Skip to main content

The story the Bible tells

The biblical account begins with ancestors. Abraham leaves Mesopotamia at God's command, and his son Isaac and grandson Jacob, also called Israel, live as herders in Canaan. Jacob's twelve sons become the twelve tribes. Famine drives the family to Egypt, where their descendants are enslaved. Moses leads them out in the Exodus, they receive the law at Mount Sinai, wander forty years in the wilderness, and then, in the book of Joshua, conquer Canaan in a few swift campaigns. The book of Judges tells a messier story of tribes living among Canaanites and fighting local wars under temporary leaders.

For believers this story carries the meaning of the covenant: a people freed from slavery and bound by law. Its memory of slavery shaped some of its most humane commands, such as the repeated instruction to treat the stranger kindly because "ye were strangers in the land of Egypt" (Exodus 22:21, King James Version).

What archaeology finds

Historians ask whether the evidence on the ground fits this account. For the Exodus the answer is difficult. No Egyptian record mentions a mass escape of Hebrew slaves, and surveys in Sinai have found no trace of a large population camping there in the late Bronze Age. Defenders reply that slaves and nomads leave little behind, and that a smaller group could have escaped and later shaped the memory of the whole people. Egyptian texts do show that Semitic speaking people lived and worked in the Nile Delta, so the setting is plausible even if the scale is not.

The conquest is harder still. At Jericho, the British archaeologist Kathleen Kenyon excavated from 1952 to 1958 and concluded that Jericho had no walled city at the time of the supposed conquest in the thirteenth century BCE. At Ai, the name means "the ruin," and the site was indeed abandoned for centuries before the Israelites were said to take it. Some sites do show destruction around 1200 BCE, such as Hazor in the north, but they were destroyed over a long span and by unknown hands.

A wave of hill villages

What archaeology does show is striking. Around 1200 BCE, hundreds of small new villages appeared in the central hill country, by one count about 250, where there had been only a few dozen before. They were unwalled farming hamlets of perhaps fifty to a hundred people. They used simple pottery much like that of Canaanite towns, terraced the slopes, dug cisterns, and built a common type of dwelling, the four-room house, with a courtyard and rooms for people, animals and storage.

This happened while the Late Bronze Age world was collapsing. Around 1200 BCE the Hittite empire fell, Mycenaean palaces burned, Egypt lost its grip on Canaan, and the Sea Peoples, including the Philistines, settled on the coast. The hill villages are the most likely ancestors of Israel.

Four models

Scholars have offered four main explanations. William F. Albright and his followers in the mid twentieth century defended a conquest model, reading burned cities as signs of Joshua's campaigns. Albrecht Alt in Germany proposed in 1925 a peaceful infiltration of pastoral nomads who slowly settled down. George Mendenhall in 1962, followed by Norman Gottwald in 1979, argued for a peasant revolt in which Canaanite farmers threw off their city lords. Today many archaeologists, including Israel Finkelstein and William Dever, favor a version of the fourth view: Israel emerged mostly from within Canaanite society, as herders and farmers moved into the hills, perhaps joined by smaller groups from outside who brought a story of escape from Egypt.

That last idea fits a curious fact. Early Israel worshipped a god named Yahweh who was linked in old poems with the southern deserts, Seir and Edom, rather than with Canaan. A small group from the south may have carried this god into the hills.

Worked example: Reading animal bones

How can archaeologists tell one group of ancient villagers from another when their pots look alike? One clue lies in their rubbish. In excavated Iron Age I villages of the central hills, bones of sheep, goats and cattle are common, but pig bones are almost entirely absent. In Philistine cities on the coast in the same period, pig bones are plentiful, and earlier Bronze Age sites in the hills had some.

Finkelstein and others suggested that the hill people avoided pork as a way of marking who they were, long before the dietary laws were written down. A food rule can work like a flag: it says "we are not them," especially when the neighbors, here the Philistines, eat pork freely.

Test the reasoning before accepting it. Pigs need water and shade and do poorly in dry hills, so ecology might explain part of the pattern. Some later Israelite sites have small amounts of pig bone, so the rule was not universal. And a gap in bones cannot tell us what people believed. Still, the pattern is consistent across many sites and sharpens over time, which makes a cultural explanation reasonable. This is how much of early Israel's history must be written: from humble evidence, with a cautious argument about meaning.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does no Egyptian record mention, according to historians?
2. What did Kathleen Kenyon conclude about Jericho?
3. What happened in the central hill country around 1200 BCE?
4. What kind of dwelling was common in the new hill villages?
5. Who defended the conquest model of Israel's origins?
6. What did Albrecht Alt propose in 1925?
7. What did George Mendenhall argue in 1962?
8. Which view do many archaeologists now favor?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia