Where theatre began is an old argument. In the early twentieth century a group of scholars at Cambridge proposed that Greek tragedy grew out of seasonal rituals of death and rebirth. Later historians found little direct evidence for that tidy story, and many now prefer a looser view: people everywhere mix ritual, storytelling, music and play, and theatre arose from that mix in many places independently. Ancient Athens is not the only birthplace of theatre, but it is the best documented early one, and it shows how closely the stage can be tied to a city's public life.
A festival and a contest
Athenian tragedy was performed at the City Dionysia, a spring festival honoring the god Dionysus. It was a civic and religious occasion, not entertainment for a few. Tradition held that a performer named Thespis first stepped out from the chorus to speak as a character, around 534 BCE, which is why actors are still called thespians; the story comes from much later writers and may be partly legend. Plays were entered in a competition, with each tragic poet presenting three tragedies and a satyr play, a rowdy short piece with a chorus of half animal followers of Dionysus. Judges, chosen partly by lot, ranked the entries.
Paying for all this was a duty of the rich. A wealthy citizen called the choregos was assigned to fund and equip the chorus as a public service, a kind of tax paid in spectacle. Victory brought prestige, and some sponsors spent lavishly. The audience in the Theatre of Dionysus on the slope of the Acropolis may have numbered well over ten thousand, though estimates vary widely.
Masks, actors and the shape of the space
The Greek theatre had three main parts. Spectators sat in the theatron, on a hillside curving around a flat circle called the orchestra, where the chorus sang and danced. Behind it stood the skene, a building that served as backdrop and changing room and gave English the word scene. All the performers were men, and they wore masks that made faces readable from far away and let one actor play several roles. According to Aristotle, Aeschylus raised the number of speaking actors from one to two, and Sophocles added a third. Tragedies were mostly limited to three speaking actors, who shared all the parts between them.
The stage had machinery too. A wheeled platform could roll out from the skene to reveal an indoor scene, often a corpse after an offstage killing, and a crane called the mechane could swing an actor playing a god through the air. Because gods so often arrived this way to sort out a tangled plot, the Latin phrase deus ex machina, god from the machine, still names any convenient rescue that a story has not earned.
Comedy and the city
Comedy had its own contests. Old Comedy, best known through Aristophanes, openly mocked living politicians and public figures, sometimes by name. In Lysistrata, staged in 411 BCE during the long war with Sparta, the women of Greece refuse sex to their husbands until the men make peace. Aristophanes attacked the powerful politician Cleon so fiercely that Cleon took him to court. A century later New Comedy, led by Menander, turned away from politics toward domestic plots: lovers, lost children, scheming slaves and lucky recognitions.
Rome inherited these forms and changed them. Roman playwrights such as Plautus and Terence adapted Greek New Comedy for festival crowds, and their clever servants, foolish fathers and young lovers passed into European comedy for two thousand years. Roman theatre had a political edge of a different kind. The Roman Senate long resisted building a permanent theatre in the city, fearing it would breed idleness and disorder, and in 154 BCE it ordered one under construction torn down. Rome's first permanent stone theatre was finished by Pompey in 55 BCE, built together with a temple.
What critics argue
Athenian theatre is often praised as democracy's school, where citizens watched their own dilemmas played out. Critics point out the limits: men wrote and acted every part, whether women sat in the audience is still disputed, and enslaved people did much of the labor that freed citizens for festivals. Both points can be true. The theatre was a place where a narrow citizen body examined itself, sometimes with surprising sympathy for those outside it.
Worked example: weeping for the enemy
Two plays show how risky that self-examination could be. Around 492 BCE the playwright Phrynichus staged The Capture of Miletus, about a Greek city recently destroyed by the Persians. According to Herodotus, the audience burst into tears, and the Athenians fined Phrynichus a thousand drachmas for reminding them of their own misfortunes and forbade anyone to stage the play again. Twenty years later, in 472 BCE, Aeschylus took a different path in The Persians, with the young Pericles as his choregos. It is set at the Persian court, which receives news of defeat at Salamis, a battle many in the audience had fought. The Athenians watched the queen mother and her people mourn their dead. The play celebrates Greek victory, but it also asks the winners to see the losers' grief as human grief. That is one of theatre's oldest powers: placing spectators inside a point of view they might otherwise refuse.
