In the summer of 1929 the United States produced more cars, radios and electricity than ever before, and most experts expected the good times to last. Four years later about a quarter of American workers had no job, world trade had shrunk to a third of its former value, and democracies on several continents were close to collapse. The roots of that fall lie in the world the First World War left behind, where prosperity was real but rested on weak foundations.
A web of war debts and reparations
The war turned the United States from a debtor into the world's largest creditor. Britain and France had borrowed heavily from American lenders and from the American government to pay for the fighting, and Washington insisted that these war debts be repaid. Britain and France, in turn, expected Germany to pay reparations under the peace settlement of 1919. Germany could not pay from its own surplus, and when payments stopped in 1923, French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr and German money collapsed in hyperinflation.
The fix came in 1924 with the Dawes Plan, which lowered Germany's yearly reparation payments and arranged a large international loan, much of it raised in New York. Over the next few years American investors poured money into German cities, firms and banks. The result was a circle of payments. American loans let Germany pay reparations, which let Britain and France repay their war debts to the United States. The circle worked only as long as American money kept flowing outward.
The restored gold standard
Before 1914 most major currencies had been tied to gold. Under a gold standard, a country promised to exchange its paper money for a fixed weight of gold. That promise limited how much money central banks could create. Nearly every country suspended it during the war and worked to restore it afterward.
The restoration was uneven. In 1925 Britain, with Winston Churchill as Chancellor of the Exchequer, returned to gold at the prewar rate of 4.86 dollars to the pound. Many economists, John Maynard Keynes among them, argued that this rate overvalued the pound, making British exports too expensive and forcing wages and prices down. France returned at a much lower rate in 1926 to 1928, which made its goods cheap abroad and drew gold into French vaults. The United States also accumulated gold. Under the informal "rules of the game," a country gaining gold was supposed to let its money supply expand, which would spread the gold back out. The United States and France often kept the gold from expanding their money supplies, a practice called sterilization, so other countries had to keep tightening to defend their own currencies.
Weak spots inside the boom
Even in the good years, some parts of the world economy were sick. During the war, farmers in the Americas and Australia had expanded production to feed Europe. When European farms recovered, prices for wheat, sugar, coffee, cotton and rubber fell through the 1920s, and many farmers who had borrowed to buy land fell into debt.
In the United States the gains of the decade went disproportionately to the top, and much of the spending on new goods was financed by installment credit. Rural banks failed by the hundreds each year even before 1929, because farm borrowers could not pay. Banking was split into thousands of small, single-office banks with no national deposit insurance. The Federal Reserve, founded in 1913, was still young, and its regional banks often disagreed about what it should do.
The squeeze of 1928
From 1927 to 1929 American share prices climbed fast, fueled partly by buying "on margin," with borrowed money. Worried about speculation, the Federal Reserve raised interest rates in 1928 and 1929. Higher American rates made it more attractive to keep money at home or lend it to stock speculators, and American lending abroad fell sharply from the middle of 1928. Germany, Australia, Argentina and Brazil, which depended on that money, began to slow down before the famous crash of October 1929.
Historians weigh these weaknesses differently, but most agree that the 1920s left many points where a shock could spread.
Worked example: following one dollar around the circle
Imagine an investor in Ohio in 1926 who buys a bond issued by a German city to build a tram line. Her dollars travel to Germany. Germany, growing on such loans, sends reparations to France and Britain, which use some of the money to pay their war debts to the United States. Part of her dollar comes home to the American government.
Now suppose that in 1928 the investor sees she can earn more by lending to stock buyers in New York. She stops buying German bonds. The tram line stays half built, German cities cut spending, and Berlin finds it harder to pay France and Britain, which find it harder to pay Washington. Nothing in Germany had changed, yet a decision in Ohio, multiplied by thousands of investors, tightened the whole circle. That dependence explains why American trouble traveled so fast.
