Skip to main content

Charles, whom later ages called Charlemagne (from Carolus Magnus, Charles the Great), was probably born in 748, though some scholars still prefer 742. He ruled from 768 until his death in 814, and in almost every one of those years his armies went on campaign. War was how a Frankish king kept the loyalty of nobles who expected plunder, land and offices in return.

The Lombard kingdom

The first great conquest came in Italy. When Carloman died in 771, his widow and sons fled to Desiderius, king of the Lombards, who also pressed the pope for land. Charles crossed the Alps in 773 and besieged the Lombard capital, Pavia, for months. In 774 Desiderius surrendered and was sent to a monastery. After Pavia fell, Charles took the title king of the Franks and of the Lombards. He kept it as a separate realm, and in 781 had his young son Pippin anointed its king.

The Saxon wars

The longest and cruelest wars were fought against the Saxons, pagan peoples living between the Rhine and the Elbe, who had long raided Frankish lands. The fighting lasted, on and off, from 772 to 804. In 772 Charlemagne destroyed the Irminsul, a sacred pillar or tree at the heart of Saxon worship, and seized its treasure. The Saxons rebelled again and again, led for years by a noble named Widukind. In 782 Charles ordered the killing of a large number of Saxon prisoners at Verden. Three years later Widukind gave up. In 785 Widukind was baptized, with Charlemagne as his godfather.

Conquest came with forced conversion. A royal decree for Saxony, usually dated to the 780s, laid down harsh penalties. The Capitulary for the Saxon regions punished refusing baptism with death, along with eating meat during Lent and burning the bodies of the dead in the old way. Not every churchman approved. Alcuin, the king's leading scholar, argued that faith must be freely chosen, since belief comes from the will and cannot be forced, and he urged that Saxons be taught before they were baptized. In 797 a milder decree replaced many death penalties with fines, though the Franks also deported thousands of Saxons and settled Franks in their place. The debate over whether belief can be compelled is one of the earliest recorded arguments in Europe for freedom of conscience.

Bavaria and the Avars

Charles also tightened his grip on Christian neighbors. Bavaria was ruled by his cousin Duke Tassilo III, who had once sworn loyalty to Pippin and then acted on his own. Accused of plotting with the Avars, Tassilo III was deposed in 788 and sent to a monastery, and Bavaria came under direct Frankish rule.

That brought the Franks face to face with the Avars, a people of nomadic origin who had ruled the plains of the middle Danube for two centuries and grown rich on tribute from Constantinople. After a first campaign in 791, Frankish forces stormed the Avars' main fortified camp, known as the Ring, in 795 and 796. The capture of the Avar Ring brought the Franks a vast treasure, which Charles shared out among churches, nobles and allies, including the pope. The Avar realm never recovered.

Spain and Roncesvalles

Not every campaign succeeded. In 778 rebel Muslim governors in northern Spain invited Charles to help them against the Umayyad emir of Córdoba, Abd al-Rahman I. Charles marched south, but the city of Zaragoza shut its gates, and he turned back, pulling down the walls of Pamplona on the way. At Roncesvalles in the Pyrenees, Basques ambushed the Frankish rear guard on 15 August 778 and killed many leading men. The Franks returned to Spain later and more patiently. In 801 Charles's son Louis captured Barcelona, and a frontier zone called the Spanish March took shape south of the mountains.

Why so much war?

By around 800 Charles ruled most of western continental Europe, from the North Sea to central Italy and from the Pyrenees to the Elbe. Expansion fed the system: every new conquest supplied rewards for the men who fought. Some historians argue that once conquests slowed after about 800, plunder and tribute dried up and loyalty grew harder to hold.

Worked example: three versions of Roncesvalles

Compare how the defeat of 778 was told over time. The earliest version of the Royal Frankish Annals, written at court, describes the Spanish campaign and says nothing about any ambush. A revised version of the annals, prepared after about 814, admits that the rear guard was attacked in the mountains and that many nobles died. Einhard's Life of Charlemagne, written later still, blames the treachery of the Basques and the rough ground, and names among the dead Hruodland, prefect of the Breton frontier.

Around 1100 that minor name became the hero of the Song of Roland, the most famous epic in Old French. In the poem the attackers are not Christian Basques but a huge Muslim army, Roland is Charlemagne's nephew, and the battle becomes a holy war. The pattern is instructive: a court source stays silent about an embarrassment, later sources admit it once the danger has passed, and centuries later memory is reshaped for the crusading age. Each version tells us most about the people who wrote it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What title did Charles take after Pavia fell in 774?
2. What did Charlemagne destroy in Saxony in 772?
3. What happened to the Saxon leader Widukind in 785?
4. Which of these did the Capitulary for the Saxon regions punish with death?
5. What did Alcuin argue about the forced conversion of the Saxons?
6. What happened to Duke Tassilo III of Bavaria in 788?
7. What did the capture of the Avar Ring in 795 and 796 bring the Franks?
8. Who ambushed the Frankish rear guard at Roncesvalles in 778?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia