Skip to main content

When news reached the West that Christian rebels had taken Nanjing, some missionaries were thrilled. Perhaps China would become a Christian nation. British envoys who sailed up the Yangzi in 1853 found something stranger: Taiping officials who welcomed them as "foreign brothers" but expected them to accept Hong as ruler of the world. Western governments declared neutrality and waited. A few British observers, such as the interpreter Thomas Meadows, urged that the rebels be given a fair hearing, but merchants worried about the silk and tea that flowed through Shanghai.

From neutrality to intervention

Neutrality did not last. Britain and France fought the Qing again from 1856 to 1860, and the treaties that ended that war gave them new ports on the Yangzi, the right to station diplomats in Beijing and large indemnities. Those gains depended on a Qing government able to honor them. Meanwhile the Taiping were threatening Shanghai, the center of foreign trade. So Britain and France began backing the Qing because their treaty gains depended on Qing rule. Missionary hopes faded too. Issachar Roberts, Hong's old teacher, lived in Nanjing from 1860 but fled in January 1862 and denounced the regime.

The Ever-Victorious Army

In Shanghai, wealthy Chinese merchants and Qing officials hired foreign help. Frederick Ward, an American adventurer, organized a mercenary force in 1860. It became the Ever-Victorious Army, Chinese troops led by Western officers and armed with modern rifles and artillery, and the Qing granted it that name. Ward, born in Salem, Massachusetts, had drifted through Latin America before reaching Shanghai, and he married the daughter of a Chinese banker who helped fund his force. He was killed in battle in 1862. In 1863 command passed to Charles Gordon, a British army engineer. British and French troops also cleared Taiping forces from a zone around Shanghai in 1862, and the Huai Army of Li Hongzhang fought alongside them.

Broken faith at Suzhou

By late 1863 Gordon's force and the Huai Army were closing on Suzhou. Several Taiping commanders inside negotiated a surrender, killed a fellow king who refused, and opened the gates in December. Gordon believed he had guaranteed their lives. Instead Li Hongzhang had the surrendered kings executed. Gordon was furious, reportedly went looking for Li with a revolver, and for a time refused to fight. He later resumed command, and the Ever-Victorious Army was disbanded in 1864.

The end of the Heavenly Kingdom

From 1862 Zeng Guoquan's army camped outside Nanjing, slowly tightening the ring. Li Xiucheng urged Hong to break out and move elsewhere. Hong refused, saying that God would protect his capital. As food ran out, he urged his people to eat wild plants as heavenly manna. Hong Xiuquan died of illness in June 1864, shortly before the city fell. Some accounts claim poison, but most historians accept illness.

Nanjing fell in July 1864, after Qing sappers exploded a mine beneath the walls. Soldiers spent days killing, looting and burning. Li Xiucheng was captured, and he wrote a long confession for Zeng Guofan before his execution in August. Hong's teenage son and Hong Rengan were caught and executed later that year. Zeng Guofan reported to the throne that Hong's son had died in the flames, a claim soon shown to be false: the boy had slipped out with a few followers before being caught. Taiping remnants fought on in the south until about 1866, and others joined rebels in the north.

How much did foreigners matter?

For a long time historians agreed that the Hunan and Huai armies did nearly all the fighting, and that foreigners mattered mainly around Shanghai. The historian Stephen Platt argued that British help mattered more than often thought: British neutrality ended at the crucial moment, steamers carried the Huai Army to Shanghai, foreign-run customs revenue paid Qing troops, and the defense of Shanghai denied the Taiping the port and money they needed. Others reply that the decisive blows, at Anqing and Nanjing, were struck by Chinese armies. The debate is about weight, not about whether foreigners played a part. Foreign help also came at a price, since customs revenue under foreign management and loans from foreign merchants tied the Qing more closely to the treaty powers whose demands it resented.

Worked example: the promise at Suzhou

Was Li Hongzhang right to execute the Suzhou kings? Consider his case. The surrendered commanders still led tens of thousands of armed men inside the city. They kept their long hair, refused to disband and demanded high posts. Li feared they might turn on him, and Qing law treated rebel leaders as criminals.

Now consider Gordon's case. A guarantee of life had been given, or believed to be given, and the kings had opened the gates on its strength. Killing them betrayed trust and taught every remaining Taiping commander that surrender meant death. That lesson probably lengthened the war. The case raises a principle that later laws of war would put in writing: an enemy who lays down arms keeps a claim to life, and promises made to the defeated bind the victor. Respecting that claim protects not only the prisoner but everyone who might otherwise fight to the end.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Britain and France begin backing the Qing after 1860?
2. What was the Ever-Victorious Army?
3. Who first organized the Ever-Victorious Army?
4. What happened after Suzhou surrendered in December 1863?
5. How did Hong Xiuquan die?
6. When did Nanjing fall to the Qing?
7. What did Li Xiucheng write after his capture?
8. What did Stephen Platt argue about the war?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia