In northern South America independence became a war of extraordinary cruelty, and its leading figure became the most famous man in the Americas. Simón Bolívar was born in Caracas in 1783 into one of the richest creole families, owners of cacao estates worked by enslaved people. Orphaned young, he traveled in Europe, married and lost his wife to fever within a year, and, according to a later account by his old tutor, swore in Rome in 1805 to free his homeland.
The First Republic and its fall
The Caracas junta went further than most. On 5 July 1811 a Venezuelan congress declared full independence, and a federal constitution followed in December. Miranda returned to command the army. But the republic was weak. Many regions stayed loyal, the poor and the enslaved had little reason to fight for creole planters, and the provinces quarreled. Then, on Holy Thursday, 26 March 1812, an earthquake destroyed much of the city of Caracas and other patriot towns while largely sparing royalist areas. Royalist clergy preached that God was punishing rebellion. Spanish forces under Domingo de Monteverde advanced, and in July Miranda signed a capitulation. Bolívar and other officers, accusing Miranda of betrayal, handed him over to the Spanish at La Guaira. Miranda died in a prison cell in Cádiz in 1816.
Lessons from Cartagena
Bolívar escaped to Cartagena, on the coast of New Granada. There, in December 1812, he wrote the Cartagena Manifesto, explaining the republic's fall. He blamed a weak federal system, tolerance of enemies and reliance on untrained militias instead of a real army. Americans, he argued, were not ready for the gentle forms of government suited to peaceful nations; they needed firm central authority. He would hold that view, in various forms, for the rest of his life.
War to the death
In 1813 Bolívar led a lightning campaign from New Granada into Venezuela, later called the Admirable Campaign, and entered Caracas in August. Grateful towns gave him the title of Liberator. In June, at Trujillo, he had issued a decree threatening death for Spaniards and Canary Islanders who did not actively aid the patriots, while Americans would be spared even if guilty. The aim was to turn a civil war among subjects of the king into a war between nations, and to answer royalist atrocities with terror.
The reply came from the plains. José Tomás Boves, a Spanish-born trader turned royalist commander, raised the llaneros, the horsemen of the Venezuelan plains, many of them of mixed or African descent, by promising them the property of the creole rich. His cavalry destroyed the Second Republic in 1814 with massacres as savage as anything the patriots had done. Boves was killed in battle in December 1814, but the lesson stuck: the lower classes would fight for whoever offered them something.
Morillo, Haiti and a new kind of army
With Ferdinand restored, Spain sent its largest expedition of the wars. General Pablo Morillo landed in Venezuela in 1815 with about ten thousand troops, then besieged Cartagena, which fell in December after months of starvation. By 1816 royal authority was restored across New Granada, and many patriot leaders were executed. Bolívar fled to Jamaica and then to Haiti. Haiti's president, Alexandre Pétion, supplied ships, weapons and money, asking only that Bolívar free the enslaved in the lands he liberated. Bolívar decreed freedom in 1816 for enslaved men who joined his forces, and later pressed congresses to go further.
From 1817 Bolívar based himself on the Orinoco River at Angostura and allied with José Antonio Páez, a llanero chief who brought many plains horsemen over to the patriot side. In 1819 Bolívar made a daring move: he led his army across the flooded plains and over the high Andes into New Granada. On 7 August 1819, at the bridge of Boyacá, he defeated the royal army and took Bogotá. A congress at Angostura then created the Republic of Colombia, uniting Venezuela, New Granada and, on paper, Quito; historians call it Gran Colombia. In 1820 Bolívar and Morillo signed a treaty to regularize the war, ending the war to the death. Victory at Carabobo in June 1821 secured Venezuela.
Worked example: the Jamaica Letter
In September 1815, defeated and in exile in Kingston, Bolívar wrote a long letter to an English resident of the island. It repays reading as a piece of political reasoning. He described Spanish Americans as a people neither Indian nor European, a middle species between the original owners of the land and the Spanish usurpers. He predicted that Spanish America would not form one great republic, that Mexico might try a representative republic with a strong executive, and that Chile's isolation and simple customs gave it a good chance of lasting liberty, while he doubted Peru's prospects. He dreamed of a congress of American nations meeting at Panama.
Notice what the letter does. It builds a case for independence aimed at a foreign audience, especially Britain, whose help Bolívar needed. It shows real insight into regional differences, and several predictions proved shrewd. It also treats the people he wanted to lead as a problem to be managed, and its "we" is plainly the creole elite, with Indigenous and African Americans at the margins.
