If you want to do good with your career, the obvious path is to work for a charity, a hospital or a public agency. Early effective altruists proposed a surprising alternative, and it became one of the movement's best known and most criticized ideas.
The idea
Earning to give means deliberately choosing a high-paying career in order to donate a large share of the income. A banker or software engineer who gives away half of a large salary might, on this reasoning, pay for the work of several people at an effective charity. The idea struck many as backward.
The replaceability argument
The case rests on replaceability. If you take a job at a good charity, the charity would probably have hired someone else nearly as able. On the replaceability view, your real contribution in such a job is the difference between you and your replacement, which may be small. If instead you take a job in finance and give much of your pay away, the person who would otherwise have had that job would probably not have donated it. So the replaceability argument says your counterfactual impact in a direct charity job may be small, because someone nearly as good would take it.
MacAskill set out a version of this reasoning in a 2013 paper. The same logic seems to extend to jobs that cause harm: if a role in a harmful industry will be filled anyway, the extra harm of your taking it may be small. That step is where many critics, and many effective altruists, get off the train.
Early recruits
Some students took the advice. Graduates went into trading, software and startups, pledging large shares of their pay. Among the people MacAskill talked with about earning to give, in 2012, was an MIT student whose later career would put the whole idea under a harsh light.
The advice changes
As very large donors joined the movement, money became less scarce than people able to use it well. 80,000 Hours came to say that only a minority of people should earn to give, and it began to stress research, policy work and direct jobs in neglected fields. The reason was simple: the movement had become shorter of skilled people than of money. Advice also turned toward personal fit. Personal fit is how well suited you are to a particular role, which strongly affects how much good you do in it. A brilliant researcher who would be a mediocre trader may do more good in the lab.
Objections
Earning to give drew several lines of attack. The first concerns character. Working for years in a high-pressure, high-paying field may change a person. Value drift is the worry that a commitment to giving fades as people grow used to wealth.
The second concerns complicity. Some well-paid jobs cause harm directly, by selling dangerous products, evading regulation or deceiving customers. Calculating that the donations outweigh the harm treats wrongdoing as a cost to be offset, which many moral traditions reject. Most effective altruist writers advised against high-paying jobs that cause serious direct harm, on moral grounds and on practical ones, since harmful work often corrupts judgment and invites scandal.
The third concerns the system. If the wealth comes from an economic order that helps produce the poverty being relieved, then earning to give may treat symptoms while strengthening causes. A fourth concerns power: a person who gives millions acquires influence over which causes thrive, without being answerable to the people those causes affect.
Defenders' reply
Defenders answer that most high-paying jobs are not harmful, that money given to proven health charities saves lives whatever its source. They also note that the movement's advice changed when the facts changed, which is what a question-driven approach should do.
Worked example: the trader and the researcher
Priya is finishing a mathematics degree. She has two offers: a trading job paying 200,000 dollars a year and a research post at a malaria charity paying 60,000. If she takes the trading job and gives half her salary, she donates 100,000 dollars a year, perhaps enough to fund one or two researchers like herself and still leave a comfortable living.
Now apply the tools. Replaceability: how hard would the charity find it to hire someone nearly as good? If the post needs rare skills, her replacement might be much weaker, and her direct contribution larger than it looks. Personal fit: does she want to trade, or will she be miserable and burn out? Value drift: will she still give half in ten years, surrounded by colleagues who spend freely? Complicity: does this particular firm deal honestly with its clients?
No formula settles Priya's choice. What the framework does is turn a vague hope of doing good into specific questions she can investigate, and its critics add questions of their own about who she will become and whom she will answer to.
