Skip to main content

Most lenders want to be repaid. A predatory lender's business works differently: it can profit even when, or especially when, the borrower struggles. Telling predatory lending apart from legitimate but expensive credit is one of the hardest problems in consumer protection, and one of the most important for people with little money.

What makes lending predatory

There is no single legal definition, but regulators and researchers point to common features: fees hidden in fine print, pressure to borrow more than needed, repeated refinancing that adds fees each time, and lending without checking whether the borrower can repay. The core idea is that predatory lending profits from the borrower's failure or confusion rather than from repayment. A loan designed to be renewed again and again, each time with a new fee, earns more from a borrower who cannot escape than from one who pays and leaves.

Payday and title loans

A payday loan is a small, short loan, often a few hundred dollars due on the borrower's next payday. A typical American fee is about 15 for every 100 borrowed for two weeks, which works out to an APR near 400 percent. The main problem is less the single loan than the cycle. A 2014 study by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found that most payday loans were rolled over or followed by another loan within two weeks. Many borrowers ended up paying more in fees than they had originally borrowed.

Auto title loans work similarly but use the borrower's car as collateral. In about one in five sequences of single-payment title loans, the borrower's car was seized, according to a later study by the same agency. Losing a car can mean losing a job, which deepens the hole.

The case for expensive credit

Defenders of these lenders make serious arguments. Defenders argue that high fees may reflect the real cost of small, risky loans, which are expensive to process and often go unpaid, rather than simple greed. A person facing a utility shutoff or a bounced check fee may rationally choose a payday loan as the cheaper evil. Some studies found that when states banned payday loans, borrowers turned to overdrafts, pawnshops or unlicensed lenders. Other studies found that access to payday loans made it harder for families to pay rent and other bills. The evidence is genuinely mixed, and an honest conclusion is that banning a product without offering a better alternative may simply move the harm elsewhere.

An old problem, an old compromise

The struggle is not new. Around 1900, American cities were full of "salary lenders" and loan sharks who charged huge rates to workers and enforced repayment through shame and harassment. Reformers at the Russell Sage Foundation took an unusual approach. Instead of banning small loans, they drafted a model law that licensed small lenders and let them charge more than old usury limits allowed, up to about 3.5 percent a month. The Uniform Small Loan Law of 1916 aimed to drive out loan sharks by letting licensed lenders charge higher legal rates, enough to make honest small lending profitable. Today a widely used benchmark is a 36 percent APR cap, which the United States applies to most loans to active-duty service members.

Scarcity and the mind

Why do people take loans they know are costly? The economist Sendhil Mullainathan and the psychologist Eldar Shafir argued in their book Scarcity (2013) that scarcity narrows attention onto the urgent problem, which the authors called tunneling. A person who must pay rent by Friday focuses on Friday, and a payday loan solves Friday. Next month's fees fall outside the tunnel. In one study, Indian sugarcane farmers scored worse on reasoning tests before harvest, when money was tight, than after they were paid, though they were the same people. The lesson is not that poor people choose badly but that scarcity itself taxes judgment, and lenders who understand this can exploit it.

This has a dignity side. A borrower in crisis is still a person entitled to honest dealing. Rules that require clear prices, checks on ability to repay and limits on endless renewals aim to keep credit available without letting it turn into a trap.

Worked example: Dana's car repair

Dana's car needs a 600 repair, and she needs the car to get to work. A storefront lender offers a payday loan for a 90 fee, due in two weeks. Dana could repay 690 in two weeks only by missing rent, so the honest forecast is that she will roll the loan over, paying 90 again and again. Before signing, she checks other options. Her credit union offers a small loan at 28 percent APR, repayable over six months. The garage accepts payment in three installments. Her employer offers a pay advance once a year. Each option costs something, but none is built to depend on her failing. The test she applies is simple: if things go slightly wrong, does this loan let me get out, or does it profit from keeping me in?

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is the core feature of predatory lending?
2. What did the 2014 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau study find about payday loans?
3. How often did single-payment title loan sequences end with the car seized?
4. What do defenders say about payday lenders' high fees?
5. How did the Uniform Small Loan Law of 1916 try to drive out loan sharks?
6. What did Mullainathan and Shafir mean by tunneling?
7. What did the study of Indian sugarcane farmers find?
8. Which US borrowers are covered by a 36 percent APR cap on most loans?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia