In 1414 the leaders of Western Christendom gathered in the city of Constance, on the shore of Lake Constance, to end the schism, reform the church and deal with heresy. Hus traveled there of his own will, hoping to defend his teaching in open debate. He would not leave alive, and the way he died turned a reform movement into a cause that thousands were willing to fight for.
Sigismund and the road to Constance
The council was the project of Sigismund of Luxembourg, king of Hungary and King of the Romans. Sigismund was the half-brother of Wenceslas IV, a younger son of Charles IV by a later marriage, and since Wenceslas had no children, he was also the likely heir to Bohemia. A Bohemian heresy was an embarrassment to his family, and he wanted it settled.
Hus arrived in Constance on 3 November 1414. Within weeks he was arrested and held in a cell in a Dominican house beside the lake, where he fell seriously ill. Sigismund protested at first, then accepted the council's view that it had the right to judge a suspected heretic. Whether Sigismund betrayed Hus or was outmaneuvered remains a real question, and Czechs never forgave him.
The trial
Public hearings came only in June 1415. Hus expected a debate. Instead the council presented lists of articles drawn from his books and from the testimony of his enemies and demanded that he abjure them all. Some he accepted as his own and defended. Others, he said, he had never taught. Hus refused to abjure because renouncing views he had never held would mean swearing a lie, and he would not perjure himself to save his life. He asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong. The council, which saw itself as the voice of the whole church, did not think a single priest had the right to set such terms.
The council's case deserves a fair hearing. Its leaders were themselves reformers who had just deposed popes to end the schism, and they believed unity required that the whole church, gathered in council, have the last word. If every priest could appeal from the church to his own reading of the Bible, they asked, what would hold Christendom together? Hus answered that a conscience bound by Scripture could not be overruled by a vote.
Wycliffe, long dead, was condemned too. The council ordered that Wycliffe's remains be dug up and burned, an order carried out in England in 1428. On 6 July 1415, after a final refusal, Hus was stripped of his priesthood and put to death outside the city walls.
The cup for everyone
While Hus was away, a new practice spread through Prague that would give the whole movement its symbol. For centuries lay people in the Western church had received only the bread at communion, while the priest alone drank the wine. In autumn 1414 Jakoubek of Stříbro, a Prague master, began giving the cup to lay people, arguing that Christ had said "drink ye all of it" and that the early church had shared both. Hussites who demanded communion in both kinds became known as Utraquists, from the Latin sub utraque specie, "under both kinds."
The council condemned the practice. In June 1415 the Council of Constance forbade giving the cup to lay people. Hus, from his cell, wrote to support it. Soon a carved or painted chalice appeared on church walls, banners and shields across Bohemia. The chalice became the emblem of the Hussite movement, a sign that ordinary believers were equal to priests at the altar.
Jerome and the Bohemian answer
Hus's friend Jerome of Prague, a brilliant and restless scholar who had carried Wycliffe's books from Oxford, came to Constance to help him and was also arrested. In September 1415, weakened by prison, Jerome recanted. Months later he changed his mind. In May 1416 Jerome of Prague withdrew his recantation before the council, praised Hus and was executed on 30 May.
The answer from Bohemia came quickly. On 2 September 1415, 452 nobles of Bohemia and Moravia sealed a letter protesting Hus's death and calling it an insult to the whole kingdom. They declared that they would protect faithful preachers on their estates and would obey church authority only where it agreed with Scripture. A heresy case had become a matter of national honor.
Worked example: reading the letter of protest
Historians treat the protest of 1415 as a primary source in two senses. First, its words. The nobles insist that Hus was a good and holy man, that Bohemia has been wrongly branded heretical and that anyone who says so is a liar. They speak as the lords of a kingdom whose reputation has been harmed.
Second, its physical form. The document is crowded with hundreds of wax seals hanging on strips of parchment, each one a personal pledge. Several copies were sent, and one survives in the library of the University of Edinburgh, carried there by a route historians still trace. Counting the seals shows breadth: great lords, but also many lesser knights and squires. Asking who did not seal shows limits: much of the high clergy and many Catholic nobles stayed away. The seals reveal a political community taking sides before a single battle was fought.
