Skip to main content

New Spain, the richest part of the empire, took a different path. In 1808 the viceroy, José de Iturrigaray, seemed willing to call an assembly of the realm, as creole members of the Mexico City council urged. In September 1808 Spanish merchants in Mexico City broke into his palace and removed him. That coup closed the legal route to self-government. When change came, it came from below, and it was violent.

Hidalgo's rising

Creole conspirators in Querétaro planned a rising for late 1810. When the plot was discovered, the parish priest of the town of Dolores, Miguel Hidalgo, called his parishioners to revolt on 16 September 1810. He was 57, a scholar who had read banned French books and had set up workshops for his parishioners. His followers were mostly Indigenous and mixed-race villagers and mine workers, many hit by drought and soaring food prices. They marched behind an image of the Virgin of Guadalupe, the Mexican image of Mary, shouting for Ferdinand and against bad government and Spaniards.

The rising grew to tens of thousands within weeks. At Guanajuato on 28 September, insurgents stormed the public granary, the Alhóndiga de Granaditas, and killed many of those inside, where Spaniards and their families had taken refuge. The massacre horrified creoles who had sympathized with reform. In late October Hidalgo defeated royal troops near Mexico City at Monte de las Cruces, but then turned back rather than attack the capital. In Guadalajara in December he decreed an end to slavery and to Indian tribute. In January 1811 his army was crushed at Calderón Bridge by General Félix Calleja. Hidalgo was captured, stripped of his priesthood and shot in Chihuahua in July 1811. His head, with those of three other leaders, hung in iron cages at the granary in Guanajuato for ten years.

Morelos and a program for a nation

The insurgency did not die with Hidalgo. José María Morelos, another priest of humble, mixed origins, built a smaller, disciplined army in the south. He held the town of Cuautla through a royal siege of more than two months in 1812 and took Oaxaca and Acapulco. In 1813 he called a congress at Chilpancingo, which declared Mexico's independence, and he presented it with a statement of principles called the Sentiments of the Nation. In 1814 the congress issued a constitution at Apatzingán. Royal forces pressed the rebels hard, and Morelos was captured in November 1815 and executed in December. Leaders such as Vicente Guerrero kept up a guerrilla war in the southern mountains, but by 1820 the insurgency seemed contained.

Why royalism held

Why did New Spain's royal government survive a decade of rebellion? Calleja organized local militias and mobile forces. Many creoles, remembering Guanajuato, sided with order. Bishops excommunicated the insurgent leaders. Royal authorities also applied the Cádiz constitution from 1812 to 1814, holding elections that gave some creoles a voice inside the system. And the insurgents were divided among regional chiefs who often distrusted one another.

The conservative turn of 1820 to 1821

What finally ended Spanish rule was a change in Spain. In 1820 a liberal revolt restored the Cádiz constitution, and the new government in Madrid moved against Church privileges and the special legal rights of the army. Conservative creoles and churchmen who had defended the king now feared the king's liberal government more than independence. Agustín de Iturbide, a creole royal officer who had fought the insurgents, reached an agreement with Guerrero. On 24 February 1821 he issued the Plan of Iguala. Its Three Guarantees were religion, independence and union: the Catholic faith as the sole religion, independence under a monarch, and union of Americans and Europeans as equals. The plan offered something to almost everyone, and royal troops changed sides in large numbers. The newly arrived Spanish official Juan O'Donojú signed the Treaty of Córdoba in August, and the army entered Mexico City in September 1821.

Spain rejected the treaty, so no Bourbon prince came to take the throne. In 1822 Iturbide had himself crowned emperor of Mexico as Agustín I. His empire lasted less than a year. Army officers turned against him, he abdicated in 1823, and Mexico became a federal republic in 1824. When Iturbide returned from exile that year, unaware that he had been outlawed, he was shot. Central America, which had joined his empire, went its own way in 1823.

Worked example: the Sentiments of the Nation

Read Morelos's 1813 document alongside Hidalgo's rising. Morelos declared that sovereignty comes from the people, that slavery should be abolished forever along with distinctions of caste, and that one American should be distinguished from another only by vice and virtue. He called for laws that would moderate both great wealth and poverty and raise the wages of the poor. He would admit only foreigners able to teach useful trades, and he made Catholicism the only permitted religion.

These points show an insurgency becoming a political program: a nation of equal citizens, defined by birth in America rather than by race. They also show its limits for a modern reader, since equality came bundled with religious exclusion. Compare the Plan of Iguala eight years later. It too promised equality, but between creoles and Spaniards, and it said nothing about land or wages. Independence came through the second document, not the first, which helps explain why so many of Morelos's hopes waited another century.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who removed Viceroy Iturrigaray in September 1808?
2. What banner did Hidalgo's followers march behind?
3. What happened at the Alhóndiga de Granaditas in Guanajuato in 1810?
4. What did Hidalgo decree in Guadalajara in December 1810?
5. What happened to Morelos in late 1815?
6. What were the Three Guarantees of the Plan of Iguala?
7. What title did Iturbide take in 1822?
8. What change in Spain in 1820 pushed conservative Mexicans toward independence?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia