Skip to main content

Isaac Newton (1642 to 1727) was born in a Lincolnshire farmhouse on Christmas Day 1642, by the calendar England still used. He became a fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge, and in 1669 its professor of mathematics. Brilliant, secretive and quick to take offense, he would sit on discoveries for years.

Light and a quarrel

Newton's first public triumph was about light. In a paper of 1672 he reported prism experiments showing that white light is a mixture of rays of different colors, each bent by a different amount. Robert Hooke, who had his own theory of light, criticized it, and the exchange grew bitter. In a letter of 1675 Newton wrote to Hooke, in apparently gracious terms: "If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants." The image was old. The saying about standing on the shoulders of giants goes back to the twelfth century teacher Bernard of Chartres. Some hear a jab at the short Hooke; most historians see a conventional compliment.

Halley's question

In August 1684 the astronomer Edmond Halley rode to Cambridge with a question that he, Hooke and Christopher Wren had failed to settle: what path would a planet follow if the Sun pulled it with a force that weakened with the square of the distance? Newton said at once that it would be an ellipse; he had calculated it. Halley's question about the orbit produced by an inverse-square pull set Newton to write the Principia. A short tract grew, over many months of furious work, into the Principia of 1687.

Publishing it was another matter. The Royal Society had agreed to print it but had no money. The Royal Society could not pay for the Principia because it had spent its funds on a lavish book about fish, Francis Willughby's History of Fishes (1686), which sold badly. Halley, then the Society's paid clerk, covered the cost himself, and was later offered copies of the fish book in place of salary. Meanwhile Hooke claimed that he had suggested the inverse-square idea first, and Newton, enraged, cut references to him from the book.

A force without a cause

The Principia described gravity's effects precisely but did not say what gravity was. To followers of Descartes, who explained everything by contact and collision, a pull reaching across empty space looked like a return to medieval sympathies. Critics such as Leibniz charged that gravity acting at a distance was an occult quality, a hidden power dressed up in mathematics. In the second edition of 1713 Newton replied that he had not been able to discover the cause of gravity and would not invent one: "I frame no hypotheses."

The Mint and the Society

In 1696 Newton left Cambridge to become Warden of the Royal Mint in London, and later its Master. He oversaw a great recoinage and hunted forgers in person, questioning suspects and informers. At the Mint Newton pursued counterfeiters himself and sent the forger William Chaloner to the gallows in 1699, at a time when coining was treated as high treason. From 1703 until his death he was also president of the Royal Society, which he ran with a firm hand.

Why Europe, and why then?

Historians still argue about why these changes clustered in Europe in these years. In 1938 the sociologist Robert Merton suggested that Puritan values encouraged English science. Others stress printing, rivalry between states that let a censored thinker publish elsewhere, and wealth flowing from trade and empire. The biochemist and historian Joseph Needham posed the sharpest version. Joseph Needham asked why modern science arose in Europe rather than in China, despite China's long lead in many techniques. Knowledge also moved in many directions: the Jesuit Ferdinand Verbiest ran China's imperial bureau of astronomy.

The calculus offers a last case. Newton developed his method of "fluxions" in 1665 and 1666 but kept it to himself and a few correspondents. The German philosopher Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz developed his own version in the 1670s and published first, in 1684. When the two camps later fought over credit, the Royal Society judged the case. Newton himself secretly wrote the Royal Society report that decided the calculus dispute in his favor. Historians today agree that the two men invented calculus independently, and the notation used in calculus today, such as dx and the long S of the integral sign, comes from Leibniz.

Worked example: a judge in his own cause

Newton's supporters accused Leibniz of borrowing from letters and papers he had seen on a visit to London. In 1711 Leibniz appealed to the Royal Society for justice. Its president was Newton. In 1712 a committee of the Society, chosen by him, ruled that Newton had been first and implied that Leibniz had copied. Newton drafted the report, and later wrote an anonymous review praising it.

Set this beside the ideals the Society proclaimed: take nobody's word, judge by evidence and witnesses, settle disputes about facts calmly. The institution had been built to judge fairly, but when its most powerful member was a party to the dispute, it became a judge in his own cause. Leibniz died in 1716 with the matter unresolved.

Methods for testing claims matter, but so do rules about who may judge. The ideal of impartial judgment survived the scandal, yet it needed protection from those who claimed to serve it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where does the saying about standing on the shoulders of giants come from?
2. What set Newton to write the Principia?
3. Why could the Royal Society not pay to print the Principia?
4. What did critics such as Leibniz say about Newton's gravity?
5. What did Newton do at the Royal Mint?
6. What question did Joseph Needham pose?
7. Who wrote the Royal Society's 1712 report on the calculus dispute?
8. Whose calculus notation, such as dx, is used today?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia