Skip to main content

The westward voyages of the Norse ended in two very different places. One was Greenland, where Norse farmers lived for more than four centuries on the edge of the Arctic before vanishing from the record. The other was a land they called Vinland, which they reached around the year 1000, half a millennium before Columbus, and then left almost as quickly as they came.

Erik the Red's Greenland

Erik Thorvaldsson, called Erik the Red, came to Iceland as a boy when his father was exiled from Norway for killing. Erik followed the family tradition. He had been outlawed for killings in Iceland, and he used his three years of exile, from about 982, to explore a land to the west that sailors had glimpsed. Returning, he called it Greenland. The Book of the Icelanders says he chose the name to make settlers want to go there, and it worked. Around 985 a fleet of settlers set out; the sagas say 25 ships left and only 14 arrived.

The colonists founded two clusters of farms on the sheltered southwestern fjords, the larger Eastern Settlement and the smaller Western Settlement farther north. At their height they may have numbered two or three thousand people, though estimates vary widely. They kept cattle, sheep and goats, and hunted caribou and seals. Greenland had no iron to speak of and little timber, so the colonists needed trade with Europe, and they paid for it with goods from the far north. Walrus ivory and hides were the most valued exports, carried from hunting grounds far up the west coast. The colony had churches, a cathedral at Gardar and its own bishop from the 1120s.

The Vinland sagas

Two Icelandic sagas, Greenlanders' Saga and Erik's Saga, written in the 1200s, tell of voyages farther west. They disagree on many details, but the outline is shared. A trader named Bjarni Herjólfsson, blown off course, sighted unknown coasts. Erik's son Leif Eriksson then sailed west and named three lands: Helluland, "flat stone land," probably Baffin Island; Markland, "forest land," probably Labrador; and Vinland, a warmer country of grapes and self-sown wheat.

Later expeditions tried to settle. The most ambitious was led by Thorfinn Karlsefni and his wife Gudrid, with several ships, livestock and both men and women. Their son Snorri was a child born to settlers in Vinland, and he is often called the first child of European descent born in the Americas. The sagas describe trading and then fighting with Indigenous people whom the Norse called skrælings, and they explain the abandonment of Vinland by the danger of living among a much larger population. After a few years the settlers went home.

Proof in the ground

For centuries many scholars treated Vinland as legend, though the German churchman Adam of Bremen had mentioned it around 1075. Then in 1960 the Norwegian explorer Helge Ingstad and his wife, the archaeologist Anne Stine Ingstad, followed clues to a site at the northern tip of Newfoundland called L'Anse aux Meadows. Helge Ingstad and Anne Stine Ingstad identified the site, and Anne Stine led its excavation. It held the remains of turf buildings in Norse style, a smithy where bog iron had been worked, a bronze cloak pin and a spindle whorl. It looks like a short-lived base camp. Among the finds were butternuts, which do not grow that far north, so Norse visitors went farther south, at least as far as the Gulf of St Lawrence, where wild grapes also grow.

The end of Norse Greenland

The Western Settlement was empty by around the middle of the 1300s. The Eastern Settlement lasted longer. A wedding at Hvalsey church in 1408, recorded in Icelandic documents, is the last written trace of the colony. Sometime later in the 1400s it was gone.

Worked example: why did Norse Greenland end?

Historians have offered several explanations, and the evidence for each has shifted. The climate cooled from the late 1200s, in what is called the Little Ice Age, bringing shorter growing seasons and more sea ice. Trade faltered: as elephant ivory from Africa returned to European markets, demand for walrus ivory fell, and Norwegian ships came less often. Contact with the Inuit, who were moving down the coast, brought both trade and conflict.

An influential account by the geographer Jared Diamond in 2005 argued that the Norse failed because they clung to European ways, raising cattle and building churches while refusing to learn from the Inuit, and even refusing to eat fish. Newer research complicates this. Chemical analysis of bones shows that the Greenlanders ate more and more seal over time, so they did adapt their diet. Some archaeologists now think the colony was not wiped out by starvation at all but slowly emptied as young people emigrated to Iceland and Norway when the ivory trade no longer paid.

Which is right? Probably no single cause. A useful way to weigh them is to ask what each predicts. Starvation predicts signs of famine in the last bones and farms; emigration predicts orderly abandonment, with valuables taken away. So far the evidence leans toward a long decline with many contributing causes. When a society disappears, the most dramatic explanation is not always the best supported.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Erik the Red go exploring west of Iceland?
2. According to the Book of the Icelanders, why did Erik choose the name Greenland?
3. What were Norse Greenland's most valued exports?
4. Which two sagas tell of the voyages to Vinland?
5. Who was Snorri, son of Thorfinn Karlsefni and Gudrid?
6. Who identified the Norse site at L'Anse aux Meadows?
7. What do butternuts found at L'Anse aux Meadows show?
8. What is the last written trace of Norse Greenland?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia