Skip to main content

Raiders took what they wanted and left. Settlers stayed, cleared fields, married local people and gave their names to the land. In the long run the settlers changed more than the raiders did, from the speech of northern England to the very existence of a new nation in the middle of the North Atlantic.

Settling in Britain and Ireland

After the Great Army divided up conquered land in the 870s, Norse families settled across northern and eastern England. Their mark survives in place names. A name ending in -by, as in Grimsby, Whitby or Derby, usually marks a farm or village of Norse origin, and -thorpe, as in Scunthorpe, marks an outlying settlement. Hundreds of such names cluster in Yorkshire, Lincolnshire and the East Midlands.

Norse also changed English itself. Old English and Old Norse were related enough that speakers could probably understand each other with effort, and in mixed communities words and grammar flowed across. English took everyday words from Norse, among them they, sky, egg and window, as well as knife, skin, take and law. Borrowing a pronoun such as they is rare between languages and suggests close contact, including mixed households.

York, called Jorvik by the Norse, became the capital of a Norse kingdom. Excavations at Coppergate in York between 1976 and 1981 uncovered crowded streets of timber houses and workshops, waterlogged soil that preserved wood, leather, textiles and even insect remains, and evidence of crafts from comb making to metalworking. Farther north, Orkney and Shetland were settled so thoroughly that a Norse language, Norn, was spoken there into the 1700s. Norse kingdoms flourished in Dublin and the Isle of Man, and in 911 a Norse leader received the land in northern France that became Normandy.

Into the empty ocean

Farther west lay islands with few or no people. The Faroes were settled in the 800s. Iceland, larger and much more remote, followed from about 870. According to Íslendingabók, the Book of the Icelanders written by the priest Ari Thorgilsson in the 1120s, the first Norse arrivals found only Irish hermits the Norse called papar, Christian monks who left rather than live among pagans. No firm archaeological trace of them has been found, so their presence remains a matter of debate.

A second book, Landnámabók, the Book of Settlements, names about 400 settlers and the land each one claimed. By tradition, Ingólfr Arnarson settled at Reykjavík in 874, after throwing the carved pillars of his high seat overboard and following where they washed ashore. The traditions were written down two to three centuries later, partly to justify which families owned which farms, so their details cannot all be trusted.

Science checks the sagas

Iceland's volcanoes provide a precise clock. Each eruption lays down a layer of ash, called tephra, with its own chemical fingerprint. One of them, which geologists call the settlement layer, is volcanic ash from an eruption around 877, a date confirmed by matching ash in Greenland ice cores. The earliest signs of human settlement lie just above or around this layer, which fits the written tradition remarkably well, though a few sites may be slightly older.

Genetics adds another check. Studies of modern and ancient Icelanders have found that the male line, traced through the Y chromosome, is mostly Scandinavian, while a large share of the female line, traced through mitochondrial DNA, is Gaelic. In other words, many founding women came from Ireland and Scotland. Some came as wives from Norse families already settled in the British Isles; many were probably captives or slaves. The books of settlement say little about them.

A cost to the land

The settlers brought cattle, sheep, goats, pigs and horses to an island that had never known grazing animals. When they arrived, birch woodland may have covered a quarter or more of the lowlands. Within a few centuries woodland was cleared and soil eroded away, as people cut trees for fuel, charcoal and pasture and animals ate the seedlings. Wind and water stripped the exposed volcanic soils, and Iceland has been fighting erosion ever since. It is one of the clearest early cases of human settlement transforming a fragile environment.

Worked example: testing the Book of Settlements

Imagine a researcher asking a simple question: who settled Iceland? Landnámabók gives a confident answer. It names hundreds of men, mostly Norwegian, gives their ancestors and their land claims, and tells dramatic stories of feuds and voyages. Taken alone, it suggests a migration of free Norwegian farming families.

Now add the other evidence. The tephra layer confirms the timing, which raises our trust in the book's broad outline. The DNA, however, reveals a population the book largely overlooks: Gaelic women, many of them unfree, who were mothers to a large part of the nation. Archaeology of early farms shows ordinary households rather than heroic ones. The book was not lying, exactly. It was recording the people whose claims mattered to its audience: landowning men and their lineages. A careful historian keeps its names and dates while asking who was left out, and why. That question applies to almost every written record of the past, and it is one of the habits of mind that makes history a training in fairness.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does an English place name ending in -by usually mark?
2. Which group of English words came from Old Norse?
3. What did excavations at Coppergate in York uncover?
4. Who, according to Íslendingabók, was in Iceland before the Norse?
5. Who, by tradition, settled at Reykjavík in 874?
6. What is Iceland's settlement layer?
7. What has DNA revealed about Iceland's founders?
8. What happened to Iceland's land after settlement?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia