Skip to main content

Excavation is the image most people have of archaeology, and it is the most powerful method the discipline has. It is also the most destructive. A chemist can repeat an experiment; an archaeologist cannot put a layer back once it has been dug. Mortimer Wheeler made the point bluntly: excavation destroys the very evidence it studies. That is why excavators record so thoroughly: digging destroys the deposits, and the record is all that survives.

Who digs, and why

Some excavations are research projects, designed to answer a question, such as when a settlement was founded or how a building was used. But in many countries most excavation is commercial work, paid for by developers before construction. In the United States, federal law since 1966 has required projects using federal money or permits to consider their effects on historic sites. In England, planning guidance issued in 1990 made archaeology a normal part of the planning process, with developers bearing the cost. This contract archaeology produces most new finds, though much of it ends up in reports few people read.

Contexts and cuts

Excavators dig by following the natural layers of a site rather than by digging arbitrary depths wherever possible. Each distinct deposit, such as a floor, a layer of rubble or the fill of a ditch, is a context and gets its own number. So does each cut, the edge of a hole dug into earlier layers. A rubbish pit, for instance, has a cut (the hole) and one or more fills (what went into it). Deposits generally lie in the order they formed, but pits, foundations and graves cut down through older layers, so the sequence is rarely a simple stack.

To keep track, archaeologists use a diagram devised by Edward Harris in 1973 while working on excavations in Winchester. The Harris matrix diagrams the order of every context on a site, showing which deposits lie above, below or cut through which. A large urban site may produce thousands of contexts, and the matrix becomes the backbone of interpretation. It pairs well with single-context recording, in which each deposit gets its own record sheet and plan, a system developed in London in the 1970s and now widely used. Overlaying the separate plans recreates the site after it has been dug away.

Dates from objects in layers

Datable objects help fix the sequence in time. If a coin minted in AD 125 is found sealed in a layer, that layer cannot have formed before 125. This is a terminus post quem, the earliest date at which a layer could have formed. The coin does not say how much later the layer formed; it might have been dropped a century after minting. A terminus ante quem works the other way: a layer sealed beneath a floor that is securely dated must be older than that floor.

Objects can also mislead. A residual find is an older object redeposited in a later layer, as when a pit digger throws up Roman pottery that ends up in a medieval floor. An intrusive find is a later object carried down into older layers, by burrowing animals, roots or a later pit that went unnoticed. Careful excavators judge each layer by its latest securely stratified finds, not by the bulk of what it contains.

Recovering the small things

Much of the most useful evidence is tiny. Excavated soil is often passed through screens or sieves to catch beads, fish bones and flint chips. For plant remains, archaeologists use flotation. Soil samples are poured into moving water: heavy sediment sinks, and flotation recovers charred seeds and charcoal, which float free of the soil. The technique spread widely in the 1960s and transformed the study of early farming by producing thousands of seeds where hand digging had found almost none.

Total stations, photogrammetry and databases now fix every find to its context, but the principle is the same as in Pitt Rivers's day: if it was not recorded, it effectively did not happen.

Worked example: reading a trench

Imagine a trench in the backyard of a house in an old English market town. Beneath the modern topsoil (context 1), the excavators find a layer of dark garden soil (2) with pottery from the 1600s to the 1800s. Below that is a compact clay floor (3) with a hearth. The floor sits on a layer of building rubble (4). Cutting through the floor and the rubble is a round pit (cut 5), filled with dark soil and animal bones (fill 6). At the base of the trench lies natural gravel.

The Harris matrix makes the order clear: rubble (4) came first, then the floor (3), then the pit (5), which was dug through both and filled (6), then the garden soil (2) and topsoil (1). Fill 6 contains mostly medieval pottery and one coin of Edward I, minted between 1279 and 1307. The coin gives a terminus post quem: the pit was filled no earlier than 1279. A clay pipe fragment from about 1650 in the fill turns out to lie in a rabbit burrow, so the excavators treat it as intrusive. The story that results, a house floor later cut by a rubbish pit around 1300 and then buried under gardens, rests on numbered contexts, stratigraphic order and careful reasoning about every find.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why must excavators record a dig so thoroughly?
2. Who pays for most excavation in many countries today?
3. What does a Harris matrix show?
4. What is single-context recording?
5. A coin minted in AD 125 is found sealed in a layer. What follows?
6. What is a residual find?
7. What is an intrusive find?
8. Why is flotation useful to excavators?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia