Rwanda is a small, green, crowded country of steep hills and high valleys in the middle of Africa, just south of the equator. Before Europeans arrived it was not a patchwork of villages but a kingdom with a royal court, an army and poets who memorized the deeds of kings. To understand how a genocide could happen there in 1994, begin with what Rwandans shared, and with how the categories later turned into weapons first took shape.
A kingdom on the hills
The central kingdom was ruled by a king called the mwami, who belonged to the Nyiginya dynasty. Court traditions gave the dynasty a very long line of kings, but historians, led by the Belgian scholar Jan Vansina, have argued that the kingdom took shape as a strong state mainly from the seventeenth century, and that the older lists were partly invented to give it ancient roots. The king was a sacred figure, surrounded by ritual specialists called abiru, who guarded the secret code of royal ceremonies. Around him stood chiefs who governed land, cattle and armies, often in overlapping posts so that no single chief grew too strong.
The kingdom grew by conquest. Many regions in the north and west kept their own rulers well into the nineteenth century and were brought under the court only gradually. The great expander was Kigeli IV Rwabugiri, who ruled in the later nineteenth century until his death in 1895. He fought almost constant wars, pushed royal power into outlying regions and replaced local leaders with men loyal to the court.
One language, shared clans
What strikes outsiders most is how much Rwandans had in common. Nearly everyone spoke Kinyarwanda, honored the same high god, Imana, and lived side by side on the same hills rather than in separate villages. People belonged to some eighteen or so large clans, and each clan included Hutu, Tutsi and Twa. A clan was a matter of descent and identity, and it cut straight across the lines that later came to seem absolute. This is one reason scholars reject the old habit of calling Hutu and Tutsi "tribes." They did not have separate territories, languages or religions.
Hutu, Tutsi and Twa
The three names were real and mattered, but their meaning changed over time. Broadly, Tutsi were associated with cattle and with power, Hutu with farming, and Twa, a small minority, with hunting, pottery and service at court. Cattle were the great measure of wealth and honor, so the word Tutsi came to mark status as much as origin. Under the court many chiefs were Tutsi, though not all, and the great majority of Tutsi were ordinary herders and farmers with no power at all.
The line could also be crossed. A Hutu family that gained cattle and favor could, over a generation or two, come to be seen as Tutsi, and the process had a name: kwihutura, "shedding Hutuness." A Tutsi family that lost its herds could slide the other way. Its existence shows that the categories worked partly like social ranks, not like fixed races.
Ties of service: ubuhake and uburetwa
Two kinds of obligation shaped daily life. The first was ubuhake, a contract in which a patron gave the use of cattle to a client in return for service and loyalty. Clients could be Hutu or poorer Tutsi, and the bond protected them as well as binding them. The second was harsher. Under Rwabugiri and his successors, chiefs imposed uburetwa, a duty of unpaid labor on a chief's land, which fell on Hutu and not on Tutsi. Where ubuhake could be a ladder, uburetwa marked a boundary, and it hardened the sense that being Hutu meant being made to work for others.
Rwandans themselves later told two opposite stories about this past. Some writers after 1994 described precolonial Rwanda as a harmonious nation spoiled by Europeans. Many Hutu political leaders before 1994 described it as centuries of Tutsi oppression. The best evidence supports neither myth. Inequality was real and growing in the nineteenth century, especially in the regions Rwabugiri conquered, but the rigid racial division of later times did not yet exist.
Worked example: a cow and a promise
Imagine a Hutu farmer on a hill in central Rwanda around 1880. He has fields of sorghum and beans but no cattle. He approaches a local Tutsi patron and asks for a cow. If the patron agrees, the farmer becomes his client under ubuhake. He will keep the cow and drink its milk, and some of its calves may in time become his own, but he owes the patron visits, gifts of beer, help with building and, above all, loyalty. In return the patron speaks for him in disputes with chiefs and protects him from rivals.
Now apply the ideas of this level. The bond is unequal, but it is also personal, and it can be broken or passed on to children. If the farmer's family prospers and gains herds of its own, his grandchildren may marry into Tutsi families and be counted as Tutsi themselves. If instead the local chief demands uburetwa, the same farmer must spend days working the chief's fields, a burden his Tutsi neighbors do not bear. Within one life the categories can look like both a ladder and a wall. In the twentieth century the ladder was taken away and the wall was written down.
