Merchants prefer peace, but the Hanse did not always get it. Its towns were small compared with the kingdoms around them, and their wealth tempted kings and pirates alike. When boycotts failed, Hanseatic towns hired soldiers, fitted out ships and went to war. Three conflicts show how they fought and what they won.
Valdemar IV and the fall of Visby
In the mid fourteenth century King Valdemar IV of Denmark set out to rebuild a kingdom broken by debt and civil war. He recovered Scania, with its rich herring markets, and then turned to Gotland. In 1361 his army landed on the island. Gotland's farmers met it outside the walls of Visby and were cut down in large numbers. Valdemar IV of Denmark captured Visby, and the town's burghers, who had kept their gates shut while the farmers died, opened them and paid a heavy ransom.
The slaughter outside the walls left an unusual record. In the early twentieth century archaeologists excavated mass graves near the battlefield and found the remains of many hundreds of people, some still wearing their armor. The bones showed that many of the dead were old, young or disabled, evidence that the defenders were ordinary farmers rather than trained soldiers.
The Hanseatic towns answered with war, and lost. In 1362 their fleet was defeated near Helsingborg, and the Lübeck mayor who had commanded it, Johann Wittenborg, was later beheaded in his own town.
The Confederation of Cologne and the Peace of Stralsund
In 1367 delegates met in Cologne and formed a war alliance, the Confederation of Cologne. It joined Baltic towns, Prussian towns and Dutch towns from the Zuiderzee, some of which were not part of the Hanse at all, with Swedish and German nobles who also had grievances against Valdemar. This time the allies won, plundering the Danish coasts and taking Copenhagen.
The Peace of Stralsund of 1370 was the high point of Hanseatic power. Denmark confirmed the towns' trading privileges and handed over the fortresses along the Scanian coast, with two thirds of their revenues for fifteen years. The towns also won a voice in the choice of Valdemar's successor. A group of merchant towns had defeated a king.
The Victual Brothers
War often bred piracy. In the 1390s the dukes of Mecklenburg, fighting Queen Margaret of Denmark over the crown of Sweden, hired sea captains to run supplies into besieged Stockholm. These men became known as the Victual Brothers, from an old word for food supplies. When the fighting ended, many kept raiding ships on their own account.
For a few years they held Gotland as a base and attacked shipping across the Baltic and North Sea. In 1398 the Teutonic Order drove the Victual Brothers out of Gotland. Survivors fled to the North Sea coast. Hamburg captured their best-known leader, Klaus Störtebeker, and executed him around 1401. Much of what is told about him, including a tale that he walked past his crew after his head was cut off, is legend.
England and the war of 1469 to 1474
The Hanse's longest quarrel was with England. English merchants wanted the same rights in the Baltic that Hanseatic merchants enjoyed in London, and they resented the Steelyard's low customs. In 1468 English ships were seized in the Sound, and the English crown blamed the Hanse and arrested its merchants in London. A war of privateers followed.
Its most famous episode happened in 1473. Paul Beneke, a Danzig sea captain, seized a galley carrying Memling's Last Judgment, an altarpiece painted in Bruges for a Florentine banker. Danzig kept the painting, and it hangs in Gdańsk to this day despite protests from the pope. The war ended with the Treaty of Utrecht in 1474, in which Edward IV restored Hanseatic privileges and gave the Steelyard to the Hanse outright, along with compensation for its losses.
Worked example: weighing the gains of 1370
Look closely at the Peace of Stralsund. What did the towns actually gain, and what did it cost?
Start with the terms. The Scanian fortresses were held for fifteen years, from 1370 to 1385. That gave the towns direct control over the herring markets and a large share of the tolls collected there. Their privileges in Denmark were confirmed. In return they had paid for ships, soldiers and supplies over several years, and their merchants had lost goods and lives.
Now notice what the towns did not do. They did not try to conquer Denmark or keep the fortresses forever. They gave the castles back on schedule. Their aim was security for trade, not territory. This was typical. The Hanse fought wars to restore the conditions for business, then returned to bargaining. Yet the human costs fell heavily on people who had little say in these choices: the farmers of Gotland, the crews of seized ships, the coastal villages that were burned. A history of the Hanse that counts only privileges and profits leaves them out.
