Skip to main content

The question everyone argues about

Basic economics says that adding supply, with demand unchanged, lowers prices. Housing complicates the story. A home lasts a century, it is fixed in place, and a single new building may be expensive, while the people struggling most need cheap homes. Many residents look at a glassy new tower and conclude, reasonably enough, that it will do nothing for them or might even raise rents nearby. Researchers have spent the last decade testing that worry.

Filtering

Most affordable homes in rich countries were not built to be affordable. They were built for middle-class or wealthy buyers and became cheaper as they aged, while their first owners moved on to newer places. Filtering is the process by which housing becomes cheaper as it ages and passes to lower-income households. It is how a Victorian mansion becomes a set of student flats, or a 1970s suburb becomes a starter neighborhood.

Filtering depends on supply. When too little is built, filtering can run in reverse, as higher-income households compete for older homes and renovate them, so that cheap housing becomes expensive again. Research on the United States has found that in metro areas with tight supply, older homes have often moved up market rather than down.

Chains of moves

A newer line of research follows people rather than buildings. When someone moves into a new flat, they leave a home behind, and someone else moves into that one, and so on. Using address histories, the economist Evan Mast traced these chains in large American cities. He found that new market-rate buildings free up homes in lower-income areas through chains of moves: for every hundred new expensive units, roughly half as many or more opened up in below-median-income neighborhoods within a few years. Studies of Helsinki found similar chains reaching low-income areas surprisingly quickly.

Next door to the new building

Another worry is local. Does a big new building signal that a neighborhood is changing, drawing wealthier newcomers and raising nearby rents? Brian Asquith, Evan Mast and Davin Reed studied large new buildings in low-income areas of several American cities. They found that nearby rents ended up about 5 to 7 percent lower than they would otherwise have been, and that the buildings drew in more people from low-income neighborhoods than expected. The supply effect, at least in these cases, outweighed the signal.

The skeptics' best case

Skeptics of a supply-first approach make several strong points. Studies of average effects can hide real harms to particular families, such as tenants evicted when an old building is torn down for a new one. A city can add homes for decades and still see prices rise if jobs and incomes grow faster. Developers build where returns are highest, which may not be where needs are greatest. And chains of moves take time, while a family facing a rent increase needs help now.

The most important point is one that many builders also accept: markets rarely produce new homes cheap enough for the poorest households without public subsidy. New construction costs a great deal, and only older housing or public money can reach the bottom of the income scale. A review of the evidence by Vicki Been, Ingrid Gould Ellen and Katherine O'Regan concluded that adding supply does moderate prices, but that it works best paired with subsidies and protections for those most at risk.

YIMBYs and their critics

The acronym NIMBY, "not in my back yard", spread in the 1980s to describe residents who oppose nearby projects. In the 2010s a counter-movement took the name YIMBY, "yes in my back yard". The YIMBY movement campaigns for rules that allow more homes to be built, often through state or national laws. It has drawn an unusual coalition, from free-market economists to environmentalists who want people living near transit.

Critics on the left call this trickle-down housing and argue that it hands profits to developers while ignoring displacement. Some conservatives worry about losing the character of established neighborhoods. The evidence suggests that both sides are partly right. Supply matters a great deal over time, and so does protecting people during the transition.

Worked example: the station building

A town considers a two-hundred-unit apartment building beside a commuter rail station, on land now used for a car dealership. Rents in the new building will be high. Opponents argue it will serve only newcomers with money.

Trace the effects. No current tenants are displaced, because the site holds no homes. Two hundred households move in. Some come from older flats in the same town, which open up for others, who leave homes in turn: the chain reaches cheaper neighborhoods within a few years. Some come from outside the region, adding demand. The research suggests rents nearby end up a little lower than they would have been. What the building cannot do alone is house the town's poorest families. A council that wants that might require some below-market units, add a subsidy, or pair the approval with tenant protections elsewhere. Seeing the chain does not settle the vote, but it changes what the argument is about.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is filtering in housing?
2. What can happen to filtering when too little is built?
3. What did Evan Mast find about new market-rate buildings?
4. What did Asquith, Mast and Reed find about rents near large new buildings in low-income areas?
5. What point do many supporters and skeptics of new building agree on?
6. What did the review by Been, Ellen and O'Regan conclude?
7. What does the YIMBY movement campaign for?
8. What kind of coalition has the YIMBY movement drawn?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia