Medieval wars were not only fought by armies. They were paid for by taxpayers, endured by villagers, and argued over in assemblies. The Hundred Years' War demanded money on a scale neither kingdom had seen, and the struggle to raise it changed how both were governed.
Paying for war in England
In England the king needed Parliament, and especially the elected Commons, to grant taxes. Knights from the shires and townsmen from the boroughs learned to bargain: they would vote a tax if the king listened to their complaints. Grants of customs on wool, and later poll taxes, kept the armies in the field. When the war went badly in the 1370s, the Commons struck back. In the Good Parliament of 1376 they impeached royal officials accused of corruption, a procedure usually counted as the first impeachment in English history. A few years later, poll taxes raised for the war helped spark the great English rising of 1381.
Paying for war in France
France had no single parliament with the same grip. Kings negotiated with regional assemblies and, in crises, with the Estates-General, which represented clergy, nobles and towns. New taxes appeared, including the gabelle, a tax on salt, a necessity no household could avoid. To pay John II's ransom, the crown created a new gold coin in 1360 showing the king on horseback. It was called the franc, a name that lasted in France for more than six centuries.
A plague in the middle of a war
The Black Death struck in 1348, killing perhaps a third or more of the population in a few years. It interrupted campaigns and emptied villages, but it did not stop the war. Fewer taxpayers now had to carry the same military costs, and that pressure made the political crises of the 1350s sharper.
Paris in revolt
After the capture of John II at Poitiers, the young heir, the Dauphin Charles, called the Estates-General to Paris to raise money. The Estates demanded reforms in return. In March 1357 they won the Great Ordinance, which required that the Estates supervise the collection and spending of taxes and meet regularly, and that corrupt officials be removed. Their leading figure was Étienne Marcel, the provost of the merchants of Paris, in effect the head of the city's government.
The experiment soon turned violent. In February 1358 Marcel's followers burst into the Dauphin's palace and killed two of his marshals in front of him. The Dauphin escaped Paris and gathered support among nobles who resented the townsmen. Marcel allied with Charles, King of Navarre, an ambitious royal cousin, and was killed by his own townsmen in July 1358.
The Jacquerie
That same summer, peasants north of Paris rose against the nobility, burning manor houses and killing noble families. The rising was called the Jacquerie, from Jacques Bonhomme, a mocking nickname nobles used for any peasant. The peasants' anger had causes: nobles had been beaten at Poitiers, yet still collected dues while soldiers looted the countryside. Within weeks, noble armies led by Charles of Navarre crushed the rebels near Mello and took savage revenge. Most chroniclers were churchmen or wrote for nobles, so their accounts of peasant atrocities should be read with care.
Soldiers without wars
Peace brought its own disaster. After Brétigny in 1360, thousands of soldiers lost their pay. Many joined free companies, bands of unemployed soldiers who lived by plunder and protection money. They seized castles and forced nearby villages to pay for safety. In 1361 they threatened the papal court at Avignon, and the pope paid them to go away. For ordinary people, a truce could be almost as dangerous as war.
Worked example: the Great Ordinance of 1357
Consider the Great Ordinance as an early test of accountable government. Its logic was simple and powerful: those who pay taxes should have a say in how they are spent, and officials who steal should be punished. The Estates named their own commissioners to oversee collection, required the king's council to include their delegates, and banned the old practice of seizing goods for royal use without payment.
Why did it fail? First, the Estates were divided. Nobles and clergy grew alarmed when the reform movement came to be led by Paris merchants. Second, the reformers had no army of their own and depended on a royal government they were trying to restrain. Third, the killing of the marshals in 1358 frightened moderates, and Marcel's alliance with Charles of Navarre looked like treason. Fourth, the Jacquerie made nobles rally to the Dauphin as the guardian of order.
The comparison with England is revealing. English kings, too, faced angry taxpayers, but the Commons sat regularly, worked through petitions and impeachment, and avoided bloodshed. Their power grew slowly and stuck. The French Estates won more on paper in a single year and lost almost all of it within two. Lasting rights, the case suggests, depend less on a bold charter than on institutions that keep meeting, keep bargaining and keep the trust of different groups at once.
