Skip to main content

Two biological worlds meet

For millions of years the Americas and the Old World of Africa, Asia and Europe had developed largely separate sets of plants, animals and microbes. After 1492 ships carried them back and forth in a few generations. The result was the largest reshuffling of living things in human history, and it changed what people ate, how they farmed, how many of them lived and where.

What went east

The Americas gave the rest of the world some of its most important foods: maize, potatoes, cassava, sweet potatoes, beans, squash, peanuts, tomatoes, chili peppers and cacao, along with tobacco. Many of these crops grew in soils or climates where older staples did poorly, so they added calories to diets that had been near the edge.

The spread was fast. Within a century of Columbus, chili peppers carried by Portuguese traders had entered the cooking of India, and they soon spread to Southeast Asia and western China. Cassava, a hardy root that grows in poor soil and survives drought, became a staple across much of Central Africa after Portuguese ships brought it from Brazil. In Europe, the potato fed a growing population. The economists Nathan Nunn and Nancy Qian estimated that the potato accounts for roughly a quarter of the growth in Old World population between 1700 and 1900. That is an estimate from a statistical model, not a count, but it gives a sense of scale.

What went west

Europeans brought wheat, barley, rice, sugar cane, citrus, bananas and later coffee. They also brought large domestic animals that the Americas had mostly lacked: cattle, horses, pigs, sheep and goats, as well as chickens. Pigs released on islands ran wild and multiplied, providing meat for later expeditions. Cattle and sheep turned grasslands into ranches.

The animals reshaped landscapes and lives. The historian Elinor Melville showed how, in central Mexico's Mezquital Valley, huge flocks of sheep in the sixteenth century helped degrade farmland into eroded scrub, pushing native farmers off their land. On the North American plains, horses that escaped or were traded from Spanish settlements spread north, especially after a Pueblo rising in 1680 drove the Spanish out of New Mexico for a time. Peoples such as the Comanche and Lakota built new ways of life around the horse, hunting buffalo and raiding over vast distances.

Microbes and mortality

The most terrible traffic was in disease. Smallpox, measles, influenza and other infections arrived in populations that had no prior exposure, and the slave trade later added malaria and yellow fever from Africa. War, famine, enslavement and the breakdown of communities made each outbreak deadlier. The scale of the loss is uncertain because no one knows how many people lived in the Americas in 1492. Estimates range from under twenty million to over a hundred million, and that uncertainty should be kept in mind whenever a single figure is quoted.

The traffic was not entirely one way. Syphilis appeared in Europe in the 1490s, and many scholars think it came from the Americas, though others argue it was present earlier and only newly recognized. The origin of syphilis remains a live debate among scholars.

A mark on the planet

Some scientists think the collapse left a trace in the atmosphere. In 2015 the researchers Simon Lewis and Mark Maslin pointed to a dip in carbon dioxide recorded in Antarctic ice around 1610. Their argument is that as farm fields in the Americas were abandoned and forests regrew, the trees drew carbon out of the air. They proposed the dip as one possible starting point for a new geological age shaped by humans. Other scientists dispute both the cause and the proposal, but the idea shows how far the effects of contact may have reached.

Worked example: a dish from Goa

Take vindaloo, a dish associated with Goa, the Portuguese capital in India. Its name comes from a Portuguese dish of meat in wine and garlic, carne de vinha d'alhos. In Goa the wine became vinegar, and local cooks added spices.

Now trace the ingredients. The chili that gives it heat came from the Americas, by way of Portuguese ships. The potato often added to it today came from the Andes. The pork reflects Portuguese and Christian tastes in a region where many cooks would have used other meats. The black pepper, cinnamon and cloves were the very spices that drew the Portuguese to Asia in the first place.

A single plate holds the whole story: Asian spices that pulled Europeans across the ocean, American plants carried back the other way, and a local kitchen that made something new from both. The same exercise works for tomato sauce in Italy, chocolate in Switzerland or maize porridge in southern Africa. Familiar national dishes are often less than five centuries old in their present form.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How quickly did chili peppers enter Indian cooking?
2. Why did cassava spread across Central Africa?
3. What share of Old World population growth from 1700 to 1900 did Nunn and Qian link to the potato?
4. What did Elinor Melville find in the Mezquital Valley?
5. Which peoples built new ways of life around the horse?
6. What do scholars say about where syphilis came from?
7. Why do Lewis and Maslin think carbon dioxide dipped around 1610?
8. Why is the number of deaths after contact uncertain?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia