Skip to main content

From the start the Commune lived under the threat of attack. Thiers had withdrawn to Versailles to gather an army, and within two weeks of the Commune's proclamation the two sides were at war. The pressures of that war divided the Commune, tested its principles and produced choices that its admirers and critics still debate.

The first battles

On 2 April Versailles troops attacked Commune forces at Courbevoie, west of the city, and shot several prisoners. The next day the Commune launched a march on Versailles in several columns. It was poorly planned and quickly broken up by artillery fire from the fort of Mont-Valérien, which the insurgents had wrongly assumed would not fire. The march failed, and two of its generals, Gustave Flourens and Émile Duval, were killed after being captured.

From then on the war was mostly a siege of Paris by French troops. Versailles shelled the western districts and slowly took outlying forts and villages. Bismarck helped Thiers indirectly by releasing French prisoners of war to swell the Versailles army, which grew to about 130,000 men under Marshal Patrice de MacMahon. The Germans, still camped to the north and east, watched.

The hostages

Angered by the killing of prisoners, the Commune passed a decree on hostages on 5 April. Anyone accused of complicity with Versailles could be held, and it threatened that each execution of a Commune prisoner would be answered by the execution of three hostages. Among those arrested was Georges Darboy, the archbishop of Paris. The Commune offered to exchange him and others for Blanqui, held by the Versailles government. Thiers refused to release Blanqui, judging that he would be worth an army to the insurgents. For weeks the threat was not carried out.

Attempts at peace

Moderates on both sides looked for a compromise. Republican leagues formed to defend the rights of Paris while condemning civil war, and delegates from provincial towns traveled to Versailles to plead for terms. On 29 April thousands of Freemasons marched to the ramparts, planted their banners in sight of the Versailles lines and asked for a truce. Thiers offered little beyond pardon for those who laid down their arms, excluding the killers of the generals. He insisted that the law must be restored in Paris, and the Commune would not dissolve itself. With each side convinced that the other was the aggressor, the middle ground vanished.

Military disorder

The Commune's forces were brave but badly organized. Battalions elected their officers, ignored orders they disliked and often failed to relieve exhausted units. The delegate for war, Gustave Cluseret, was arrested at the end of April. His successor, Louis Rossel, a young professional officer who had joined the Commune because he refused to accept the surrender to Germany, tried to impose discipline. After the fort of Issy fell, Rossel resigned in disgust on 9 May, complaining publicly that he could not command. The veteran Delescluze, a civilian, took over the war effort.

The Committee of Public Safety

As defeats mounted, many members wanted a stronger executive. On 1 May the Commune voted 45 to 23 to create a Committee of Public Safety, named after the body that had directed the Terror of 1793 and 1794. The majority, mostly Jacobins and Blanquists, believed a besieged revolution needed concentrated power. The minority, many of them members of the International such as Varlin, argued that the new body betrayed the Commune's own principles of open, accountable government.

On 15 May the minority published a declaration protesting that the Commune had handed its powers to a dictatorship. Meanwhile the Commune closed hostile newspapers and the police arrested suspected agents of Versailles. The Commune also ordered the demolition of Thiers's town house, a symbolic act that changed nothing militarily.

Worked example: debating the committee

Imagine the debate of 1 May from both sides. A member of the majority speaks first. The army of Versailles is at the gates. Decisions are taken by a large assembly that argues for hours, while the war commission and the commanders blame each other. In 1793, he says, a committee with sweeping powers saved the republic from invasion. Paris needs the same.

A member of the minority replies. The Commune was elected to show that ordinary people could govern themselves in the open, with officials they could recall. If it copies the Terror, it gives up the very thing that makes it worth defending. A committee will not make guardsmen obey; better weapons, pay and organization might.

Now test each argument against what happened. The committee did not reverse the military decline: Issy fell days later and Rossel resigned. Nor did the minority have a convincing plan to save the city. The episode shows a dilemma common to revolutions under siege. Concentrating power can seem the only way to survive, yet it can destroy the principles that gave the revolution its claim. Neither side in the Commune found a way out, and the debate split the leadership in its final weeks.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did the Commune's march on Versailles of 3 April end?
2. How did Bismarck help Thiers rebuild his army?
3. What did the Commune's decree on hostages of 5 April threaten?
4. Whom did the Commune offer to exchange for Archbishop Darboy and others?
5. Why did Louis Rossel resign as delegate for war on 9 May?
6. By what vote did the Commune create its Committee of Public Safety?
7. What did the minority argue about the Committee of Public Safety?
8. What did thousands of Freemasons do on 29 April 1871?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia