Skip to main content

Most crusaders never saw Jerusalem. Popes extended the vow, the cross and the spiritual rewards to wars on Europe's own edges: against Muslim powers in the Iberian peninsula and against pagan peoples around the Baltic Sea. These frontiers lasted far longer than the crusader states and changed the map of Europe more.

Iberia: a frontier of many faiths

Christian kingdoms in northern Spain and Portugal had fought Muslim al-Andalus long before 1095, often allying with Muslim rulers against fellow Christians. The papacy linked this frontier to the crusade almost at once. Around the time of Clermont, Urban II told Catalan knights that they could earn the same spiritual reward by restoring Tarragona as by going to Jerusalem, and later popes formally granted crusade privileges for Iberian wars.

The frontier drew in northern crusaders on their way east. In 1147 a fleet of crusaders bound for the Holy Land helped the king of Portugal take Lisbon, one of the few successes of the Second Crusade. Military orders on the model of the Templars appeared, such as Calatrava and Santiago. On the Muslim side, Berber dynasties from North Africa, first the Almoravids and then the Almohads, crossed the strait to defend al-Andalus. At Las Navas de Tolosa in 1212, allied Christian kings defeated the Almohads, opening the south. Córdoba fell in 1236 and Seville in 1248, leaving Granada as the last Muslim state. Kings drew settlers south with town charters, called fueros, that offered land, tax breaks and local self-government.

Conquest did not mean everyone left. Muslims who lived under Christian rule in Iberia were called Mudéjars, and for centuries they farmed, built and paid taxes under negotiated terms, as Christians had under Muslim rule. Their position worsened over time, ending in forced conversion and expulsion.

Historians are wary of the familiar label for all this. The word Reconquista is a modern label that became popular in the 1800s, and it suggests a single, planned recovery of a lost Christian homeland over almost eight centuries. The reality was messier. The most famous Castilian warrior, Rodrigo Díaz, known as El Cid, fought for the Muslim ruler of Zaragoza as well as for Christian kings, before taking Valencia for himself in 1094.

The Baltic: crusade as conquest

Around the Baltic lived peoples who still worshipped their own gods: Wends, Prussians, Livonians, Estonians and Lithuanians. In 1147 Bernard of Clairvaux won crusade status for a campaign against the Wends east of the Elbe. Later, German merchants and bishops pushed into Livonia, and the bishop of Riga founded a military order, the Sword Brothers, in 1202.

The decisive force was another order. The Teutonic Order, founded in the Holy Land, began conquering pagan Prussia in the 1230s, invited by a Polish duke who wanted protection from Prussian raids. The order absorbed the Sword Brothers, built castles and towns, settled German colonists and turned Prussia into its own state. In 1242 the order's push into Russian lands was checked by Prince Alexander Nevsky of Novgorod in a battle on the frozen Lake Peipus, later made famous by a Soviet film. Knights from all over Europe came for seasonal campaigns. Chaucer's Knight in the Canterbury Tales is one: "In Lettow hadde he reysed and in Ruce," meaning he had campaigned in Lithuania and Russia. Lithuania's rulers resisted until Grand Duke Jogaila accepted baptism and married the Polish queen in 1386, and in 1410 a Polish and Lithuanian army crushed the order at Grunwald. Its Prussian state survived the defeat, though it lost lands and paid a heavy indemnity, until in 1525 its last Grand Master there, Albert of Hohenzollern, became a Lutheran and turned the territory into a secular duchy.

Was it still a crusade once the enemy was Christian? Poland argued its case before the Council of Constance. There Paulus Vladimiri argued that pagans living in peace had a right to their lands and could not be attacked simply for their unbelief, an early argument that political rights do not depend on religion.

Worked example: conversion by conquest

The best narrative of the Livonian crusade is the chronicle of Henry of Livonia, a priest who worked there in the early 1200s. He presents the war as a mission bringing souls to Christ, and he is honest enough to record what that meant: villages burned, hostages taken, baptism accepted under threat and tribute imposed. Read him alongside other evidence. Archaeology shows the old hill forts abandoned and new stone castles built by the conquerors. Language tells a slower story: Old Prussian, the language of the conquered Prussians, faded under German rule and had died out by around 1700.

Three lessons follow. A source can be partisan and still useful, because a believer may record without shame what we now find shocking. Silence matters, since the conquered peoples left almost no written voice of their own. And the effects of a crusade can outlast its fighting by centuries, in who owned the land, which language people spoke and whose history got written down.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Urban II tell Catalan knights about Tarragona?
2. How was Lisbon taken in 1147?
3. What happened at Las Navas de Tolosa in 1212?
4. What were Muslims living under Christian rule in Iberia called?
5. Why are historians wary of the word Reconquista?
6. Whom did El Cid serve besides Christian kings?
7. What did the Teutonic Order begin conquering in the 1230s?
8. What did Paulus Vladimiri argue at the Council of Constance?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia