Skip to main content

The ocean that was already busy

The story of exploration is often told as if Europeans sailed out into an empty world. In 1400 the busiest sea lanes on the planet lay far from Europe. The Indian Ocean trade ran on the monsoon, winds that blow from the southwest in summer and from the northeast in winter. A merchant from Gujarat could sail to East Africa on one season's wind and come home on the next. Ports such as Calicut on India's Malabar coast, Melaka on the strait between Sumatra and the Malay Peninsula, Hormuz at the mouth of the Persian Gulf and Kilwa on the Swahili coast linked Chinese porcelain, Indian cotton, Southeast Asian spices, Arabian horses and African gold and ivory.

No single power ruled this ocean. Trade was mostly carried by private merchants, many of them Muslims, along with Hindu, Jewish, Armenian and Chinese traders, and port rulers grew rich by keeping their harbors open and their customs duties moderate. This point matters for everything that follows: the newcomers who arrived after 1498 did not create long distance trade in Asia. They forced their way into a system that already worked.

China's great fleets

Between 1405 and 1433 the Ming court sent the admiral Zheng He on huge state voyages across this ocean, carrying gifts, collecting tribute and displaying the emperor's power. The fleets dwarfed anything Europe would send for a century. How large the biggest ships were is still argued over. Some later Chinese texts describe treasure ships well over a hundred meters long, but many naval historians doubt the largest size claims, because wooden hulls that long would have been very hard to keep sound. Either way, the voyages ended, and the Ming state turned its attention to its northern frontier. China kept trading, through private and often illegal merchants, but the state did not try to build a sea empire.

Why Europe looked outward

Europe at the start of the fifteenth century sat at the far end of these networks. Pepper, cloves, nutmeg and cinnamon reached it after passing through many hands, with each middleman taking a share, so that Venice and Genoa grew rich by buying in Egyptian and Levantine ports. Gold was the other great lure. West African gold had crossed the Sahara by camel for centuries, and Europeans wanted to reach its source directly.

An old textbook explanation says that the Ottoman capture of Constantinople in 1453 cut off the spice routes and forced Europeans to find new ones. Historians have largely abandoned this. Portuguese voyages down the African coast began decades before 1453, and Venetian spice imports through Egypt carried on afterward. The motives were older and more mixed: profit, crusading zeal, the search for Christian allies against Islam, and the ambitions of nobles who had no land at home. Many Europeans believed in Prester John, a legendary Christian king somewhere beyond the Muslim world. The real Christian kingdom of Ethiopia gave the legend some basis.

Portugal's head start

Portugal was small and poor, but it faced the Atlantic, had been free of internal war since the 1380s and had a monarchy willing to back risky ventures. In 1415 a Portuguese force captured Ceuta, a Muslim port in North Africa across from Gibraltar. Ceuta did not make Portugal rich, but it gave its nobles a taste for overseas war and showed them the gold caravans that ended there.

Among the leaders at Ceuta was a younger son of the king, Prince Henry. He later sponsored many voyages down the African coast and took a share of their profits. English writers of the nineteenth century gave him the title "the Navigator" and pictured him running a school of navigation at Sagres. Historians now doubt that any such school existed, and Henry himself never sailed beyond North Africa. He was a patron, a crusader and a businessman, not a scientist.

The Atlantic islands

The first real gains were islands. Portuguese settlers moved onto uninhabited Madeira in the 1420s and the Azores in the following decades. On Madeira, colonists cleared forests and planted sugar cane, worked increasingly by enslaved people. Madeira's sugar estates became an early model for the plantation system later carried across the Atlantic. The Canary Islands were different: they had a native people, the Guanches, and Castile conquered them over most of the fifteenth century, finishing in 1496. The Canaries became a testing ground for conquest, conversion and forced labor before Columbus ever sailed.

Worked example: two ways to go to sea

Compare a Ming fleet of the 1410s with a pair of Portuguese ships of the 1440s. The Ming fleet carried thousands of men and could visit dozens of ports, but its purpose was diplomatic display, and it existed only as long as the court paid for it. When the court lost interest, the knowledge and the shipyards faded.

The Portuguese ships were tiny, perhaps a few dozen men each, and each voyage pushed only a little farther south. Yet the voyages were cheap enough to repeat year after year, and they were tied to profit: every new stretch of coast could yield gold, slaves, ivory or pepper, which paid for the next voyage. Merchants, nobles and the crown all had reasons to keep going.

The lesson is not that one civilization was bolder than another. A state at the center of a rich trading world had little reason to keep spending on distant voyages. A small kingdom on the edge had every reason to search for a way in. Where a society stands in the world shapes what it is willing to risk.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What drove the seasonal rhythm of Indian Ocean trade?
2. Who carried most Indian Ocean trade around 1400?
3. Why do many naval historians doubt the largest Zheng He ship sizes?
4. What weakens the claim that the fall of Constantinople set off the voyages?
5. What did Portugal capture in 1415?
6. What do historians now say about Prince Henry?
7. Why does Madeira matter in the history of the Atlantic?
8. Who were the Guanches?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia