Peace and money produced a culture that the founders of the shogunate would hardly have recognized. Townspeople with cash and leisure paid for novels, prints, theater and poetry, while scholars argued about what a good society should be. Much of what the world now thinks of as traditional Japanese culture took shape in these centuries.
The floating world
The word ukiyo has a history of its own. In Buddhist usage it once meant a sorrowful, fleeting world, a place of suffering to be escaped. Seventeenth century writers punned on a different character with the same sound to make it the floating world: a life of pleasure lived in the moment, in the theaters, teahouses and licensed quarters of the cities. The same ideal of transience that had meant sorrow now meant enjoyment while it lasted.
The Genroku era, from 1688 to 1704, saw this culture flower in Kyoto and Osaka. Ihara Saikaku wrote comic and moving fiction about townspeople, including tales of how merchants made and lost fortunes, in a collection called The Japanese Family Storehouse. Kabuki and the puppet theater staged love, debt and duty for crowds of commoners, and the poet Matsuo Basho turned the short verse into an art of wandering and close attention. Later, woodblock printers in Edo produced cheap color prints of actors, beauties and landscapes by the thousand. The shogunate disliked much of this world and repeatedly tried to regulate it, banning certain plays, limiting luxury and censoring publishers, but it never managed to suppress it.
Orthodoxy and its critics
The shogunate favored Neo-Confucianism, the philosophy of the Chinese scholar Zhu Xi, which taught that a natural moral order runs through the universe and through society, with each person in a proper place. The Hayashi family of scholars served the shoguns from the early seventeenth century and ran the official academy. Yet Confucian thought in Tokugawa Japan was lively and contested.
In Kyoto, the merchant's son Ito Jinsai rejected the abstract metaphysics of the Zhu Xi school. Ito Jinsai urged readers to study Confucius and Mencius directly, setting aside later commentaries, and to find in them a practical ethic of human warmth. In Edo, Ogyu Sorai went further. Sorai argued that the Way was not a law of nature but a set of institutions created by the ancient sage kings. If the social order was a human creation, rulers could and should design institutions deliberately, a startlingly political idea. Sorai also gave advice on the most famous case of his day. When former retainers of the Ako domain avenged their lord in 1703, Sorai advised that they had acted loyally but broken the law, so they should be allowed to die by their own hand.
Philosophies for commoners
Townspeople developed their own ethics. Ishida Baigan, a farmer's son who had worked as a shop clerk in Kyoto, began giving free public lectures in 1729 that anyone could attend, women included. Baigan taught that a merchant's honest profit was as legitimate as a samurai's stipend, since each served society in its own way. His movement, known as Shingaku, spread across Japan. In Osaka, merchants founded the Kaitokudo, an academy for townspeople, in 1724, where scholars such as Tominaga Nakamoto and Yamagata Banto later developed critical, skeptical approaches to religion and history.
The most radical voice belonged to Ando Shoeki, a country doctor in the far north. Ando Shoeki attacked everyone who ate without farming, from samurai and priests to merchants and scholars, as parasites living off the labor of cultivators. He imagined a natural society in which everyone farmed and no one ruled. His writings were barely known in his lifetime and were rediscovered only in the late nineteenth century.
Worked example: the forty seven retainers
In 1701 Asano Naganori, lord of the small domain of Ako, drew his sword inside Edo Castle and wounded a senior official, Kira Yoshinaka, who had reportedly insulted him. Drawing a sword in the castle was a grave crime, and Asano was ordered to take his own life the same day. His domain was confiscated and his retainers became masterless samurai. Kira went unpunished.
Nearly two years later, on a snowy night in early 1703, forty seven of the former retainers, led by Oishi Kuranosuke, broke into Kira's Edo mansion and killed him. They carried his head to their lord's grave and surrendered. The shogunate faced a hard choice. The men had shown exactly the loyalty the regime praised, yet they had organized a private armed attack in the capital. After much debate, forty six of them were ordered to die by their own hand, an honorable death rather than execution, and they were buried beside their lord.
The case still divides readers. To admirers, the retainers embodied selfless duty. To critics, then and now, they put private loyalty above public law. Their story became one of the most popular plays in Japanese theater, set in an earlier century to avoid censorship. It poses a question every society faces: what happens when loyalty to people and loyalty to rules point in different directions, and who has the right to decide?
