Skip to main content

By 1826 Spain had lost every mainland colony in the Americas. What had been won? The answer depends on who is asking. Creole elites gained power over their own affairs. Trade opened to the world. Legal castes and noble titles were abolished, and most constitutions promised equal citizenship. But the wars had killed hundreds of thousands, wrecked mines and farms, and left behind armies, debts and leaders who had learned to settle disputes by force.

Recognition and the great powers

The United States began recognizing the new states in 1822. In December 1823 President James Monroe told Congress that the Americas were closed to new European colonies and that any European attempt to restore Spain's empire would be seen as unfriendly. The United States could not enforce this; the British navy, which wanted open markets, mattered more. At the end of 1824 Britain announced it would recognize Buenos Aires, Colombia and Mexico. In 1826 the British foreign secretary, George Canning, boasted to Parliament: "I called the New World into existence, to redress the balance of the Old." Spain itself refused to accept the loss for years. It sent a small invasion force to Mexico in 1829, which was defeated near Tampico, and Spain did not recognize Mexico's independence until 1836.

Bolívar's last dream

Bolívar hoped to bind the new nations together. In 1826 he called a congress of American states at Panama. Only a handful sent delegates, and only one state ratified its treaties. He also wrote a constitution for Bolivia that provided for a president serving for life who named his successor, which he saw as a way to gain the stability of a monarchy without a crown. Critics saw it as monarchy under another name.

Gran Colombia itself began to come apart. Venezuelans resented rule from Bogotá, Páez rebelled in 1826, and Bolívar took dictatorial powers in 1828. In September 1828 conspirators broke into his palace in Bogotá at night; his companion Manuela Sáenz delayed them while he escaped through a window. In 1830 Venezuela and Ecuador separated, and Sucre was murdered on a mountain road in June. Gravely ill, probably with tuberculosis, Bolívar died near Santa Marta, on the Caribbean coast, in December 1830, aged 47, on his way to an exile he never reached.

The weight of war

The new states began life in trouble. During a speculative boom in the early 1820s several governments borrowed in London, raising loans with a face value of roughly twenty million pounds, and nearly all of these loans went unpaid by the late 1820s. Mining output fell, and taxes on trade became the main source of revenue. Generals who had won the wars expected power, and in many countries a pattern took hold of strongmen, called caudillos, coming to power through armed revolt.

The promises of equality were partly kept. Indian tribute was ended in several places, but in Peru and Bolivia it was soon restored under a new name, because governments needed the money. Most countries did not abolish slavery at independence. Chile abolished slavery in 1823 and Mexico in 1829, but elsewhere free womb laws freed people only slowly, and Venezuela and Peru did not end slavery until 1854. Voting was limited by property or literacy in many constitutions, and women were excluded everywhere.

How historians have changed the story

For much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, national histories told independence as the awakening of nations that had existed in spirit all along. Later historians questioned this. Some stressed social conflict and the narrow creole leadership. Others, writing since the 1990s, emphasized the political revolution inside the Spanish world itself: the juntas, the Cádiz constitution and the elections it brought, through which many ordinary Americans first voted. In this view independence grew out of the monarchy's collapse rather than from long-planned national movements. Nations were as much the result of the wars as their cause.

Worked example: the cult of Bolívar

In Venezuela, Bolívar's remains were brought home from Colombia in 1842. In the 1870s the president Antonio Guzmán Blanco built a national pantheon, placed statues of Bolívar in town squares and named the currency the bolívar. Later governments of every kind, democratic and military, left and right, claimed to be his heirs, and in 1999 the country renamed itself the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. In a well-known study first published in 1969, the Venezuelan historian Germán Carrera Damas argued that this devotion worked like a civic religion, used to lend authority to whoever held power.

The example shows how a historical figure can become a tool of politics. A careful citizen can admire Bolívar's courage and vision while noticing that he also distrusted popular government, freed slaves partly to fill his armies and believed in strong rulers. Rulers who invoke a liberator are not thereby protecting liberty. The best way to honor the generation of independence may be to judge its heirs by the standard it set on paper: equal citizens, governed by law, choosing those who rule them.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did President Monroe tell Congress in December 1823?
2. What did Spain send to Mexico in 1829?
3. What did Bolívar's constitution for Bolivia provide?
4. Where did Bolívar die in December 1830?
5. What happened to most of the London loans raised by the new states?
6. Which new state abolished slavery in 1823?
7. According to many historians since the 1990s, how did independence come about?
8. Which British foreign secretary boasted in 1826 of calling the New World into existence?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia