Skip to main content

The republic's first years were a long emergency. Its leaders had to accept a peace treaty that almost every German party denounced, while armed men from the right and the left tried to overthrow them by force. That the republic survived at all says something about its supporters. That so many of its enemies went unpunished says something about the state machinery it had inherited from the empire.

A peace Germans called a dictate

The treaty presented to Germany in May 1919 was drafted without German participation and offered on take-it-or-leave-it terms. Germany lost about 13 percent of its European territory and about a tenth of its population, including Alsace-Lorraine to France and large areas to the new Polish state, as well as all its colonies. The army was limited to 100,000 men, with no conscription, tanks or military aircraft, and the Rhineland was to be occupied by Allied troops and kept free of German forces. Germans across the political spectrum called the treaty a Diktat, a dictated peace. Chancellor Scheidemann resigned rather than sign it, but the Assembly voted to accept when the Allies made clear that refusal meant invasion. The republic thus carried the stigma of a treaty signed by its first democratic leaders.

The final reparations bill came in May 1921 with the London Schedule of Payments, which set the total at 132 billion gold marks. Historians such as Sally Marks have pointed out that most of this sum took the form of so-called C bonds, which the Allies never seriously expected Germany to pay, so the real burden was closer to 50 billion. Germans saw the headline figure, however, and the dispute over whether Germany could not pay or simply would not pay ran through the whole decade.

The Kapp Putsch

The first great attack came from the right. In March 1920, when the government tried to disband Freikorps units to meet the treaty's limits, the Ehrhardt Marine Brigade marched on Berlin and installed a Prussian official, Wolfgang Kapp, as chancellor. The army leadership refused to defend the government, and its leading general, Hans von Seeckt, was reported to have said that soldiers would not fire on soldiers. Ministers fled first to Dresden and then to Stuttgart. The putsch collapsed within days because unions and the government called a general strike that shut down transport, water and power, while civil servants refused to obey the putschists. Yet in its aftermath a workers' uprising in the Ruhr was crushed by the same army and Freikorps units that had sat out the coup.

Voters then punished the founding parties. The Weimar coalition lost its majority in the election of June 1920 and never won one again, as voters moved toward the nationalist right and the radical left.

Murder as politics

The years from 1919 to 1922 saw hundreds of political killings. A secret group of former naval officers called Organisation Consul carried out some of the most notorious. In August 1921 its members shot Matthias Erzberger, the Centre politician who had signed the armistice. On 24 June 1922 they killed Walther Rathenau, the foreign minister, a Jewish industrialist and writer whom nationalist songs had openly threatened. Rathenau had worked to fulfill the treaty so as to show its terms were impossible, and earlier that year he had signed the Treaty of Rapallo, which restored relations with Soviet Russia.

Rathenau's murder brought hundreds of thousands into the streets. Chancellor Joseph Wirth told the Reichstag, in words that became famous: "The enemy stands on the right." In July the Reichstag passed a Law for the Protection of the Republic, which banned anti-republican groups and set up a special court for political crimes. Enforcement, however, depended on judges and police who often had little sympathy for the republic.

Worked example: counting justice

In 1922 the statistician Emil Julius Gumbel published a study of political murders in Germany since the revolution. He counted 354 killings by people on the right and 22 by people on the left. The difference in punishment was even more striking. Most of the right-wing killings went unpunished or drew light sentences, while the left-wing cases produced long prison terms and ten death sentences. A later memorandum from the justice ministry largely confirmed his figures, though it was never published.

Gumbel's method is a model for testing a claim of bias. He did not rely on stories about one outrageous verdict. He listed cases, sorted them by the politics of the accused and compared outcomes. A defender of the judges might reply that the cases differed, since many right-wing killings happened in the confused fighting of 1919, while some left-wing cases involved armed revolt. Even allowing for that, the pattern was hard to explain away. A judiciary trained under the empire tended to see nationalist killers as misguided patriots and socialist rebels as traitors. For citizens the lesson is that equal protection of the law depends not only on what the laws say but on who applies them. Gumbel paid for his work: nationalist students campaigned against him for years, and he was driven from his university post at Heidelberg in 1932.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. About how much of its European territory did Germany lose in 1919?
2. What limit did the treaty place on the German army?
3. What total did the London Schedule of 1921 set?
4. What did Sally Marks point out about the C bonds?
5. Why did the Kapp Putsch collapse within days?
6. What happened to the Weimar coalition in June 1920?
7. Who was Walther Rathenau?
8. What did the Law for the Protection of the Republic do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia