by factions, an army underpaid, and a tax system that could not raise money when it was most needed.

Worked example: weighing the causes of 1644

Imagine three historians arguing over the same famine in Shaanxi in 1640. The first notes that grain prices tripled after years of drought, and that no state could have fed everyone. The second replies that the government's own choices made it worse: it raised extra taxes to pay the armies facing the Manchus and closed the courier stations that employed local men. The third adds that silver was scarce, so farmers who did harvest something got less for it when they sold.

Each explanation is partly right, and the causes fed one another. Drought made taxes harder to collect; missing taxes left soldiers unpaid; unpaid soldiers deserted and joined rebels; rebellion destroyed more farms.

The Ming had been founded by a peasant rebel who promised order to the poor, and it ended when a government no longer able to protect its people met another rebel making the same promise. Among the scholars who survived the fall, the writer Zhang Dai later remembered the lanterns, theaters and gardens of the late Ming in loving detail, from a hut in the hills where he lived in poverty. His memoirs remind us that a dynasty's fall is measured not only in battles and silver but in millions of ordinary lives, each of which mattered.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the dispute over the root of the state?
2. How did the Wanli emperor respond to his quarrel with officials?
3. What was the Donglin Academy?
4. What unusual honor did officials give the eunuch Wei Zhongxian?
5. What were the Seven Grievances of 1618?
6. What helped Yuan Chonghuan hold Ningyuan against Nurhaci in 1626?
7. What had Li Zicheng's job been before he became a rebel?
8. What did William Atwell argue about the fall of the Ming?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia