Skip to main content

Colonial conquest was violent everywhere, but in German South West Africa, now Namibia, violence turned into a deliberate attempt to destroy whole peoples. What happened there between 1904 and 1908 raises hard questions about how such policies arise and how they should be named.

Land, cattle and protection

German rule began with the treaties of the 1880s. Governor Theodor Leutwein, who arrived in 1894, ruled by playing leaders against one another and by signing protection treaties. The central plateau belonged to the Herero, cattle herders led by Samuel Maharero, while the Nama lived further south. The Nama leader Hendrik Witbooi had fought the Germans after they attacked his settlement in 1893, then signed a treaty in 1894. Witbooi fought alongside the Germans for ten years before rising against them in 1904.

Pressure on the Herero grew steadily. Rinderpest in 1897 destroyed much of their wealth. Traders pressed debts, settlers took grazing land, and plans for reserves threatened what remained. German courts treated violence against Africans lightly. By 1903 many Herero saw their society slipping away.

The war of 1904

In January 1904 the Herero rose, killing more than a hundred German settlers and soldiers, mostly men. Samuel Maharero ordered his fighters to spare women and children, missionaries, and English and Boer settlers. Berlin replaced Leutwein's command with Lieutenant General Lothar von Trotha, a veteran of earlier colonial wars who believed in crushing resistance completely.

In August 1904 German forces encircled the Herero at the Waterberg. The battle did not end in surrender. After the battle most Herero fled into the Omaheke, a waterless sandveld, and German patrols guarded the waterholes at its edges. In October von Trotha issued a proclamation. It declared that any Herero found within the German borders would be shot, and that women and children would be driven back into the desert. Thousands died of thirst. After protests in Germany, the Kaiser revoked the order in December, but by then the destruction was largely done.

The camps

Survivors were gathered into prison camps, which German officials themselves called concentration camps, and set to forced labor. The worst was on Shark Island off Lüderitz, where most prisoners died from cold, hunger, disease and brutal work. Skulls of the dead were sent to Germany for racial research, and some were returned to Namibia only in the twenty-first century. In October 1904 the Nama rose too. Witbooi, by then in his seventies, was killed in battle in 1905, and guerrilla resistance lasted until 1908.

The war at home

The war also shook German politics. Its cost and the reports of brutality led the Catholic Centre Party and the Social Democrats to vote against further colonial spending in December 1906. Chancellor Bernhard von Bülow dissolved the Reichstag, and in the election of January 1907, mocked as the "Hottentot election" after a slur for the Nama, nationalist and pro-colonial parties gained seats. A new colonial secretary, Bernhard Dernburg, then promised more businesslike and less violent rule, a sign that even supporters of empire saw that something had gone badly wrong.

Counting and naming

Before the war there were perhaps 60,000 to 80,000 Herero; German officials counted only about 15,000 Herero in 1911. Roughly half of the Nama also died. Figures are uncertain, but the scale is not in doubt. Much of the best grazing land passed to settlers, and a large share of it remained in the hands of their heirs long after Namibia became independent in 1990. Most historians call these events genocide, in the sense later defined in international law: acts intended to destroy a group as such.

Historians debate the causes. The historian Isabel Hull argued that the German army's military culture, which sought the total destruction of the enemy, drove the killing, more than any plan made in advance. Jürgen Zimmerer argued that the genocide anticipated later Nazi crimes in its racial thinking, camps and goal of living space for settlers. Critics of that view accept the brutality but warn against drawing a straight line from Namibia to Auschwitz, since the intervening decades shaped Nazism in many other ways.

Worked example: the Blue Book of 1918

During the First World War South African forces occupied the colony. In 1918 the British government published a report on German treatment of the territory's peoples, based on sworn testimony from Herero, Nama and other survivors. It helped Britain and South Africa argue at the peace conference that Germany should lose its colonies, and South Africa received the territory as a mandate.

The report was openly propaganda, yet it preserved voices that German records ignored. In 1926 white settlers in the territory, including many Germans, objected to it, and the British government withdrew the report and had copies destroyed. Copies survived in libraries, and historians republished it with notes in 2003. The case shows a general lesson: a source can be both partisan and true. Historians test such testimony against German military papers, missionary reports and later oral histories, and much of it holds up.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Hendrik Witbooi do in the decade before 1904?
2. What did Samuel Maharero order his fighters in 1904?
3. Where did most Herero flee after the battle of Waterberg?
4. What did von Trotha's proclamation of October 1904 declare?
5. What was the camp on Shark Island off Lüderitz known for?
6. About how many Herero did German officials count in 1911?
7. What did Isabel Hull argue drove the killing?
8. What did Jürgen Zimmerer argue about the genocide?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia