Skip to main content

Ask young adults to guess how content people in their seventies are, and they usually guess low. Ask people in their seventies, and many report as much contentment as the young, often more. Late life does bring real losses: of strength, of hearing, of friends and partners. But research on older adults keeps turning up a surprise. Many people grow emotionally steadier just as their bodies grow frailer.

Choosing what matters

The American psychologist Laura Carstensen developed socioemotional selectivity theory in the 1990s. It holds that when people see their time as limited, they focus on emotionally meaningful goals and close relationships rather than on gathering new information and contacts. In one study, older adults offered a choice of whom to spend half an hour with usually chose a familiar person, such as a close friend, over an interesting new acquaintance. Younger people chose differently, except when their time horizons were cut short, as for those imagining a move across the country or living with a serious illness. Then they chose like the old. The key factor is perceived time left, not age itself.

Carstensen and colleagues also described a positivity effect: older adults tend to attend to, and remember, more positive than negative information, compared with younger adults. The effect is real on average but modest, and it varies with health and circumstances.

Selection, optimization, compensation

Paul Baltes and Margret Baltes proposed a model of successful aging in 1990 with three linked strategies. Selection means narrowing one's goals to those that matter most. Optimization means practicing and investing in those chosen areas. Compensation means finding new means to reach a goal when old ones fail, such as hearing aids, written reminders or help from others. Baltes liked to cite the pianist Arthur Rubinstein, who explained in old age that he played fewer pieces, practiced them more, and slowed down before fast passages so that they sounded faster by contrast.

The model sits between two older theories. Disengagement theory, proposed by Elaine Cumming and William Henry in 1961, held that older people and society naturally withdraw from each other. Activity theory replied that staying busy and involved keeps people well. Neither fits everyone, and differences between people tend to widen with age.

Facing death

Erikson called the last stage integrity versus despair: looking back on one's life and accepting it as one's own, mistakes included, rather than being consumed by regret.

How people die changed during the twentieth century, as more deaths moved from home to hospital. The British nurse, social worker and physician Cicely Saunders founded St Christopher's Hospice in London in 1967, launching the modern hospice movement. She developed the idea of total pain, suffering that is physical, emotional, social and spiritual at once, each part deserving care. Her insistence that the dying still matter as whole persons, to the last moment of life, is a direct expression of the equal dignity of every human being.

In On Death and Dying (1969), the Swiss-American psychiatrist Elisabeth Kübler-Ross drew on interviews with dying patients to describe five reactions: denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. The book did enormous good by persuading doctors to talk honestly with dying people. But the stages were later applied to grief and taught as a fixed sequence, which she had not intended, and research has not found that people move through the stages in a fixed order.

How people grieve

The psychologist George Bonanno followed bereaved people over time and found several typical paths. The most common was resilience: a short period of distress followed by a fairly steady return to daily functioning, without the long collapse many people expect. Others recover more slowly, and a minority experience grief that stays intense and disabling for a long time. Since 2022 the American Psychiatric Association's diagnostic manual has included prolonged grief disorder for such cases, defined for adults as intense yearning or preoccupation lasting at least a year after a death.

In 1999 Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut proposed the dual process model, in which healthy grieving moves back and forth between facing the loss and rebuilding daily life. Others have stressed continuing bonds: many bereaved people stay connected to the dead through memories, conversations and rituals, and this need not be a failure to let go.

Worked example: Rose at 82

Rose, 82, lost her husband of fifty years last spring. Arthritis has made gardening hard, and her daughter worries she is withdrawing because she has dropped her book club. A closer look tells a different story. Rose has narrowed her social world to the people who matter most, as socioemotional selectivity theory predicts, and she sees her sister and two old friends every week. She has selected and compensated: she now grows herbs in raised beds instead of tending a whole vegetable plot. She talks to her husband's photograph each morning, a continuing bond rather than a symptom, and some days she cries while on others she plans a trip, the swing between loss and rebuilding that the dual process model describes. If her grief stayed intense and disabling a year or more on, a referral would make sense. For now, the most respectful response is to support the choices she is making, since they are hers to make.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does socioemotional selectivity theory hold?
2. What is the positivity effect?
3. In the selection, optimization and compensation model, what is compensation?
4. What did disengagement theory claim?
5. What is total pain, in Saunders's sense?
6. What has research found about Kübler-Ross's stages?
7. What was the most common grief pattern Bonanno found?
8. What does the dual process model of grief describe?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia