When Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Nazi leadership planned not an ordinary campaign but a war of annihilation against what it called "Jewish Bolshevism." In the territories it overran, which held several million Jews, the systematic killing of whole Jewish communities began. Most of it was done not with gas but with guns, at the edges of towns, in ravines, forests and pits, often in sight of local people.
The killers
Behind the advancing armies came four Einsatzgruppen, labeled A to D, with about 3,000 men in all. They were too few to kill on the scale that followed without help. Battalions of German Order Police, Waffen SS brigades, army units and local auxiliary police in Lithuania, Latvia, Ukraine, Belarus and elsewhere did much of the shooting, guarding and rounding up. At first the units mainly killed Jewish men of military age, along with communist officials. From late July and August 1941 they began shooting women and children as well, a step that turned mass murder into the destruction of entire communities.
Scale and speed
The numbers rose with frightening speed. At Kamianets-Podilskyi in western Ukraine, in late August 1941, about 23,600 Jews were shot in three days, many of them refugees whom Hungary had expelled across the border. It was the first massacre of the campaign to claim more than 20,000 lives. At Ponary, a forest outside Vilna, around 70,000 Jews were murdered over the next three years, along with Poles and Soviet prisoners. Near Riga, about 25,000 Jews were shot in the Rumbula forest on two days in late 1941. By the end of the war about two million Jews had been killed by shooting, most of them in the occupied Soviet lands.
Neighbors and allies
The killing was German in design and command, but not only German in execution. In some places local people killed Jews themselves, often in the days between the Soviet retreat and the full German takeover. At Jedwabne in northeastern Poland, in July 1941, Polish townspeople herded their Jewish neighbors into a barn and set it on fire, with Germans present and encouraging the crime. A book about the massacre by the historian Jan Gross set off a national debate in 2000, and an official Polish investigation found at least 340 victims. Germany's ally Romania ran its own campaign of murder. Romanian forces carried out a massacre in Odessa in October 1941 and deported Jews to camps in the region called Transnistria, where many died of hunger, cold and shootings. An international commission chaired by Elie Wiesel concluded in 2004 that Romania was responsible for the deaths of 280,000 to 380,000 Jews.
The army's role
For decades many Germans believed that the regular army had fought a hard but honorable war while the SS did the killing. The record says otherwise. Army commanders shared supplies, transport and intelligence with the killing units, and some issued orders urging soldiers to understand the need for harsh measures against Jews. A traveling exhibition that opened in Hamburg in 1995 challenged the myth of a "clean" army with photographs and documents, and its fierce reception showed how painful the evidence still was.
From bullets to gas
Shooting at close range wore on the shooters. Some drank heavily, some broke down, and a few asked to be transferred. When Heinrich Himmler, the head of the SS, watched an execution near Minsk in August 1941, he reportedly urged his officers to find other methods. The killers turned to gas partly to spare the shooters' nerves as well as to kill faster and more secretly. Gas vans, trucks whose exhaust was piped into a sealed compartment, were used in the east from late 1941, and the experience fed into the camps described next.
Much about the shootings was forgotten in the west for decades, partly because many sites lay in the Soviet Union, where Jewish victims were often described only as "peaceful Soviet citizens." Since 2004 a French priest, Patrick Desbois, and his team have interviewed thousands of village witnesses to locate unmarked mass graves, and the term "Holocaust by bullets," taken from his work, is now widely used.
Worked example: a report in neat columns
On 1 December 1941 Karl Jäger, commander of Einsatzkommando 3, a subunit of Einsatzgruppe A, sent his superiors a typed summary of his unit's work in Lithuania since July. Day by day, town by town, it lists the number of Jewish men, Jewish women and Jewish children killed, along with smaller numbers of communists and others, and ends with a total of 137,346. Jäger wrote that the Jewish problem in Lithuania had been solved, apart from Jews kept alive for work.
Read the document twice. First as evidence: it was written by a perpetrator for other perpetrators, never meant for outsiders, and it matches survivor testimony and later excavations, which makes it very hard to dispute. Then as a portrait of a mind. Murder appears as a statistic to be reported upward, with columns for gender and age, as if the writer were proud of his diligence. That bureaucratic calm is one of the most chilling features of the Holocaust. Jäger lived under his own name in West Germany after the war. He was arrested in 1959 and took his own life in prison before trial.
