Skip to main content

The revolutions of 1848 are often mapped as a blaze running from Paris to Budapest. The edges of that map tell their own story. In Italy the fire burned longest. In Britain, the Low Countries and Scandinavia it was met with reform, or with the police. In Russia it never caught at all. Comparing them shows that revolution was never simply a matter of anger; it depended on how governments answered.

Italy: from Sicily to Rome

Sicily rose first in January 1848, and its parliament declared the Bourbon king deposed. Ferdinand II of the Two Sicilies struck back that autumn. His forces bombarded Messina so heavily that he was nicknamed "King Bomba", and by May 1849 the island was his again. In the north, Milan and Venice drove out the Austrians in March and the kingdom of Piedmont went to war, but Austria's army won the decisive battles. In Rome a republic was proclaimed after the pope fled, and it fell to a French army in the summer of 1849. Venice, under siege and stricken by cholera, held out until August. Only Piedmont emerged with a constitution, a fact that would matter greatly in the following decade.

Britain: the day of the special constables

In London the Chartists, who had campaigned for a decade for votes for all men, planned a mass meeting on Kennington Common for 10 April 1848, followed by a procession to deliver a huge petition to Parliament. The government took no chances. The aged Duke of Wellington placed troops out of sight around the capital, and tens of thousands of special constables, volunteers sworn in for the day, were enrolled to keep order. One of them was a French exile who would soon be president of France: Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte.

The meeting was smaller than its organizers had promised, and it was peaceful. The Chartist leader Feargus O'Connor agreed not to march, and the petition went to Westminster in cabs. Arrests followed later in the summer, and the movement faded. The government had shown that it could face down a crowd without firing a shot.

Ireland: rising in a famine

Ireland was a different matter. In 1848 it was in the third year of the Great Famine, and a group of young nationalists called Young Ireland had lost patience with peaceful agitation. The journalist John Mitchel was convicted under a new Treason Felony Act and transported. In July, with habeas corpus suspended, William Smith O'Brien tried to raise the countryside. At Ballingarry, County Tipperary, a few dozen police barricaded themselves in a farmhouse and held off his small, hungry force. The rising collapsed in a day. O'Brien was sentenced to death, and the sentence was commuted to transportation to Van Diemen's Land, now Tasmania. The starving rarely make revolutions; they are too busy surviving.

The Low Countries and Denmark

Some governments chose concession before the crowd arrived. Belgium, a constitutional monarchy since 1831, lowered the property bar for voting in March 1848, nearly doubling the electorate, and its streets stayed quiet. In the Netherlands, King William II reportedly said he had turned from very conservative to very liberal in a single night. He asked the liberal Johan Rudolf Thorbecke to lead a revision, and the constitution of November 1848 introduced direct elections to the lower house and made ministers answerable to parliament. It remains the basis of Dutch government. In Denmark, King Frederick VII gave up absolute rule in March 1848, and the country's first democratic constitution was signed on 5 June 1849. Danes still mark 5 June as Constitution Day.

Russia: the frozen center

Tsar Nicholas I tightened censorship, closed his borders to dangerous books and sent his army to help Austria in Hungary. In 1849 police broke up a discussion circle in St Petersburg; among those arrested was the young writer Fyodor Dostoevsky. He and his comrades faced a mock execution, standing before a firing squad until a last-minute reprieve was read, and were then sent to hard labor in Siberia.

Worked example: why did Britain escape revolution?

Britain had the most developed industrial economy in Europe, a large and angry working class and a mass movement for democracy. Why did 1848 pass it by?

Consider the case for reform. Parliament had shown it could change: the Reform Act of 1832 widened the vote, and the repeal of the Corn Laws in 1846 cut the price of bread. Many workers believed, rightly or wrongly, that pressure could work without barricades. The economy was also recovering by 1848.

Consider the case for strength. The state was confident, its army was loyal and well led, and middle-class Britons volunteered in large numbers to defend property. The Chartists were divided over whether to threaten force.

Now test both explanations against Ireland. There, consent was thin and the state ruled through emergency laws, soldiers and transportation. The British answer to 1848 combined reform in one island with repression in the other. An honest explanation of British stability must hold both facts at once.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why was Ferdinand II of the Two Sicilies nicknamed King Bomba?
2. How did the British government guard London on 10 April 1848?
3. Which future ruler served as a special constable in London in April 1848?
4. What happened to William Smith O'Brien after the Ballingarry rising?
5. How did Belgium head off revolution in 1848?
6. What did the Dutch constitution of 1848 introduce?
7. What do Danes mark each year on 5 June?
8. What happened to Dostoevsky after his arrest in 1849?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia