Skip to main content

As 1849 drew to a close, the old powers were back almost everywhere. Kings had recovered their capitals, generals sat in ministries, and thousands of revolutionaries were in prison, in exile or dead. It is easy to tell 1848 as a story of failure. The harder and more interesting question is what survived the defeat, and where it went.

The return of order

In Austria the young emperor Franz Joseph and his chief minister, Prince Felix Schwarzenberg, rebuilt central power. The constitution they had issued in March 1849 was never fully put into effect, and the Sylvester Patent of 31 December 1851 revoked the constitution outright. A decade of rule by officials, police and army followed.

Prussia tried to salvage something of the national program by forming a union of German princes under its own leadership. Austria, backed by Russia, threatened war. At Olmütz in November 1850 Prussia gave way, giving up its union plan and restoring the old confederation. Prussians remembered it as the humiliation of Olmütz.

What lasted

Yet much could not be undone. The peasants of the Habsburg and many German lands never returned to labor dues. Prussia kept a written constitution and a parliament, however unequal its voting system. Piedmont kept its constitution, and France kept universal male suffrage even under an emperor. Switzerland, the Netherlands and Denmark built lasting constitutional orders. Above all, millions of people had joined clubs, read free newspapers, voted and argued in public. Governments that came after 1848 had to manage public opinion, not merely suppress it.

Exiles

Defeat scattered the revolutionaries. London became a crowded refuge for Germans, Italians, Hungarians, Poles and French republicans, among them Marx, Mazzini and Kossuth. Others crossed the Atlantic. Thousands of these political refugees, later called the Forty-Eighters, settled in the United States, where many became journalists, teachers and opponents of slavery.

The best known was Carl Schurz, a student from the Rhineland who fought in the last stand in Baden. When the fortress of Rastatt fell, he escaped through a drain beneath the fortress and reached Switzerland. In 1850 he returned in secret to free his old teacher, Gottfried Kinkel, from prison in Spandau. In America Schurz became a Union general in the Civil War, then served as a senator and Secretary of the Interior, and spent his later years fighting for civil service reform and against the annexation of colonies.

Women after 1848

Women had been active in clubs, newspapers and on the barricades, and the reaction moved quickly to silence them. In Saxony, Louise Otto founded a women's newspaper in 1849 under the motto "I recruit women citizens for the realm of freedom". A Saxon press law of 1850 then banned women from editing newspapers, a rule aimed squarely at her. In France the seamstress and teacher Jeanne Deroin stood as a candidate for parliament in 1849, although women had no vote; she was later imprisoned for organizing workers' associations.

The verdicts

In 1862 Bismarck, now Prussia's chief minister, told a parliamentary committee: "Not by speeches and majority decisions are the great questions of the day decided, that was the great mistake of 1848 and 1849, but by iron and blood." He meant that 1848 had failed by relying on speeches and majority votes. Germany and Italy were indeed united within the next decade, by kings and armies rather than parliaments.

Historians have weighed that verdict ever since. Some, especially writing after the Nazi era, saw 1848 as the moment when German liberalism lost its chance to shape the nation. Others, including Christopher Clark in a large study published in the 2020s, argue that the revolutions changed how Europe was governed, since the regimes that defeated them quietly adopted many of their reforms. The rights the Frankfurt deputies wrote down did not die either: the Basic Rights became a model for later German constitutions, including the Weimar constitution of 1919 and the Basic Law of 1949.

Worked example: one life, two verdicts

Measure 1848 by Carl Schurz's life and see how the answer shifts.

Judged from Germany in 1850, Schurz was a defeated rebel. His cause had lost, his friends had been shot or imprisoned, and the nation he dreamed of would later be built by Bismarck on very different principles.

Judged from the United States in 1865, the picture changes. Schurz and thousands of other Forty-Eighters had carried the ideas of 1848, that all men are equal before the law and that government needs the consent of the governed, into the fight against slavery. Many fought for the Union.

Judged from Germany in 1949, the picture changes again. The writers of a new democratic constitution looked back past Bismarck to the Frankfurt deputies and borrowed their language of basic rights.

The exercise shows why "Did 1848 fail?" has no single answer. A revolution can lose its battles and still win part of its argument, in another country or another century. Whether it succeeded depends on where you stand, what you count and how long you are willing to wait.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Austria's Sylvester Patent of 31 December 1851 do?
2. What did Prussia accept at Olmütz in November 1850?
3. How did Carl Schurz escape when Rastatt fell?
4. Which offices did Carl Schurz hold in the United States?
5. What did a Saxon press law of 1850 forbid?
6. What did Jeanne Deroin do in 1849?
7. According to Bismarck in 1862, what was the mistake of 1848 and 1849?
8. Which later constitutions drew on the 1848 Basic Rights?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia