Spain entered the twentieth century as a country of sharp contrasts. Barcelona had textile mills and a busy port; Bilbao had iron mines, steelworks and banks; but most Spaniards still lived on the land, and roughly half the adults could not read. The quarrels that exploded in 1936 had been building for generations, over land, religion, the army, the regions and the basic question of who should rule.
A managed stability
After years of upheaval, the Bourbon monarchy was restored in 1874, and a constitution followed in 1876. Its architect, the Conservative politician Antonio Cánovas del Castillo, wanted to end the era of military coups. His solution was the turno pacífico, an arrangement in which the Conservative and Liberal parties took turns in power by agreement. Elections were held, but their results were arranged in advance. The machinery depended on local political bosses called caciques, who delivered votes through favors, pressure and fraud. The system kept the peace for decades, yet it shut out the growing working class and the new regional movements, and it taught many Spaniards that parliament was a stage play performed for someone else.
The disaster of 1898
In 1898 Spain lost a short war with the United States and with it Cuba, Puerto Rico and the Philippines, the last major pieces of its overseas empire. Spaniards called it simply "the Disaster." A group of writers later known as the Generation of 1898, among them Miguel de Unamuno, asked what had gone wrong with their country. Officers, humiliated, tended to blame politicians. Reformers blamed backwardness and the caciques. The argument about how to "regenerate" Spain ran through every political camp for the next thirty years.
Land and labor
Land was the deepest grievance. In Andalusia and Extremadura, much of the soil belonged to huge estates called latifundios, worked by landless laborers hired by the day or the season. These jornaleros might go without work for months each year. In Galicia, by contrast, plots were often too small to live on, while in Old Castile and Navarre many families owned modest farms and were devoutly Catholic. The same word, "peasant," covered people with very different interests, which helps explain why rural Spain split apart rather than rising together.
Two labor movements competed for the poor. Socialists founded the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE) in 1879 and the General Union of Workers (UGT) in 1888; they were disciplined and willing to work through elections. Anarchist ideas arrived in 1868 with an Italian envoy of Mikhail Bakunin and took root among Andalusian laborers and Catalan factory hands. In 1910 anarchists in Barcelona founded the CNT, the National Confederation of Labor, an anarcho-syndicalist union that rejected party politics and aimed to replace the state with free federations of workers. It grew into a mass movement, strongest in Catalonia, Aragon and Andalusia.
Church, army and regions
The Catholic Church ran much of the country's schooling and remained central to rural life, but many urban workers saw it as an ally of the rich. That anger burst out in Barcelona's Tragic Week of July 1909, when protests against calling up reservists for war in Morocco turned into riots in which dozens of churches and convents were burned. The army was another problem. It had far too many officers for its size, a long tradition of the pronunciamiento, the coup by public declaration, and a costly colonial war in northern Morocco. Meanwhile Catalan and Basque movements demanded recognition of their languages and self-government. The Basque Nationalist Party was founded in 1895, and the Catalan Regionalist League in 1901.
Dictatorship and the end of the monarchy
On 13 September 1923, General Miguel Primo de Rivera, captain general of Catalonia, seized power, and King Alfonso XIII accepted the coup and appointed him to head the government. Primo suspended the constitution, built roads, dams and railways, and drew the Socialist UGT into state arbitration boards while repressing the CNT. But economic trouble, student protests and the army's own discontent wore him down, and he resigned in January 1930. The king had tied his crown to the dictator, and many former monarchists now turned against him. In August 1930 republicans and Catalan nationalists, soon joined by the Socialists, agreed in the Pact of San Sebastián to work together to bring down the monarchy.
Worked example: the Annual disaster and the Picasso file
In July 1921 Rif fighters led by Abd el-Krim routed a Spanish army near Annual in Morocco. Thousands of Spanish soldiers were killed; estimates commonly run from about 8,000 to more than 10,000. Public outrage demanded to know who was responsible. General Juan Picasso González led an official inquiry, and his file documented incompetence, corruption and wretched supply. Parliament was preparing to debate responsibility, including questions that reached toward the king himself, when Primo de Rivera took power in 1923, and the debate never took place.
Apply the ideas from this level. The Restoration system had no real way to hold the powerful to account, because elections were managed rather than won. The army, humiliated in 1898 and again in 1921, saw itself as the true guardian of the nation rather than a servant of elected governments. And the king's acceptance of the coup cost the monarchy its claim to stand above party. When Spaniards voted in 1931, many were also passing judgment on 1921. The lesson for citizens is plain: a state that buries its failures instead of examining them stores up anger that eventually finds another outlet.
