Skip to main content

In 1616 a Dutch captain named Dirk Hartog, sailing for Java, ran too far east and landed on an island off the coast of Western Australia. Before leaving he fixed to a post a flattened pewter plate inscribed with the date and his ship's name. The plate, now in the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, is among the oldest surviving European objects from Australia. For the next century and a half, Europeans touched the continent's edges, judged it poor and sailed on. Then, within twenty years, Britain claimed half of it and planted a prison colony on its shore.

The Dutch coast

The first European voyage known to have reached Australia was that of the Duyfken under Willem Janszoon, which in 1606 charted part of the western coast of Cape York Peninsula and clashed with the people living there. A few years later, Dutch East India Company ships began using the strong westerly winds of the far southern Indian Ocean to speed the passage to Java. The route was fast but risky: ships that turned north too late struck the coast of Western Australia. The Dutch named the land New Holland.

The most notorious wreck was the Batavia, which hit a reef off the west coast in 1629. While its commander sailed a small boat to Java for help, a junior merchant named Jeronimus Cornelisz took control of the survivors and led the murder of more than a hundred of them. In 1642 Abel Tasman reached the island he named Van Diemen's Land, now Tasmania. The Company decided the land offered little to trade and lost interest. The English buccaneer William Dampier visited the northwest in 1688 and 1699 and wrote scornfully of what he saw, a view that shaped British opinion for decades.

Cook and the claim

In 1770 James Cook, returning from charting New Zealand, followed the east coast north in the Endeavour. At Botany Bay, two Gweagal men tried to stop the landing, and Cook fired at them. His secret instructions from the Admiralty told him to take possession of convenient places "with the Consent of the Natives." He did not seek that consent. On Possession Island, off the tip of Cape York, he claimed the whole eastern coast for George III, calling it New South Wales. The botanist Joseph Banks, who sailed with him, later recommended Botany Bay as a place to settle.

Why a penal colony?

Britain had long sent convicts to its American colonies. After American independence, that outlet was closed, and prisoners piled up in old ships, called hulks, moored in the Thames and southern ports. In 1786 the government chose Botany Bay. Historians still debate the motives. Some argue that the plain need to empty crowded prisons explains nearly everything. Others point to strategic aims: flax and tall pines on nearby Norfolk Island for the navy, and a foothold in the Pacific to rival France. Both factors may have counted.

The First Fleet

Eleven ships under Captain Arthur Phillip left Portsmouth in May 1787 with about 1,500 people, roughly half of them convicts. Phillip found Botany Bay shallow and short of fresh water, so he moved a few kilometres north to Port Jackson. On 26 January 1788 he raised the British flag at Sydney Cove, on the land of the Gadigal people of the Eora nation. The first years were hungry, and the Second Fleet of 1790 arrived with many convicts dead or dying from neglect by the contractors who carried them.

Phillip's instructions told him to live with the local people "in amity and kindness." He tried at first to keep the peace and punished some colonists who attacked Aboriginal people. But in April 1789 smallpox swept through the Eora and killed a large share of them; how the disease arrived remains disputed. Two Eora men show the range of responses that followed. Bennelong, captured on Phillip's orders in 1789, became a go-between and sailed to England with Phillip in 1792, returning in 1795. Pemulwuy, a Bidjigal man, led armed resistance around Sydney for more than a decade until he was shot in 1802.

Worked example: what does 26 January mean?

Australia's national day falls on the anniversary of Phillip's landing at Sydney Cove. Colonists in New South Wales marked it as Foundation Day in the nineteenth century, and all states have kept a public holiday on the same date since 1994. To many Australians it celebrates a nation built by convicts, settlers and migrants. To many First Nations people it marks the start of dispossession, and protests call it Invasion Day or Survival Day.

Apply the evidence from this level and both readings make sense. The landing began a colony that grew into a stable democracy. It also began without consent, against the very instructions Cook had carried, and it brought disease and war to the Eora within months. Arguments over moving the holiday are therefore not only about a date. They ask whether a single day can stand for a shared history when the same event meant arrival for some and loss for others, and they test whether a nation can honour its founding while telling the truth about it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Dirk Hartog leave behind in 1616?
2. Why did some Dutch ships wreck on the coast of Western Australia?
3. What happened after the Batavia was wrecked in 1629?
4. How did Cook handle the Admiralty's instruction about consent?
5. Why did Britain need a new destination for convicts in the 1780s?
6. Where did Phillip raise the flag on 26 January 1788?
7. What did Bennelong do in 1792?
8. Who led armed resistance around Sydney until he was shot in 1802?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia