For a few months in 1946 it seemed war might be avoided. Ho Chi Minh needed the Chinese Nationalist troops in the north to leave, and France wanted its army back in Hanoi. In March the two sides reached a compromise. Under the March 1946 accords, France recognized the Democratic Republic as a free state within the French Union, and Vietnamese leaders accepted the return of French troops for five years.
The road to war
Talks in France that summer failed to settle the key question: whether the south, Cochinchina, would join a united Vietnam. In November 1946 French warships shelled the port of Haiphong, killing thousands of civilians, though the exact number is disputed. On 19 December fighting broke out in Hanoi, and the Viet Minh leadership withdrew to the mountains of the north to wage a long war.
People's war
The Viet Minh's military chief was Vo Nguyen Giap, a former history teacher with no formal military training. Viet Minh leaders planned a protracted war in stages: first defense and guerrilla raids, then a balance of forces, and finally a general counteroffensive with regular armies. People's war meant mobilizing the whole population, not only soldiers: villagers carried supplies, hid fighters, gathered intelligence and dug traps. A French army that controlled the cities and main roads by day often found that the countryside belonged to its enemy at night.
The Bao Dai solution
France needed Vietnamese allies to answer the charge that it was simply restoring colonial rule. In 1949 it agreed to create the State of Vietnam, with the former emperor Bao Dai as head of state. The State of Vietnam was a rival Vietnamese government backed by France. Many anticommunist Vietnamese, including Catholics, members of religious sects such as the Cao Dai and Hoa Hao, and nationalists who had broken with the Viet Minh, supported it or at least opposed Ho. But France kept control of defense, foreign policy and finance for years, and critics at the time saw Bao Dai's government as independent in name only.
The war goes global
The Chinese Communist victory in 1949 transformed the war. In January 1950 China and the Soviet Union recognized Ho's government, and China began sending weapons, advisers and training across the border. When the Korean War began in June 1950, American leaders came to see Indochina as another front against communist expansion. Washington began sending aid, and the amounts grew quickly. By 1954 the United States was paying roughly three quarters of the cost of France's war.
Land reform
To strengthen peasant support, the party in the north launched a radical land reform from 1953. Teams of cadres classified villagers by class and held struggle sessions in which accused landlords were denounced before their neighbors. Land went to poor farmers, but the campaign also killed many people. Estimates of executions vary widely; careful scholars suggest a figure in the low tens of thousands or below. In 1956 the party admitted serious errors in land reform and began a campaign to rectify them, and the party chief Truong Chinh lost his post.
Geneva
Defeat at Dien Bien Phu in the spring of 1954 brought France to a conference already meeting at Geneva. The accords ended the fighting and confirmed the independence of Laos and Cambodia. Vietnam was split for a time, with elections planned for 1956 to reunify it. Pressed by China and the Soviet Union, who wanted calm, the Viet Minh accepted less than its battlefield position seemed to promise. Neither the United States nor the State of Vietnam endorsed the final Geneva declaration, though Washington said it would not use force to disturb the agreement.
Worked example: the siege of Dien Bien Phu
In late 1953 the French commander, General Henri Navarre, dropped paratroopers into the valley of Dien Bien Phu, near the border with Laos, and built a fortified base. The plan was to block Viet Minh moves into Laos and lure Giap into a pitched battle, where French artillery and air power would destroy his troops. The French assumed the Viet Minh could not bring heavy guns through the surrounding mountains.
They were wrong. Tens of thousands of porters carried food and ammunition over jungle tracks, some pushing bicycles loaded with hundreds of pounds of supplies. Troops dragged artillery up the hillsides and dug it in under cover, looking down on the French positions. When the assault began on 13 March 1954, the guns soon knocked out the airstrip, so the garrison could be supplied only by parachute. France asked the United States for air strikes, and American planners discussed a scheme known as Operation Vulture, but President Eisenhower would not act without British support and the backing of Congress. The base fell on 7 May, and around 11,000 French Union soldiers were taken prisoner, many of whom did not survive captivity. The lesson both sides drew was that the Viet Minh could beat a modern Western army in open battle if it chose the ground. The question it left was whether a far richer power would draw the same lesson.
